The Indianapolis Colts have already made one big swing at the quarterback reunion game, and now they may be reaching for another. After bringing Philip Rivers back for a year, the team is reportedly eyeing Peyton Manning for a much bigger role: general manager.
The move comes after a season that started with promise and then collapsed in a hurry. Indianapolis was 2-2 entering Week 5 and had even reached No. 1 in the AFC standings at one point in 2025, but Daniel Jones’s injury knocked the whole plan off course. Two straight losses, first to the Pittsburgh Steelers and then to the Tennessee Titans, pushed the Colts to 2-4 and triggered a firing of general manager Chris Ballard.
In announcing the change, team owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon said the Colts’ standard is “to compete for championships,” adding that “a change in leadership is necessary to meet that standard.”
The front office search may be wide open, but one name has reportedly jumped to the front of the line. Dan Patrick, via Evan Sidery on X, reported that Indianapolis is preparing to pursue Manning as its next general manager.
Sidery wrote that “The Colts are planning to pursue Peyton Manning as their next general manager, per @dpshow. Indianapolis is attempting a Hail Mary to bring back their franchise legend to run the show.”
There’s at least some history behind the idea. Six years ago, sources said Manning could eventually run an organization, particularly if he had an ownership stake. If that thinking still holds, the timing could finally line up for the two-time Super Bowl champion.
Brady’s influence in Las Vegas has shown that a former star can have a real voice in team decisions once he’s in the room. Whether Manning wants that path is the big question. His post-playing success with the Manningcast has kept him in the spotlight, and with his son Marshall already playing at a high school level, the situation only adds another layer to the speculation.
For now, it’s just that - speculation. But if the Colts really are serious, Peyton back in Indy would be a storyline that would grab the entire league.
In Other News...
Purdue Fans Have An Unexpected Colts Storyline To Watch Now
The Colts front-office shakeup has put an unexpected Purdue-adjacent storyline on the radar, with Indianapolis moving on from its general manager and now being linked to Peyton Manning in some capacity. For Boilermakers fans, that kind of conversation always carries extra weight, given Mannings place in Indiana sports history and the natural curiosity that follows whenever his name comes up in a Colts discussion.
There was plenty of NFL movement for former Purdue players in Week 6, too, with George Karlaftis making an impact in the Chiefs win and Tyrone Tracy Jr. finding the end zone twice for the Giants in a loss. Some other former Boilermakers were inactive or did not play, but the bigger wait-and-see item may be whether the Colts latest search turns into something far more familiar for fans around West Lafayette. [Read more 🡒]
Barry Odom Has Purdue Fans Debating What Counts As Progress
The bye week arrived with Purdue sitting at 3-4 after the loss to Washington, and theres a real sense that this start has been better than many expected in Barry Odoms first season. The Boilermakers have already shown signs of progress in one area that matters most to a rebuilding team, with Ryan Browne taking a meaningful step forward at quarterback and giving the offense more stability than it had coming into the year.
Still, the conversation around Purdue is not just about records or expectations, because the defense has been a different story and that has left some fans questioning how much of the early improvement is sustainable. Odoms job security looks steady for now, but the scrutiny around defensive coordinator Kevin Kane has grown sharper, and the bye week gives the staff a chance to sort through a unit that has not matched the offenses upward trend. [Read more 🡒]