The 2026 season is shaping up to be a pivotal one for Minnesota Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy.
After a challenging 2025 season marred by performance issues and injuries, McCarthy finds himself at a crossroads. The Vikings missed the playoffs, and there's a growing sense that change is in the air.
Rumors are swirling that the Vikings might bring in a seasoned veteran as a backup plan, or perhaps even a full replacement for McCarthy. Enter Aaron Rodgers, a name that has caught the attention of many, including Sports Illustrated’s Conor Orr, who predicts Rodgers could join the Vikings to compete with McCarthy.
While it’s speculative, Rodgers’ pursuit of passing Peyton Manning on the NFL’s all-time touchdown list could be a motivating factor. For head coach Kevin O’Connell, adding Rodgers could provide much-needed depth and a winning edge after last season's playoff miss. The situation echoes Rodgers' time with the Jets, where expectations were high, but the results were mixed.
The prospect of Rodgers joining the Vikings is intriguing. Minnesota boasts a strong supporting cast, particularly at wide receiver, and a well-rounded roster. If Rodgers could notch 10 wins with the Steelers last season, imagine the possibilities with the Vikings.
However, Rodgers’ future remains uncertain. Retirement is on the table, or he could return to the Steelers, now led by his former coach Mike McCarthy. Yet, the allure of the Vikings, with their solid lineup, might be hard to resist.
If Rodgers were to leave the Steelers, they’d face a quarterback conundrum, lacking a clear starter. Will Howard is unproven, and Mason Rudolph hasn’t secured a starting role. In such a scenario, the Steelers might look to the Vikings for a trade involving McCarthy, who would likely seek a new opportunity if Rodgers signs with Minnesota.
While McCarthy may not be a guaranteed solution for the Steelers, he could offer a glimmer of hope for their future. The unfolding quarterback drama promises to be a captivating storyline as the 2026 season approaches.