The Steelers left Week 10 with a harsh reminder of how thin the margin can be when the pass rush doesn’t show up.
Pittsburgh’s 38-18 loss to Cincinnati was ugly enough on its own, but it also put a spotlight on Alex Highsmith’s season-long slide. The Bengals carved up the defense behind Joe Burrow, who went 35 of 44 for 409 yards and four touchdowns, and the Steelers managed just one sack with no turnovers forced.
That kind of night is bad for the whole unit. For Highsmith, it was another chapter in a frustrating stretch.
For the seventh straight week, Highsmith finished with fewer than 1.0 sack in a game. That’s not the kind of production the Steelers need from one of their veteran edge rushers, especially when the team is leaning on its front four to create chaos.
T.J. Watt had to fight through Amarius Mims all night, but Highsmith had a more favorable matchup and still didn’t make enough noise.
The numbers tell the story clearly. Through nine games, Highsmith has 19 tackles, with only eight of them solo and 11 assisted.
More important for his role, he has only 3.5 sacks and five tackles for loss. That five-tackle-for-loss total ranks 38th among NFL edge rushers with at least one snap, according to SumerSports.
It’s also tied with Patrick Queen for second on the Steelers, which says plenty about where Highsmith’s production has landed so far.
The bigger issue is that he’s not getting to the quarterback fast enough. Highsmith’s average time to pressure is up to 2.62 seconds this season.
He had been a much quicker disruptor in previous years, averaging 2.40 seconds or less in 2022, 2023 and 2024, then 2.56 seconds last year. That extra delay matters in a league where quarterbacks are getting the ball out in a hurry.
Burrow is averaging 2.59 seconds before throwing. Trevor Lawrence is at 2.61.
Patrick Mahomes is at 2.56. Jordan Love is at 2.45 in 2026.
That’s the problem for Pittsburgh. When offenses are operating that quickly, a four-man rush has to win fast. Right now, Highsmith isn’t winning fast enough.
His future in Pittsburgh is also starting to come into focus. Since the Steelers signed Nick Herbig to a new extension, the sense has been that Highsmith’s time with the team is moving toward its end.
A trade is one possibility, especially with the Steelers expected to address their salary cap situation by moving on from at least one or two veteran players in the offseason. Highsmith is 29 and still one of the more complete EDGE rushers in football, even with the down year.
The more likely path, though, is that the Steelers let the contract run its course and Highsmith leaves after the 2027 campaign. Spotrac lists him for a base salary of $15.5 million next year, plus a signing bonus, which brings his cap hit to $21.1 million. That would leave Pittsburgh with three outside linebackers carrying more than $20 million against the cap.
It’s a costly setup, but it’s also the team’s strongest position. That’s why the expectation is that the Steelers will keep Highsmith around rather than force a move and risk losing him for nothing after 2027.
For now, though, the bigger concern is immediate. Pittsburgh needs to recover from the beating it took from Cincinnati, and Highsmith needs to rediscover the form that once made him such a disruptive piece of the defense.
In Other News...
Steelers Still Face One Big Test After That Bengals Loss
The loss to Cincinnati did not knock Pittsburgh off course, but it did sharpen the next stretch of the season into something more revealing. At 6-3, the Steelers still have room to build toward a winning record and a playoff berth, yet the margin for comfort is thinner now with eight games left and a schedule that keeps asking for answers against quality opponents.
What comes next will say plenty about how far this team can go beyond simply getting back to the postseason. Matchups with Baltimore and Philadelphia loom as the kind of tests that can separate a sturdy contender from a team that merely survives the regular season, and Pittsburgh also has to handle the games it is expected to win if it wants to avoid putting itself in a bad spot come January. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Suddenly Have Real Hope On Mason McCormick
Mason McCormicks injury looked grim in the moment against the Cincinnati Bengals, but the early read has given the Steelers a much better sense of what they are dealing with. The rookie lineman suffered a dislocated ankle, and the fact that the injury did not include a fracture changes the outlook considerably for a team trying to hold things together late in the season.
The bigger development is the recovery path, which does not appear to require surgery and leaves at least some room for optimism down the stretch. For Pittsburgh, that means McCormick is not automatically lost for the year, and there is now a real possibility he could be back in the postseason if his rehab goes well. [Read more 🡒]
Cam Heyward Just Stirred Up Lamar Jackson Rivalry Speculation
Cam Heyward has never been shy about talking rivalry football, and this week the Steelers veteran added a little more fuel to the long-running Lamar Jackson conversation. On his podcast, Heyward floated the idea that Jacksons future in Baltimore may not be as settled as it looks on paper, a topic that always gets attention in Pittsburgh given how often the two sides have crossed paths and how much of the AFC North has run through Jacksons presence.
The timing makes the speculation easy to notice. Jackson is under contract through 2027, but there is no extension in place, and Baltimore is working with a new coaching staff, which only adds to the uncertainty around what comes next. For the Steelers, it is another reminder that the rivalrys biggest figure could still be at the center of plenty of noise before anyone knows whether the next chapter stays in Baltimore or takes a different turn. [Read more 🡒]
