The Steelers are heading into 2026 with a Payton Wilson decision that could shape the entire linebacker room.
That’s the reality after a second season that never really took off. Wilson arrived in Pittsburgh as a third-round pick with the kind of profile teams dream on: big frame, rare athleticism, and college tape that made plenty of people believe he should have gone earlier. The knee concerns pushed him down the board, and the Steelers were the team that got the shot.
For a while, it looked like that gamble might pay off. Wilson’s rookie year was encouraging enough to earn him a rotational role, and he flashed enough in limited action to hint at more. By the time his sophomore season arrived, he was the obvious breakout candidate.
Instead, the season went sideways fast. Wilson opened the year as the starter next to Patrick Queen for the first two weeks, but the run defense got gashed.
After that, the Steelers quietly pulled him out of base defense for most of the season. He never really settled in, and the splash plays that had made him such an intriguing prospect just weren’t there.
Now the Steelers are back in a familiar place: trying to figure out whether a linebacker can finally become part of the answer.
The odd part is that the room hasn’t changed much around him. The same linebacker group is coming back, and the same positional coach is still in place. The defensive coordinator is different, but there’s still a lot more continuity than overhaul in that unit.
That makes Wilson’s third year especially important. It’s not just about his own career arc. It affects what Pittsburgh does with the position going forward, especially with Wilson set to want a new deal next summer.
There are really three paths from here. He could keep stalling out and remain a limited piece on defense.
He could take a real leap and force his way into top-line linebacker conversation. Or he could land in the middle, putting together a better season than 2025 without answering enough questions to make the Steelers comfortable.
Only one of those outcomes gives Pittsburgh a clean solution.
If Wilson truly breaks out in 2026, the Steelers can live with the risk that comes with paying for one strong season, the way Zack Baun did a few years back. But if Wilson slips again, the team won’t be in position to extend him, and linebacker becomes a major need all over again. Wilson would fall out of the long-term plan, and Queen is also likely headed for free agency next offseason.
That middle ground might be the most frustrating of all. Wilson could have his best pro season and still leave the Steelers unsure whether he’s worth a new contract. That would leave Pittsburgh entering 2026 with another hole and another round of uncertainty at a spot that has been difficult to stabilize for years.
So the ask is simple, even if the stakes are huge: Wilson doesn’t just need to be better. He needs to break out. If he doesn’t, the Steelers’ linebacker problem isn’t going anywhere.
In Other News...
Steelers Fans Finally Got The Acrisure Update They Wanted
Acrisure Stadium is getting a long-awaited facelift, and this one goes beyond the usual offseason touch-up. The Pittsburgh Sports and Exhibition Authority has approved funding for about 18,000 new seats, with the work set to roll out in phases through 2027. Along with the seating project, the stadium is also slated for concrete repairs, part of a broader push to modernize a building that has drawn plenty of scrutiny in recent years.
The latest seat replacement phase covers the lower level on the east end of the stadium, and the full project is expected to wrap with a third and final phase in 2027. Precision Turf has already installed a new playing surface made of Tahoma 31 Bluegrass, replacing the previous Kentucky bluegrass field, so the Steelers are finally seeing action on both the stands and the field after a stretch of complaints about how the venue looked and played. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Donald Just Entered A New Steelers Storyline
A new Steelers subplot surfaced this week when a video showed Aaron Donald working with Jaquan Brisker on pass-rush techniques. For Pittsburgh, it is the kind of offseason clip that instantly gets attention, especially with Brisker now in the building after signing a one-year deal following three seasons with the Bears.
Brisker gives the Steelers another physical, versatile piece in the secondary, and any extra work from a player with Donalds reputation only adds to the intrigue around his arrival. The bigger question hanging over the moment is what, if anything, it says about Donalds future, even as he has not said he plans to make a comeback. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Fans Just Got A Telling Sign About Drew Allar
For a rookie quarterback, the first real test often comes less in the huddle than in the vocabulary, and Drew Allar appears to be arriving in Pittsburgh with a head start. The Steelers passer said he is already comfortable with West Coast concepts, the kind of foundation that can make the transition to the league a little less overwhelming, and he has also spent time around the newer branches of that offense during his days at Penn State.
There is still plenty for Allar to absorb, but the early signs are encouraging for a team that is always looking for stability behind center. He also sounds eager to learn from Aaron Rodgers, a veteran whose own background in a similar system could make the pairing especially useful as Allar tries to get up to speed and carve out his place in the Steelers quarterback room. [Read more 🡒]