The Steelers’ fast start under Mike McCarthy has Pittsburgh looking like a different team, but it also has reopened an old conversation: what does all of this mean for Mike Tomlin’s legacy?
After a shaky opening stretch, the Steelers have ripped off four straight wins and gone into their Week 9 bye at 6-2, sitting alone in first place in the AFC North. That kind of surge was not the expectation when the organization moved on from Tomlin after his 19-year run at the top.
The early read around the league was that Pittsburgh had downgraded. Instead, the Steelers look energized, and the ceiling in 2026 suddenly feels higher than it has in at least half a decade.
Tomlin’s résumé was never in doubt when it came to regular-season consistency. He never posted a losing season in Pittsburgh. But the McCarthy era is off to a stronger start than most people expected, and that has naturally sparked debate about whether the new regime’s success somehow reflects poorly on what came before it.
The short answer: it shouldn’t.
Tomlin has long been praised as one of the NFL’s sharpest defensive minds, but in recent years that side of the ball did not always match the talent on the roster. In 2025, Pittsburgh’s defense ranked seventh-worst in yards allowed at 356.9 per game and 16th in points allowed at 22.8.
This season under defensive coordinator Patrick Graham, the numbers have swung hard in the other direction. The Steelers are allowing 305.6 yards per game, sixth-fewest in the league, and 18.0 points per game, third-fewest.
If that pace holds, it would be Pittsburgh’s best yards-allowed mark since 2019 and its best points-allowed figure since 2011.
That matters because the defensive core is mostly the same in 2026 as it was in 2025, with cornerback the biggest exception. The Steelers have arguably taken a step back there after trading Joey Porter Jr. to the Dallas Cowboys. So the turnaround looks less like a roster overhaul and more like a new voice getting more out of the same group.
And that’s really the heart of the story. For years, it felt like both sides needed a reset. The Steelers had dropped seven straight playoff games under Tomlin, and the whole thing seemed stuck.
McCarthy and his staff have already brought in a wave of changes, and early returns are encouraging. Whether that lasts through the rest of the season and beyond is still to be determined, but the hire has clearly worked so far.
None of that erases what Tomlin built in Pittsburgh. He remains a future Hall of Famer, the coach who delivered a Super Bowl title in 2008 and kept the Steelers in the playoff mix year after year for nearly two decades.
He raised the floor and the ceiling of the franchise. That part of his legacy does not disappear because the next coach gets off to a strong start.
Even if McCarthy ends up winning a Lombardi Trophy or developing Pittsburgh’s next franchise quarterback, it should not change how Tomlin’s time with the Steelers is remembered.
In Other News...
Steelers Debate Just Got Louder Around Aaron Rodgers And The Deadline
The Steelers have spent much of the season looking like a team with real playoff ambitions, and former offensive coordinator Todd Haley thinks the roster is close enough to justify a more aggressive push. His view is simple: Pittsburgh has the kind of foundation that can matter in January, but it still needs another offensive playmaker to make the whole operation more dangerous, especially with Aaron Rodgers in place to steer the offense.
Haley also took aim at the clubs quiet approach at the NFL trade deadline, pointing to the Jacksonville Jaguars as an example of a team willing to act decisively to strengthen its roster. For Pittsburgh, the debate now is less about whether it can contend and more about whether it did enough to help Rodgers and the offense make a deeper postseason run. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Are Earning Real Respect With Bengals Test Looming
The Steelers spent their bye week in a good place, riding four straight wins into first place in the AFC North and drawing a noticeable bump in national respect along the way. Across a handful of NFL media power rankings, Pittsburgh landed anywhere from No. 7 to No. 13, a range that reflects both the strength of its defense and the sense that this team has earned a real seat at the table.
Pittsburgh also managed to hold steady through the week off, with no outlet dropping the Steelers in its rankings as the attention shifts to Sunday Night Football against the Bengals. It is the kind of matchup that can say plenty about where the Steelers really stand, especially with a division rival waiting and the stakes rising fast in the race at the top of the AFC North. [Read more 🡒]
T.J. Watt Has Steelers Defense Looking Dangerous Again
T.J. Watt has put himself right back at the center of the Steelers defensive conversation, and it is easy to see why. Several Pittsburgh analysts have already pegged him as the teams midseason Defensive Player of the Year, pointing to his relentless pressure off the edge and the way he keeps changing games even when he is not finishing every play himself. Under coordinator Patrick Graham, the defense has started to look more like the unit Pittsburgh expects, and Watt has been a major reason for that turn.
He has not been doing it alone, either. Cam Heyward has remained a steady force up front, Keeanu Benton has added another layer inside, and Jalen Ramsey has given the secondary a more dangerous feel. Still, Watt is the one setting the tone, and the bigger question for the Steelers is how high this defense can climb if he keeps driving it the way he has so far. [Read more 🡒]