The New York Giants have already had enough quarterback chaos for one season, and the latest name to get tossed into the mix is one they should keep far away from: Aaron Rodgers.
With Jaxson Dart done for the year because of a knee injury, the speculation machine has spun up fast. Colin Kaepernick, Tua Tagovailoa and Shedeur Sanders have all been floated as possible answers, at least in somebody’s imagination. Now Rodgers has entered the conversation, with Ryan Pawloski of Still Curtain, FanSided’s Pittsburgh Steelers site, suggesting the Steelers could send the 42-year-old to East Rutherford if their season goes off the rails.
The idea is simple enough on paper. Rodgers would give the Giants a veteran stopgap, offer them a chance to stay afloat in John Harbaugh’s first season in charge, and give the quarterback a meaningful final season while Pittsburgh resets. But that’s where the appeal ends.
Giants general manager Joe Schoen should not even think about making that move.
There’s only one real reason to trade for a 42-year-old quarterback who has already said this is his final season: he has to give you a legitimate shot at winning a Super Bowl. Rodgers is nowhere near that level right now.
The numbers are brutal. Among the 29 quarterbacks with at least 50 dropbacks this season, Rodgers is last in EPA per play, last in success rate and 28th in yards per attempt. By those measures, he has been the worst starting quarterback in the NFL.
And the way he’s playing is dragging everything down around him. Rodgers is still operating from static, easy-to-read formations and getting the ball out quickly, and the Steelers have not been able to move the ball consistently because of it.
Pawloski’s scenario also depends on Pittsburgh reaching a point where it’s willing to bail out. That would only happen if the season truly tanked, and even then, the Steelers have spent the last decade showing they’re reluctant to admit defeat.
The cost might not even be steep. A seventh-round pick, or maybe just a late-round pick swap, could be enough to get a deal done.
But cheap doesn’t make it sensible. If the Steelers are bad enough to move Rodgers, that would mean he hasn’t rebounded.
So why would the Giants hand over even a modest asset for a 42-year-old quarterback who has been one of the worst in the league?
In Other News...
Joey Porter Jr. Just Sparked A Steelers Debate He Can't Win
Joey Porter Jr. has only been in the league a short time, but he already knows what comes with a Steelers-Bengals week: every comment gets measured against the tape. After recent remarks suggesting he has never really had trouble with Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins, the discussion around his matchup work has only grown louder, because Pittsburgh fans know Cincinnatis top receivers have been central figures in this rivalry for years.
The numbers behind those games paint a more complicated picture for Porter and the Steelers. Across the past three seasons, Chase and Higgins have consistently found production when Porter has been on the field, while his own coverage grades against Cincinnati have bounced around from game to game. It leaves Porter in a familiar spot for a young corner in a division that never lets anyone off the hook: the debate is already bigger than the quote, and the next meeting is the only place he can really settle it. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Suddenly Have A Guard Problem Before Bengals Week
The Steelers found themselves sorting through a new interior line concern this week as rookie guard Gennings Dunker popped up on the injury report with a knee issue ahead of Week 3. Spencer Anderson is still working through a bone break in his leg, though he has been able to practice fully this week, leaving Pittsburgh with a thinner-than-expected group at a spot that usually needs steady rotation and depth.
For now, Brock Hoffman is the only fully healthy guard on the roster, which makes the upcoming matchup with Cincinnati a little more complicated than the Steelers likely wanted. Even with Anderson on the field, the groups availability is suddenly a real storyline heading into a divisional game, and Pittsburgh will be watching closely to see how much it can trust its interior options when the game plan starts to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Backfield Decision Just Got A Lot More Serious Before Bengals
The Steelers backfield picture got a little murkier this week with Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle both limited or missing practice because of injuries, leaving Pittsburgh with fewer clean answers as it prepares for Cincinnati. It is the kind of late-week development that can change how an offense is built, especially when the running game already has to absorb the ripple effects of a crowded injury report.
Pittsburgh has other players showing up as limited or absent, but the running back situation is the one demanding the most attention heading into the Bengals game. Depending on Dowdles availability, the Steelers may need to turn to the practice squad to add depth at the position, which would make Fridays final injury updates especially important. [Read more 🡒]