The Steelers opened preseason with a 28-9 win over the Packers, and the box score only told part of the story. Pittsburgh came out looking organized and sharp, even if the night still had enough messiness to remind everyone it was August football. The positive list was longer than the negative one, and a handful of players clearly helped their cases.
One of the clearest boosts went to Kaden Wetjen. His work in camp had been easy to overlook because the return units weren’t getting much full-speed action, and no one is expecting a major offensive workload from the rookie.
But he made noise against Green Bay anyway. Wetjen broke off a long catch-and-run and later added a short touchdown reception, giving the offense a spark even if his returns themselves weren’t especially eye-popping.
He still profiles first as a returner, but there’s something there to keep exploring on offense.
Will Howard also helped himself. It wasn’t the kind of performance that steals headlines away from everyone else, but it was a solid first NFL showing.
He looked composed, threw accurately, and kept the offense moving when he got his chances. That kind of clean, efficient outing matters for a young quarterback trying to carve out a role, and Howard now looks like someone who could be trusted as the backup this season.
Robert Tonyan added another steady performance to the mix. He’s no longer the player he once was, but he still looks like a dependable outlet for the passing game.
Tonyan found space, caught the ball cleanly, and gave the offense a veteran target who can keep drives alive. He doesn’t need a huge role to matter, and after this game he looks extremely secure.
Germie Bernard was another bright spot after a quiet camp. The second-round pick had been easy to miss up to this point, but he showed up when the lights came on.
Bernard ran crisp routes, settled into open spots in coverage, and made things happen after the catch. The receiver room needed exactly that kind of skill set, and he may become a quarterback favorite sooner rather than later.
Lew Nichols also made a strong case. He has been one of those easy-to-forget names in the running back group, but he kept showing the same kind of burst he flashed last preseason.
Nichols ran with force, found holes quickly, and stayed upright through contact. He was also the first true running back to get snaps in the game, with Travis Homer getting some early work before Nichols provided the first real spark on the ground.
At minimum, he looks like the leading candidate for a practice squad spot.
Asante Samuel Jr. kept building on the momentum he had already created in practice. He looked fully recovered from the injury he dealt with a few years ago and continued what has been a strong camp.
At this point, it’s getting hard to imagine keeping him off the field. Jamel Dean still has to prove he is worth his contract, and Samuel is pressing him hard.
The Steelers also had a few things go sideways. Penalties were a real issue, and the game got sloppy fast.
There were mistakes sprinkled everywhere, and special teams was especially rough in that department. In a regular-season setting, those kinds of errors would have been costly, so it’s something that needs to get cleaned up before the next preseason game.
Dylan Cook had a rough night on the right side of the line. He got plenty of work, but the results weren’t encouraging.
The expectations for him are not the same as they would be for a proven starter, yet he still didn’t look as steady as he did last year when filling in for Broderick Jones. With Max Iheanachor not playing, the gap between the two may be closer than it looked before.
Troy Fautanu also came away with more questions than answers. His first outing at left tackle was uneven, and he was beaten off the edge too often.
Mason Rudolph’s pocket presence didn’t help matters, but that wasn’t enough to excuse the former first-round pick. If this is just about getting comfortable again on the left side, the turnaround needs to come quickly.
And then there was Kaleb Johnson, who had the roughest night of the group. He got only two carries, and even with the starters sitting and Travis Homer leaving early, Johnson barely saw the field.
When he did get touches, he wasn’t effective. Nichols has moved ahead of him, and the team seemed more interested in giving Eli Heidenreich a look than in feeding Johnson.
At this point, it looks like a matter of when, not if, Johnson gets cut or traded this offseason.
There was also a note on Drew Allar, who looked like a star in the game. He was working against the bottom end of the roster, but he wasn’t surrounded by elite talent either.
What stood out most was his accuracy, especially considering that was something he struggled with in school. Howard is pushing for the backup job, but Allar is showing real potential to develop into something.
The talent is obvious, and the coaching staff appears to be making good progress with him.
In Other News...
Drew Allar Just Gave Steelers Fans A Reason To Dream
Drew Allars first turn in a Steelers uniform gave the team something it can always use in August: a little hope. In a preseason game against the Green Bay Packers, the third-round pick looked poised and accurate, handling the moment like a quarterback who understood he was more than a long-term project. Even with some footwork issues showing up, Allar kept the offense moving and gave Pittsburgh a cleaner, calmer look than teams usually expect from a young passer in his debut.
The performance stood out because it came with real production, not just tidy mechanics. Allar helped lead three touchdown drives and made his case in a way that should at least get the conversation started about what kind of ceiling he might have in this system. The questions now are less about whether the arm talent is there and more about how quickly the rest of his game can catch up, which is exactly the kind of development a team wants to monitor closely in the weeks ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Will Howard Just Gave Steelers Fans A Real Backup QB Reason To Watch
After missing his rookie season with a fractured thumb, Will Howard finally got his first NFL action for the Steelers against the Packers and made it look like a meaningful first step rather than a ceremonial one. He completed 7 of 9 passes for 86 yards, took a sack and helped move Pittsburgh with poise in a game situation that mattered for a backup quarterback trying to prove he belongs.
Howard also showed enough late to give the Steelers something to think about behind the starter. His first NFL hit seemed to settle him in, and he helped guide an 80-yard drive in the two-minute drill, a stretch that gave Pittsburgh a real glimpse of what the rookie can do when the pace speeds up and the pressure starts to climb. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Rookie Is Already Pushing His Way Into A Key Role
Germie Bernard wasted little time making a case for himself in Pittsburghs first preseason game, giving the Steelers some early energy against Green Bay with a first-half showing that stood out for more than just volume. The rookie wide receiver and second-round pick hauled in four passes for 51 yards, and much of the appeal came after the catch, where he showed the kind of movement and toughness that can help a young receiver earn trust quickly.
For a Steelers offense looking for answers behind its top targets, that matters. Bernard already looks like a real contender for the WR3 job, but Aaron Rodgers also pointed to the obvious next step, saying the rookie still has to get sharper with the playbook and the speed of his execution. For now, Bernard has given Pittsburgh something worth watching as camp rolls on. [Read more 🡒]