The Steelers are sitting at 2-2, and that record tells only part of the story. Through four weeks, Pittsburgh has been a team of swings - some encouraging, some messy - and the rookie class has followed that same pattern.
A few young players are starting to carve out real roles. Others are still waiting for their first real chance.
The biggest thing to know is that the rookie group has become more visible as injuries and underwhelming play have forced the Steelers to lean deeper into the roster. That has created a mixed bag, with one late-round pick after another either flashing, fading, or barely getting on the field.
For Drew Allar, Gennings Dunker, Gabriel Rubio, Eli Heidenreich, and Kevin Jobity Jr., there really hasn’t been much movement. Eli Heidenrich has been active, but his impact has been limited to 21 total snaps on offense and special teams.
Dunker went to IR with an injury, and even if he were healthy, he would be a weekly inactive because of the depth at guard. Allar still hasn’t dressed for a game.
Rubio and Jobity are the two names to watch next, especially now that Derrick Harmon is injured. With the way Pittsburgh rotates defensive linemen, whoever gets the nod should have a chance to play real snaps.
Verdict: Stock even
Max Iheanachor’s first month has already shown how quickly things can change for a rookie lineman. He didn’t exactly win the right tackle job outright, but circumstances pushed him into the lineup anyway, with Dylan Cook losing his spot and Brock Hoffman needing to join the starting five because Spencer Anderson had been struggling.
Iheanachor’s first start against the Bengals was a clear bright spot. The offense looked sharper, and the run game opened up.
Then came Cleveland, where the Browns got a little film on him and exposed some of the rookie growing pains. He allowed two sacks, and the difference showed up in the grades too - an 81.3 from PFF in his debut, followed by a 56 the next time out.
The talent is there, but if he wants to keep the job from Cook, he has to string together better games.
Verdict: Stock shot up, but has come right back down
Germie Bernard has been mostly defined by one drive so far, but it was enough to hint at something more. Against the Patriots, he caught four passes for 35 yards on a drive that gave the offense a spark.
With Michael Pittman back in the lineup, Bernard hasn’t had many chances, but the veteran hasn’t been especially effective either. That could open the door a little wider for Bernard to steal touches if the trend continues.
The Steelers have already seen a glimpse of what he can do. Now he needs a real run of opportunities.
Verdict: Stock up, slightly
Daylen Everette has gone from promising camp buzz to being thrown straight into the fire. The rookie third-round pick was supposed to need time before becoming a steady defensive piece, but he impressed in camp and the preseason, got opportunities early with Joey Porter holding out, and even got the nod over Asante Samuel at the end of the Bengals game.
Then came his first extended start against the Browns, and it was rough. Coverage issues and a near-costly penalty made it a tough day for the former Georgia cornerback.
The early read on him may have been right after all: he needs development time. The problem is that the Steelers may not be able to wait, especially with Porter traded to the Cowboys.
Kaden Wetjen was drafted to help the return game, and that expectation hasn’t been met yet. A fourth-round pick at return specialist comes with a pretty clear job description, but the production hasn’t followed.
He has been more direct as a runner, which is a positive, but the returns themselves haven’t popped. His 22.6-yard-per-kick return average and 9.9-yard-per-punt average are both below average, and he still hasn’t delivered a long return.
At least he hasn’t put the ball on the ground, though that feels more like the bare minimum than a real selling point.
Riley Nowakowski has been a little quieter than many probably expected. The fifth-round pick has only 15 offensive snaps and still hasn’t logged a catch or a rush.
The offense hasn’t really been in a spot to lean on a fullback, and he hasn’t seen much action as a reserve tight end either. Still, he has been useful on special teams, where he’s played 61 percent of the snaps.
That gives him a role, and if the Steelers ever build a comfortable lead, his offensive usage could rise. For now, there’s no need to panic.
Verdict: Stock even
Robert Spears-Jennings has been one of the most encouraging rookie stories so far. The Steelers’ final pick has already made an impression on special teams and defense.
On coverage units, he has done exactly what you want from a safety with his athleticism - getting downfield fast and piling up tackles. The bigger surprise came on defense against the Browns, where he was called into action and delivered, highlighted by a key interception and a 78.6 PFF grade.
He may already have jumped Rayshawn Jenkins, and even if he settles back into depth once the safety room gets healthy, he has shown enough to matter. When a late pick gives you this much on special teams and can hold up on defense too, that’s a win.
In Other News...
Steelers Fans May See Joey Porter Jr. Trade Very Differently Now
The Cowboys acquisition of Joey Porter Jr. came with the usual instant questions about what comes next, but the early read on his approach may ease some of that anxiety. Rather than pushing immediately for a new deal, Porter is reportedly willing to play out his current contract, which gives Dallas some breathing room as it sorts through the longer-term picture around one of its newest defensive additions.
For Steelers fans, that detail may change the way the move is viewed from afar. Porters market value is estimated at around $27.4 million per year, so the price tag is still substantial, but the bigger issue now appears to be how much security and how many years the Cowboys want to offer when the time comes. The contract conversation is not going away, but the early signs suggest this may be more about fit and timing than any urgent showdown over money. [Read more 🡒]
Missing Steelers Fan Case In Cleveland Just Took A Disturbing Turn
A trip to Cleveland for a football game has turned into a search that now carries real weight. Phoenix Phillips, a 24-year-old from Maryland, was last seen downtown after attending the game, and police have said his disappearance is concerning. His phone was found, adding to the unease around a case that has quickly moved beyond a simple missing-person report.
Authorities have also recovered an unidentified body near the area where Phillips was last known to be, though they have not confirmed any connection. The investigation remains active, and online chatter has added another layer of noise around Phillips, with unverified allegations tying him to unauthorized trading and scamming. For now, though, the only thing that matters is the unanswered question of what happened after he left the game. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers LB Cole Holcomb Shares A Feel Good Life Update
For a Steelers defense still trying to settle in through a 2-2 start, Cole Holcomb has had a more personal milestone to celebrate away from the field. Holcomb and his wife, Casey, welcomed their second child this week, a baby boy named Drew Jarrett, or DJ, adding a bright spot to a season that has already had its share of on-field grind for the veteran inside linebacker.
Holcomb has continued to be part of Pittsburghs mix in the middle of the defense, even as the early weeks have brought a little bit of everything, including an NFL fine for a blindside block on a special teams play in Week 3. The newborn news, though, is the kind of update that can reset a players week in a hurry, and it gives Holcomb and his family a memorable moment as the Steelers move deeper into the season. [Read more 🡒]