Steelers QB Future Is Suddenly Looking A Lot More Like Drew Allar

Steelers fans may see a new face at quarterback as Drew Allar emerges as a promising candidate for the starting role in the 2027 NFL season.

The Steelers may have their next quarterback already in the building, and one insider is saying the quiet part out loud.

Pittsburgh used the 76th overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft on Drew Allar out of Penn State, a move that caught some people off guard. Aaron Rodgers was expected back with the team, even though he had not officially signed when the Steelers made the pick. Pittsburgh had also already brought back Mason Rudolph and drafted Will Howard in the fifth round the year before.

Still, the picture for 2027 is starting to tilt toward Allar.

Mark Kaboly of The Pat McAfee Show said on X that he thinks Allar’s odds of opening the 2027 season as the Steelers’ starter are stronger than most people realize.

“At this moment, I would say that Drew Allar has an 87.9% chance of being the Steelers’ starting quarterback in Week 1 of 2027,” Kaboly said on his X account.

Allar’s preseason work gave that idea some fuel. In three appearances, he completed 30 of 54 passes for 351 yards and threw two touchdowns. The most encouraging part of that stretch was his ball security, along with visible improvement in his footwork.

The roster situation also points in his direction. Rodgers retired after the season, and Rudolph is on an expiring contract. That leaves Allar and Howard as the only quarterbacks under contract for 2027.

And with the Steelers sitting firmly in playoff position, the chances of them chasing a top quarterback in what is described as a weird 2027 quarterback draft class look slim.

Because Mike McCarthy picked Allar himself, and because of the way the rookie has looked so far, insiders are beginning to think the Steelers could have their answer for Week 1 of 2027 already lined up at quarterback.

In Other News...

Joey Porter Jr Is Making Steelers Secondary Questions Even Harder

Since Joey Porter Jr. was traded away, the Steelers have had to live with the ripple effect on the back end, and the contrast has only gotten sharper as the season has gone on. Porter has settled in quickly with the Cowboys, where he has been a steady presence in coverage despite their broader defensive issues, allowing only three catches for 19 yards on 12 targets in his first five games there.

For Pittsburgh, the problem is not just what Porter is doing elsewhere, but how much his departure has exposed a hole in the secondary. Asante Samuel Jr. has struggled to hold up on the outside, giving up significant yardage and touchdowns, and that kind of production makes the missed opportunity even harder to ignore as the Steelers try to sort out a defense that no longer looks as sturdy at corner. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Quarterback Contracts Reveal What Pittsburgh Is Really Betting On

The Steelers have quietly built some flexibility into their quarterback plans by attaching 2026 incentives to both Aaron Rodgers and Mason Rudolph, a sign that Pittsburgh is keeping its options open beyond the immediate season. Rodgers can add up to $2.5 million through playoff wins and playing time, while Rudolphs path to extra money is tied to reaching at least half of the offensive snaps and helping the team get into the postseason.

Rudolphs contract situation makes the arrangement especially interesting because he is scheduled to hit free agency after the 2026 season. If Pittsburgh likes how things unfold, there is at least a plausible path to bring him back and let him compete for the starting job in 2027, which says plenty about how the Steelers are trying to balance short-term stability with a longer view at the position. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Suddenly Have A Nick Herbig Problem Before Eagles Game

Nick Herbigs status has become a real storyline for Pittsburgh as the Steelers get ready for a tough Week 11 trip to Philadelphia. The second-year edge rusher was listed as a non-participant in practice because of a hip and ribs injury, an issue he picked up in the Week 10 win over Cincinnati before still managing to finish the game.

The timing is less than ideal with the Eagles waiting next on the schedule, and Pittsburgh now has to sort out its pass-rush rotation without knowing whether Herbig will be available. For a defense that leans on pressure off the edge, his practice absence adds another layer of uncertainty as the Steelers head into one of their biggest tests of the season. [Read more 🡒]