The Steelers open the season at Acrisure Stadium with a Falcons team that arrives short-handed in a few major spots, and most of the Week 1 staff sees that as enough to tilt the matchup toward Pittsburgh. Atlanta is down its top two edge rushers and is set to start its third quarterback, a combination that has the panel leaning toward a Steelers win even with plenty of questions still hanging over the home team.
There is still no shortage of uncertainty around Pittsburgh. The offense barely showed itself in the summer, the line looked like it was still working through issues, and the secondary enters the opener with concerns of its own.
Joey Porter Jr. has not fully participated in a practice in several months, and the defense is already missing a starting safety. Still, the general feeling among the picks is that the Steelers have enough to handle a Falcons roster that is missing key pieces.
Joey Bray expects Pittsburgh to get by with a narrow win, saying, “The Pittsburgh Steelers begin the Mike McCarthy era at Acrisure Stadium against the already hampered Atlanta Falcons. After an oblique injury to Falcons “starter” Tua Tagovailoa in practice on Thursday, it will be Cooper Rush taking the field for Atlanta.
Stopping Bijan Robinson is much easier said than done, and there will likely be some growing pains for the Pittsburgh secondary which is already down a starting safety, and their star corner in Joey Porter Jr. has not fully participated in a practice in several months.
At the end of the day, this is a game that the Steelers should win. I’ll bank on Aaron Rodgers and the offense to get enough going to hold off whoever the Falcons have playing QB and get to 1-0 on the season. Steelers 24, Falcons 20”
Ryan Parish also sees a win, though not a clean one. He pointed to the lack of summer reps for the first-team offense, concerns about the offensive line, and lingering issues on the defensive side, especially against the run. Even so, he called Atlanta’s quarterback situation and missing pass rushers enough of a mismatch for Pittsburgh to survive a sloppy opener, picking Steelers 23, Falcons 16.
Ryland Bickley’s read was similar. He acknowledged that Atlanta has some pieces and what should be a competent coaching staff in 2026, but said it is tough to expect much from a team starting Cooper Rush and missing its top two pass rushers.
He also noted Pittsburgh’s own preseason rust, adding that he expects the Steelers to win without much style. His pick: Steelers 20, Falcons 13.
Mike Nicastro wasn’t expecting fireworks from Pittsburgh either. He said the Falcons are battered and bruised, but he still doesn’t think the Steelers will come out “guns blazing.”
He cited the lack of preseason reps for DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman Jr., along with an offensive line that is “less than inspiring.” Even so, he sees the Steelers’ pass rush as the difference against “a statue in Cooper Rush,” predicting sacks and forced fumbles from Nick Herbig and Alex Highsmith, plus a second-half offensive surge led by Pat Freiermuth.
His pick: Steelers 23, Falcons 16.
Jason Aponte was the most lopsided in favor of Pittsburgh, saying it does not matter who starts at quarterback for Atlanta and calling for the Steelers to roll to an easy victory to begin the Mike McCarthy era in Pittsburgh. He picked Steelers 27, Falcons 10.
Jarrett Bailey also wanted a convincing finish. He said he is “not going to pick this game scared,” argued that the Falcons are on their third quarterback and lack the talent Pittsburgh has, and said a close game would be a disappointment. His pick: Steelers 27, Falcons 9.
In Other News...
Mike Tomlin Just Reopened One Painful Steelers Debate
Mike Tomlin has put a fresh spotlight on one of the franchises long-running debates, saying in a recent interview that the best team he ever coached in Pittsburgh was the 2015 Steelers rather than the Super Bowl-winning group from 2008. It is the kind of comparison that tends to stir up old arguments fast, because the 2008 squad has the ring and the legacy, while the 2015 team was built with a different kind of firepower and expectation.
The 2015 Steelers went 10-6, survived a wild card playoff game and then ran into Denver in the divisional round. Tomlin pointed to the talent on that roster and the injury issues that left them short-handed in the postseason loss, which only adds another layer to the what-if conversation around a team that was good enough to make people wonder how far it really could have gone. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Suddenly Have A Week 1 Cornerback Problem To Watch
The Steelers had to make a little extra room in the secondary heading into Week 1, elevating cornerback Doneiko Slaughter from the practice squad before Sundays game against the Falcons. Its a depth move with obvious meaning: Joey Porter Jr. is questionable because of a back injury, and Pittsburgh is giving itself another option in case the spot opposite the rest of the cornerback group needs to be filled on short notice.
Slaughter has not appeared in a regular-season game yet, but he did see significant preseason action, which at least gave the coaching staff a chance to evaluate him in something closer to game conditions. For a team already trying to sort out its opening-week lineup, the question now is less about whether Slaughter can dress and more about how much the Steelers might need him right away. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Rodgers Just Created Another Steelers Headache Off The Field
Aaron Rodgers has already given the Steelers plenty to sort through on the field, but his latest public comments have turned into an awkward off-field distraction too. On Cam Heywards podcast, Rodgers revisited his past engagement to Shailene Woodley and offered his version of how the relationship unraveled, adding another layer to a breakup that had largely stayed private since it ended.
The reaction has only widened the gap between the two sides, with Woodleys friends pushing back on his account and describing the remarks as out of line with the person they knew. For Pittsburgh, it is the kind of headline that has little to do with game plans and everything to do with the attention that follows Rodgers wherever he goes, even when the conversation is supposed to be about football. [Read more 🡒]