Mike McCarthy saw the problem before it blew up on Sunday. He just didn’t pull the plug in time.
The Steelers went into their 20-3 loss to the New England Patriots carrying too much on offense, and McCarthy knew it. He felt it during practice on Wednesday and Thursday, left the full plan in place anyway, and watched the whole thing unravel when the lights came on.
After the game, McCarthy owned it. Aaron Rodgers didn’t let him stand there alone.
Both men had a point. Pittsburgh’s offensive plan was too ambitious, and the execution didn’t come close to rescuing it.
The numbers tell the story in a hurry. The Steelers managed only 235 total yards, went 2-for-12 on third down, gave up four sacks for 43 yards, and lost a strip-sack for a touchdown.
Meanwhile, the defense did its job: New England’s offense was held to 13 points, Pittsburgh forced two turnovers, and the Steelers recorded three sacks. That’s how a winnable game gets wasted.
And this wasn’t exactly a surprise. The offense already looked shaky in Week 1, when Pittsburgh scored one offensive touchdown and finished 3-for-13 on third down. The Patriots took those same problems and stretched them into a 17-point loss.
McCarthy said he should have simplified sooner.
“I felt it on Wednesday and Thursday. I am a veteran coach. I know better,”
McCarthy said. “I didn’t do a good job.”
Coach McCarthy spoke to the media. @Acrisure pic.twitter.com/iokAxjzoIE
- Pittsburgh Steelers (@steelers) September 20, 2026
That honesty matters. The timing didn’t. McCarthy could see the plan was getting too heavy for his players in practice, but he still carried it into the game without trimming it down.
A smaller offensive package would mean fewer formations, fewer personnel looks, fewer protection checks, fewer motions, and fewer route tweaks. In theory, that should mean more reps on the things that remain, quicker tempo out of the huddle, and less thinking at the line.
But the Steelers’ breakdown wasn’t about false starts or delay penalties. The damage came after the snap. Two strip-sacks changed the game, including one on an all-out blitz that turned into a fourth-and-43, and Christian Barmore’s fourth-quarter strip-sack that became New England’s clinching touchdown.
McCarthy said the Steelers expected the pressure. They just didn’t handle it.
“I’ve seen Mike for 14 years, so Mike is going to take accountability,” Rodgers said after the game. “Sometimes when it’s not his fault, he doesn’t need to do that.”
Rodgers also put the responsibility back on himself and the rest of the offense. He said his play wasn’t good enough and acknowledged that it’s his job to tell McCarthy which calls are working.
Rodgers can digest a thick play sheet, and he knows McCarthy’s terminology from their years together in Green Bay. The rest of the offense doesn’t have that advantage. Rodgers might have the right answer, but it won’t help if the center, guard, and running back aren’t seeing the same pressure.
Even so, simpler doesn’t automatically mean safer. Cutting down the playbook won’t fix anything if the protection still falls apart. Pittsburgh still has to be aggressive, just with a tighter package and cleaner answers when the heat comes.
That has to happen quickly, because the schedule is about to turn into a test. The Bengals come to Pittsburgh next, and then the Steelers head to Cleveland four days later. Cincinnati has every reason to keep sending pressure until Pittsburgh proves it can stop it, and the Browns will try the same thing.
In Other News...
Steelers Suddenly Have A Trade Decision Giants Fans Just Created
Jaxson Darts knee injury has added a fresh layer of uncertainty to the Giants quarterback situation, and that ripple effect reaches all the way to Pittsburgh. The Steelers are carrying four quarterbacks on their active roster, which gives them more flexibility than most teams at the position and puts Mason Rudolph back into the conversation as a possible trade chip if another club decides it needs help.
For the Steelers, the question is whether keeping Rudolph provides more value as insurance or whether this is the kind of moment to turn a surplus into future draft capital. The Giants, facing an uncertain timeline for Darts return, are the most obvious club to watch, with speculation already linking them to Rudolph as a depth answer and a possible offer centered on a conditional 2027 sixth-round pick. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Catch A Break As Bengals Passing Game Takes Early Hit
The Bengals passing game took an early hit this week when Andrei Iosivas landed on injured reserve after tearing a ligament in his thumb and undergoing surgery. Cincinnati has not given a firm return date, but the projected absence of four to six weeks trims another option from a receiver group that was already facing the challenge of adjusting on the fly.
For the Steelers, it is the kind of development that matters even before the first meaningful divisional head-to-head meeting. Zac Taylor said other players will get chances to step into the void, but any early-season reshuffling in Cincinnati only adds another layer of uncertainty to a matchup Pittsburgh is already going to be tracking closely. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Rookie Is Making Himself Hard To Ignore Early
Robert Spears-Jennings has already found a way to stand out for the Steelers, even with his role mostly coming on special teams. Through the first two weeks of the 2026 season, the rookie safety leads the league with seven special teams tackles, a strong early sign that he is quickly earning trust in Pittsburgh where every hidden-yardage play tends to matter.
Special teams coach Danny Crossman has taken notice of Spears-Jennings effort and impact, even with limited defensive snaps, and he has also had reason to mention running back Eli Heidenreich after a 26-yard kick return against the Patriots. For a Steelers team always looking for young players who can carve out value in any phase, those kinds of contributions can turn into real opportunities before long. [Read more 🡒]