The Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves in a bit of a quarterback conundrum as they await a decision from four-time MVP Aaron Rodgers. With Mason Rudolph and Will Howard already on the roster for the 2026 season, the team might pivot to Howard if Rodgers chooses retirement or another team.
Steelers fans are intrigued by the prospect of Howard stepping up, but questions linger about his long-term fit with the franchise. Drafting a top-tier quarterback next month seems unlikely, yet General Manager Omar Khan is on the lookout for a hidden gem.
Enter the 2026 NFL Draft, where Fernando Mendoza is the standout quarterback expected to be the first overall pick. Ty Simpson is another name floating around the early rounds, though his buzz has cooled. If the Steelers decide to draft a quarterback, it’ll likely be a mid-to-late-round pick, with Carson Beck and Cole Payton catching their eye.
Payton, hailing from North Dakota State University, is a particularly intriguing prospect. His quarterback coach, Jake Heaps, emphasized Payton's potential during his Pro Day, suggesting that NFL insiders are well aware of his talent.
"The NFL knows about Cole Payton," Heaps remarked. "Don’t be surprised on Day 2 when he’s selected."
Payton might be flying under the media radar, but his stock could rise come draft day. The Steelers have shown keen interest, having met with him at the NFL Combine. Payton mentioned he’s headed to Pittsburgh for a private workout and meetings with the team’s brass.
NFL Draft expert Todd McShay also supports Heaps’ confidence, ranking Payton as the third-best quarterback in the draft, indicating a likely Day 2 selection. The Steelers are doing their due diligence on Payton, and he could be a fascinating addition to the team.
There’s a connection between Payton and the Steelers through Heaps, who became a full-time quarterback trainer while working with Russell Wilson in 2022. During Wilson's time with the Steelers in 2024, Heaps likely crossed paths with Tom Arth, the team's quarterbacks coach. Arth remains with the Steelers, possibly advocating for Payton.
With four picks on Day 2, the Steelers might just use one of those third-round selections to bring Payton to Pittsburgh. The Black and Gold are clearly exploring all options as they navigate their quarterback future.