Steelers Just Reopened A Playoff Fear Fans Know Too Well

Joe Burrow's dominant performance shines a light on the Pittsburgh Steelers' ongoing struggle against elite teams, casting doubt on their playoff potential.

Joe Burrow and the Bengals didn’t just beat the Steelers on Sunday Night Football. They put the whole Pittsburgh operation under a bright, ugly spotlight.

The 38-18 loss in Cincinnati looked like more than a bad night for the Black and Gold. It looked like the same old problem showing up again: Pittsburgh can handle the teams it’s supposed to handle, but when the opponent is a real playoff-caliber threat, the cracks get wide fast.

That’s been the story for a while now, and this latest beatdown only sharpened it. The Steelers were expected to get some kind of lift from the change from Mike Tomlin to Mike McCarthy, a move that was treated as a necessary evil in the push for postseason success.

But the results still look familiar. Nine years and counting without a playoff win has hung over this franchise, and so far McCarthy’s Steelers don’t look like the group that’s going to break that pattern.

What made Sunday night sting is how cleanly Cincinnati exposed them. When Pittsburgh faces a quarterback like Joe Burrow, the defense’s predictable zone coverage gets picked apart, and the pass rush gets taken out of the game.

That’s exactly what happened here. The Bengals’ offense controlled the night, and the Steelers’ offense never found an answer.

It’s not an isolated issue, either. Pittsburgh has now been blown out this season by Joe Burrow and Drake Maye, and that’s the kind of company that tells the story.

The Steelers’ wins have mostly come against quarterbacks such as Cooper Rush, Joe Burrow, Daniel Jones, Jalon Daniels, Tyler Shough, and Deshaun Watson. Outside of the first Burrow win - when Cincinnati helped itself with a few mental errors - there hasn’t been much evidence that Pittsburgh has taken down a quarterback of real substance.

That’s why this team keeps feeling like the same team. The Steelers can still find their way into the postseason because the rest of the schedule is manageable. They should be able to win four to five more games, and their path to the playoffs still looks strong enough after this loss.

But the bigger question is what happens once they get there. The latest loss to an AFC North rival, and the Week 2 20-3 defeat to New England, both point in the same direction. Pittsburgh may make the tournament, but Sunday night was another reminder that the Steelers still don’t look built to do much once the real tests begin.

For fans hoping for a different ending, that’s the part that hurts most. The warning sign is right there.

In Other News...

Steelers Get A Needed Receiver Boost Before A Huge Bengals Test

The Steelers are getting healthier at a time when they could use the help most, with an AFC North matchup against the Bengals looming. Wide receiver depth has been tested by injuries, and Ben Skowronek has been part of that equation after missing the past two games with a calf injury.

Skowronek has practiced fully this week, which puts him on track to rejoin the mix and give Pittsburgh another option at receiver. For a team heading into a division game with plenty on the line, any added stability at that position matters, especially with Cincinnati coming back into view. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Suddenly Face Real Pressure To Respond Before Eagles Game

A divisional loss like the one Pittsburgh just absorbed from Cincinnati tends to linger, and this one came with enough issues on both sides of the ball to make the next week feel urgent. The Steelers were beaten decisively, and afterward Mike McCarthy and Aaron Rodgers both pointed to the need for accountability and a cleaner standard as the team turns the page toward Philadelphia.

Rodgers also made clear the offense never found its rhythm against the Bengals pressure looks, leaving Pittsburgh with more questions than comfort heading into a matchup with the Eagles. After a performance that fell well short of what the Steelers expect from themselves, the response in practice and in the game plan will matter almost as much as the result on Sunday. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers-Bengals Just Picked Up An Officiating Concern Fans Wont Ignore

A primetime AFC North game already carries enough edge on its own, but the officiating crew for Steelers-Bengals now comes with an unusual wrinkle. A FAA ground stop has scrambled travel plans, and four NFL officials are slated to work the Dolphins-Colts game in Indianapolis before making the drive to Cincinnati for the nightcap.

For Pittsburgh fans, the bigger concern is the potential effect of that tight turnaround on a game that figures to be played with playoff-type intensity. The crew change also means Don Willard will step in as the head referee instead of Clete Blakeman, adding another layer of attention to a matchup where every flag, spot and replay decision is likely to matter. [Read more 🡒]