Steelers Just Got Hit With A Reality Check Fans Feared

Can the Pittsburgh Steelers overcome their recent setbacks and salvage their season after a crushing defeat by the Cincinnati Bengals?

Maybe Ja'Marr Chase had a point about this rivalry not being much of one.

The Steelers walked into Week 10 riding momentum and talking like a team ready to prove it belonged in the AFC picture. They left Paycor Stadium looking nothing like that group, buried 38-18 by the Bengals and suddenly facing a very different kind of conversation.

Pittsburgh is now 6-3, but the loss did more than dent the record. It exposed problems everywhere.

Aaron Rodgers was at the center of it. The entire Steelers operation looked off, but Rodgers had one of the roughest afternoons of the bunch.

He looked unsettled before some plays even began, felt the rush early, missed throws, flirted with interceptions and too often settled for quick dumps to running backs that went nowhere. Rodgers still has moments that show he can play at 42, but against Cincinnati he was flat-out bad.

Maybe the worst player on the field.

The numbers told part of the story, too. Just before the two-minute warning, Rodgers was 0/7 while Joe Burrow was 21/26 for 245 yards and two touchdowns.

Genuinely one of the graphics of all time pic.twitter.com/jvitfuIqw0

The Steelers’ passing game is also screaming for help. They need a WR1, and right now Germie Bernard is the closest thing they have, though he’s not there yet.

DK Metcalf is not the answer. Omar Khan’s choice not to make a move before the trade deadline is going to linger, especially with Rodgers lacking reliable weapons and not always trying to extend plays when nothing is open.

More often than not, he seems to shut it down quickly.

That puts even more pressure on the group behind Metcalf, and the hope is that Roman Wilson and Michael Pittman Jr. can give the offense something different. If they don’t, this unit is going to have a hard time hanging with teams that can score like Cincinnati.

Metcalf’s role is becoming harder to justify, too. There’s a case for the attention he draws from defenses, but that only matters if Rodgers can actually find someone else.

Right now, that hasn’t been happening. Metcalf can’t even be counted on to finish open catches consistently.

He ended with two receptions for 54 yards and a touchdown, but all of that came in the fourth quarter with the Steelers already down 31-3.

The frustration around him is obvious. The offense isn’t all his fault, but when a receiver making over $30 million a year is barely holding up as a playable option, he becomes an easy target.

Metcalf, plain and simple, isn’t very good right now. At times, he’s not good at all.

Pittsburgh also has a matchup problem on the back end. Asante Samuel Jr.’s return to a starting lineup is a nice story after a neck injury that nearly ended his career, but this game showed the limits of what he can handle in the AFC North.

He’s simply not big enough for battles like this one against the Bengals. Tee Higgins kept making it look easy against him, and Ja'Marr Chase is the kind of receiver nobody can claim to have figured out - Samuel Jr. certainly isn’t close.

Daylen Everette is going to make rookie mistakes, but he has the size to at least compete in these kinds of games. Pittsburgh needs to see what that looks like. Samuel Jr. just doesn’t have it against Cincinnati.

Then came another blow before halftime. Mason McCormick went down with what looked like a significant ankle injury, and if that keeps him out for the rest of the season, the Steelers’ offensive line just took a major hit. That may be the second hardest loss for this team to absorb.

Zach Frazier and McCormick have been Pittsburgh’s best two offensive linemen this season, and McCormick, a third-year fourth-round pick, had been playing at a Pro Bowl level. At times, he’d been the most dependable piece up front, and the line’s progress had been built in part around him.

Against the Bengals, that group took a clear step backward. Without McCormick, the problems suddenly feel even bigger.

For now, the Super Bowl talk can be shelved. The Steelers have looked like a pretender against the best competition, especially on the road. They’ve played two teams in the AFC playoff race away from home this season, and both times they were blown out.

They can’t keep pace with explosive offenses in the secondary, and the offense has no real juice unless Jaylen Warren is rushing for 100 yards. Take away No. 30, and the whole thing starts to stall. The four-game winning streak still mattered, but it came against losing teams in close games, and that’s not the same thing as holding up against real contenders.

The season isn’t over. But after this one, it’s a lot harder to feel good about where Pittsburgh is headed.

In Other News...

Steelers Get A Needed Receiver Boost Before A Huge Bengals Test

The Steelers are getting healthier at a time when they could use the help most, with an AFC North matchup against the Bengals looming. Wide receiver depth has been tested by injuries, and Ben Skowronek has been part of that equation after missing the past two games with a calf injury.

Skowronek has practiced fully this week, which puts him on track to rejoin the mix and give Pittsburgh another option at receiver. For a team heading into a division game with plenty on the line, any added stability at that position matters, especially with Cincinnati coming back into view. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Suddenly Face Real Pressure To Respond Before Eagles Game

A divisional loss like the one Pittsburgh just absorbed from Cincinnati tends to linger, and this one came with enough issues on both sides of the ball to make the next week feel urgent. The Steelers were beaten decisively, and afterward Mike McCarthy and Aaron Rodgers both pointed to the need for accountability and a cleaner standard as the team turns the page toward Philadelphia.

Rodgers also made clear the offense never found its rhythm against the Bengals pressure looks, leaving Pittsburgh with more questions than comfort heading into a matchup with the Eagles. After a performance that fell well short of what the Steelers expect from themselves, the response in practice and in the game plan will matter almost as much as the result on Sunday. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers-Bengals Just Picked Up An Officiating Concern Fans Wont Ignore

A primetime AFC North game already carries enough edge on its own, but the officiating crew for Steelers-Bengals now comes with an unusual wrinkle. A FAA ground stop has scrambled travel plans, and four NFL officials are slated to work the Dolphins-Colts game in Indianapolis before making the drive to Cincinnati for the nightcap.

For Pittsburgh fans, the bigger concern is the potential effect of that tight turnaround on a game that figures to be played with playoff-type intensity. The crew change also means Don Willard will step in as the head referee instead of Clete Blakeman, adding another layer of attention to a matchup where every flag, spot and replay decision is likely to matter. [Read more 🡒]