The Pittsburgh Steelers have kept their fan base on edge over the past two offseasons, largely due to the uncertainty surrounding Aaron Rodgers and his potential retirement. As fans eagerly await his decision for the 2026 season, the only quarterbacks currently under contract in Pittsburgh are Mason Rudolph and Will Howard. These two could be the fallback options if Rodgers decides not to return.
Despite the uncertainty, the Steelers appear to be operating under the assumption that Rodgers will be back. They've been making strategic "win-now" moves throughout the 2026 offseason, suggesting confidence in their current roster, which seems stronger than it was this time last year.
Steelers beat writer Mark Kaboly shared insights on 93.7 The Fan, noting the team originally expected to know Rodgers' plans before free agency. However, the timeline might have shifted to just before the 2026 NFL Draft. The team is prepared for any outcome, with Howard and Rudolph as potential starting options if Rodgers opts out.
There's palpable excitement within the organization about Will Howard. Despite a setback in 2025 due to a thumb injury during training camp, Howard has shown promise. Head Coach Mike McCarthy, known for his expertise with quarterbacks, has spoken highly of Howard, underscoring the team's enthusiasm for his potential.
While Kaboly mentioned Rudolph and Howard as contingency plans, it's clear from McCarthy and General Manager Omar Khan's comments that Howard will have every chance to earn the starting role. His name frequently comes up in press conferences, highlighting the team's optimism.
Rudolph brings experience but is largely seen as a career backup. He can fill in when needed, but the Steelers likely prefer not to rely on him for an entire season.
For many fans, starting Howard is a win-win scenario. If he excels, the Steelers may have found their future franchise quarterback.
If he struggles, the team could secure a valuable draft position in 2027, which is expected to be rich with talent. Either way, the Steelers are positioning themselves strategically for the future.