A surprising ranking from CBS Sports’ Mike Renner has stirred up a familiar Steelers debate: which of Pittsburgh’s recent first-round picks left the better mark, Najee Harris or Kenny Pickett?
Renner ranked all 191 first-round selections of the 2020s, and the Steelers did not land a single player in the top third. Only Derrick Harmon at No. 94 and Troy Fautanu at No. 99 cracked the top 100. But the placement that stands out most for Pittsburgh is the one involving its two headline picks from back-to-back years.
Pickett came in at No. 138.
Harris was even lower at No. 152.
Both were ranked ahead of Broderick Jones, who landed at No. 173.
That ordering is the one that will raise eyebrows in Pittsburgh, because while neither Pickett nor Harris became the kind of cornerstone the Steelers hoped for, Harris clearly gave the team more on the field.
Harris arrived first in 2021 and delivered the best season of his Steelers tenure right away. He piled up 1,667 yards from scrimmage, scored 10 touchdowns and earned a Pro Bowl nod. A year later, Pickett entered as Ben Roethlisberger’s successor and started 12 games as a rookie, finishing 7-5 with 2,404 passing yards, seven touchdowns and nine interceptions.
Harris followed that rookie season from Pickett with another 1,263 yards from scrimmage and 10 touchdowns in 2022.
Pickett never really took the next step in 2023. In 12 starts, he threw for 2,070 yards with six touchdowns and four interceptions before asking for a trade. He was eventually sent to the Philadelphia Eagles the following offseason after Pittsburgh signed Russell Wilson.
Harris, by contrast, kept producing. Over the 2023 and 2024 seasons, he combined for 2,531 yards and 14 touchdowns. He then signed with the Los Angeles Chargers before the 2025 campaign after the Steelers declined his fifth-year option.
The Steelers drafted both players during Kevin Colbert’s final two drafts as general manager, and they were part of a young offensive group that also included Pat Freiermuth and George Pickens.
There is a case that positional value influenced Renner’s ranking, but the production gap in Pittsburgh is hard to ignore. Pickett never looked like a starting-caliber quarterback with the Steelers, even if offensive coordinator Matt Canada took plenty of heat along the way. Harris wasn’t an explosive efficiency machine - he averaged 3.9 yards per carry and 4.3 yards per touch - but he was a dependable No. 1 back who consistently put up numbers.
In the end, Harris was the better investment for Pittsburgh. Pickett simply didn’t give the Steelers enough to make the argument close.
In Other News...
Why Steelers Fans Suddenly Believe This New Era Could Change Everything
Patrick Grahams arrival as defensive coordinator gives the Steelers another major piece to sort through as this new staff takes shape, and it is a hire that naturally invites big-picture questions about how quickly the defense can be reshaped. With coaching changes and roster adjustments already altering the conversation around Pittsburgh, there is a growing sense that the team is trying to reset more than just a few schemes.
The optimism has spread beyond the sideline, too, with some around the team wondering whether the pieces now in place can push both sides of the ball into a different tier by 2026. It is the kind of early buzz that usually comes with a fresh regime, but in Pittsburgh it also carries real weight because expectations are never small, and the next steps will say plenty about how far this overhaul can go. [Read more 🡒]
Two Steelers Legends Just Earned Rare All Time NFL Recognition
A fresh round of all-time NFL state rankings put a couple of familiar Steelers names back in the spotlight, with FanSideds Nick Villano sorting through the leagues history and landing on two franchise icons near the top of his list. For Pittsburgh fans, the appeal is obvious: Franco Harris and Rod Woodson were not just great players, they were defining figures for different eras of the organization.
Harris was chosen as the best NFL player from New Jersey, while Woodson earned the nod for Indiana, a reminder of how far their legacies reach beyond the black and gold. The selections also underscore the kind of company they keep in these debates, where regional pride and career greatness collide, and where the Steelers can still point to two Hall of Fame-caliber names as standard-bearers in a conversation that never really gets old. [Read more 🡒]
Ryan Clark Unleashed On ESPN After Stunning Exit
Ryan Clarks exit from ESPN landed with extra weight in Pittsburgh, where the former Steelers safety built a second career as one of the networks more familiar NFL voices. He had spent 11 years at ESPN and was a regular on several football shows, so his departure was notable even before the public back-and-forth began.
Clark has since pushed back on how the move was described, saying on his podcast that he was fired and not simply caught up in a routine layoff. He also suggested the situation was more complicated inside ESPN, and while he has been outspoken about what happened, what comes next for him in NFL media remains unclear. [Read more 🡒]