Mike McCarthy’s first season with the Pittsburgh Steelers is already drawing attention, and one NFL analyst thinks it could put him in the mix for one of the league’s top honors.
NFL.com’s Bucky Brooks listed McCarthy as a long-shot candidate for Coach of the Year while running through dark-horse picks for the NFL’s major awards in 2026. Brooks pointed to McCarthy’s résumé, Pittsburgh’s roster, and the possibility that the pairing with Aaron Rodgers could quickly change the conversation around the Steelers.
“This underappreciated, Super Bowl-winning head coach has a chance to cement his legacy with a strong run in Pittsburgh,” Brooks wrote. “McCarthy takes over a longtime winner that had plateaued under Mike Tomlin, but the roster still features enough veteran playmakers to make a jump from good to great under new direction.
If the veteran coach can get Aaron Rodgers to play like a top-half quarterback in a system that minimizes his deficiencies as a 42-year-old - while simultaneously prodding defensive coordinator Patrick Graham to help the vaunted defense regain its swagger and suffocating style - the Steelers will make plenty of noise as contenders. Inherently, McCarthy could win his first Coach of the Year award.”
The award has never gone McCarthy’s way, even though his NFL track record is packed with success. He owns a .608 winning percentage, has racked up 11 double-digit-win seasons, won a Super Bowl and reached the playoffs 12 times across 18 years in the league.
Coach of the Year, though, usually goes to the coach who pushes a team to the league’s best record or beats expectations in a major way. That’s part of why McCarthy’s name has never made it to the top of the ballot.
His years with Aaron Rodgers in Green Bay from 2006 to 2018, followed by a stretch with a loaded Dallas Cowboys roster from 2020 to 2024, gave him plenty of chances to stack wins. Still, outside of the 2010 title run that ended with a victory over the Steelers, he never quite forced the award voters to view him as the coach who went above and beyond.
Voting happens before the playoffs, which also worked against McCarthy that year.
Now he gets a new chance in Pittsburgh, where the idea is simple: if Rodgers can still perform like a top-half quarterback and the defense sharpens up under Patrick Graham, the Steelers have enough talent to make noise.
That’s why McCarthy’s case is at least worth watching. He’s a Super Bowl-winning coach returning to his hometown team with a chance to reshape the narrative that followed him in Green Bay and Dallas. The road to Coach of the Year is crowded, but the ingredients are there for him to make a run at it.
In Other News...
DK Metcalf Is Already Turning Steelers Rookie Eli Heidenreich Into A Camp Story
Eli Heidenreich has already found a way to stand out in Steelers camp, and it starts with the kind of attention rookies usually hope to earn later in the summer. The seventh-round pick out of Navy has drawn a nickname from DK Metcalf, who has been calling him Captain America after seeing him on the field, a fitting label for a player whose path to Pittsburgh has always been built around toughness, versatility and doing a little bit of everything.
For the Steelers, Heidenreich is the sort of camp name worth tracking because his role could come in more than one form. He is competing for special teams work and a possible spot in the backfield mix, where his speed and flexibility give him a chance to push for a place on the depth chart as training camp and the preseason unfold. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Offseason Just Got Hit With A Brutal National Reality Check
ESPNs Seth Walder took a skeptical look at the Steelers 2026 offseason, handing the group a C+ and casting doubt on whether the moves were enough to keep Pittsburgh in the AFC North race. The biggest concerns centered on the quarterback room and the front offices willingness to double down on Aaron Rodgers, while Walder also took issue with the trade for Michael Pittman Jr. as the team tried to reshape its offense.
Patrick Grahams defense may end up carrying much of the load if the Steelers are to stay in the conversation, and that only raises the pressure on a roster that is about to report to training camp on July 28 under new head coach Mike McCarthy. For a team trying to reset without losing its edge, the next few weeks will say plenty about whether this offseason was a calculated bet or a step backward. [Read more 🡒]