The Steelers made a coaching change, brought in an offensive-minded play-caller, and yet the old frustrations are still hanging around.
That’s the uncomfortable truth for Pittsburgh after a 4-2 start that includes an overtime escape in Tampa Bay. This is not a case of Mike McCarthy failing outright. It’s something more annoying for Steelers fans who thought a new coach would mean a new attitude: the philosophical makeover they expected hasn’t shown up.
McCarthy’s name carries real offensive weight, and for good reason. His teams have been productive for years.
The 2021 Cowboys led the NFL with 31.2 points per game, the 2022 version finished fourth, and the 2023 Cowboys again topped the league at 29.9. Before that, Green Bay regularly fielded elite offenses with Aaron Rodgers.
He knows how to build a scoring unit.
But offensive production and bold decision-making are not the same thing.
His résumé also includes plenty of moments that show a coach can score points without necessarily leaning into aggression. The most famous example came in the 2014 NFC Championship Game, when Green Bay got to Seattle’s 1-yard line on back-to-back early drives and came away with field goals both times. NFL.com chronicled those choices after the Packers later blew a 16-0 lead.
Dallas gave a fuller picture. McCarthy was willing to gamble at times, including a failed fourth-and-3 try against the Rams in his first game there.
But he also had stretches where a loaded offense played far more conservatively than fans would expect. The man overseeing those scoring totals was not always the same guy treating every big moment like a green light to attack.
That’s why his arrival in Pittsburgh was supposed to mean more than just a different name on the headset. The Steelers were hoping for a different vibe altogether - less of the familiar defense, field position, and close-game survival formula that had defined the Tomlin era. An offensive head coach was supposed to bring a little more initiative when points were there for the taking.
Instead, the early results have felt stubbornly ordinary.
Pittsburgh has already had to sit through a three-point outing against New England and another sluggish game that dragged through three quarters against Tampa Bay. Through six games, the Steelers are 18th in scoring even with Rodgers, DK Metcalf, Jaylen Warren, and an offensive head coach in place.
That’s the part fans wanted most: the aggression. And that’s exactly the part that still hasn’t become the Steelers’ identity.
McCarthy being from Pittsburgh and coaching the team he grew up rooting for is a strong story. But six games into this experiment, the hometown angle is wearing thin. Same crap, different coach.
In Other News...
Aaron Rodgers Had A Ruthless Postgame Moment After Steelers Comeback Win
Aaron Rodgers spent much of Sunday night trading punches in the pocket and in the back-and-forth that followed, helping the Steelers survive a tense road test against Tampa Bay. Pittsburgh needed overtime to finish off a comeback win at Raymond James Stadium, and Rodgers was steady enough to keep them alive after a rough start, throwing for 253 yards with two touchdowns and one interception as the offense found just enough rhythm to get back in the game.
The postgame edge was there, too, after Rodgers had already answered a rookie's trash talk in real time. He later took aim at the field conditions in Tampa, adding another pointed note to a night that had plenty of them. For the Steelers, the result mattered most, but Rodgers made sure the game left a little extra residue beyond the standings. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Finally Get Clarity On Joey Porter Jr. Trade Return
The Joey Porter Jr. trade finally moved from paperwork to certainty when he was active for the Dallas Cowboys' Week 6 game against the Green Bay Packers. That appearance satisfied the condition attached to the deal with Pittsburgh, giving the Steelers the clarity they had been waiting for on what they were getting back in return.
With the activation complete, Pittsburgh now has its full draft compensation secured and can close the book on the transaction. The return includes a 2027 sixth-round pick and a 2028 second-round pick, a resolution that lets the Steelers move on from the lingering uncertainty around Porter and look ahead to what those selections can mean down the road. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Escaped Tampa But One Late Decision Will Be Debated
Pittsburgh left Tampa with a 26-19 overtime win, but the victory came with plenty to sort through on both sides of the ball. The offense never found a smooth rhythm for long stretches, and Jaylen Warrens limited first-half workload stood out in a game where the Steelers often needed more balance to help steady the tempo.
The defense delivered enough high-leverage moments to keep Pittsburgh alive, with interceptions from Jamel Dean and Daylen Everette and sacks from Jaylen Ramsey and Nick Herbig helping shape a tense finish. Still, the late-game management will linger as a talking point, especially after the Steelers had a chance to close it out in regulation and instead left the outcome hanging until overtime. [Read more 🡒]