The idea of the Steelers making a run at Quenton Nelson is the kind of deadline thought that grabs attention fast. Pittsburgh is sitting at 4-2 and, by all appearances, is in position to buy. Wide receiver, inside linebacker, cornerback and safety are the clearest needs, but offensive guard has quietly entered the conversation too.
That’s partly because the current setup has held together better than expected. Mason McCormick’s move from right guard to left guard has gone well so far, and Brock Hoffman has been more than a serviceable fill-in since replacing Spencer Anderson in Week 3. Still, if the Colts start shopping veterans after dropping to 2-4 and firing general manager Chris Ballard, Nelson’s name is one that could immediately draw Pittsburgh’s interest.
And for good reason. Any team would think hard about adding a player who is a three-time first-team All-Pro, three-time second-team All-Pro and eight-time Pro Bowler.
Hoffman has been solid, especially in pass protection, where he has allowed just seven pressures and no sacks over 257 total snaps, per SumerSports. Nelson is on another tier entirely.
The Colts guard has allowed eight pressures and no sacks across 397 snaps this season, also per SumerSports, while continuing to be one of the league’s premier run blockers.
That kind of player would clearly raise the ceiling of Pittsburgh’s offensive line. The fit on paper is obvious, and the price might not be outrageous since Nelson would be a rental and is set to hit free agency after the season. A 2027 third-round pick would still be a real cost, but for a player of this caliber, it would likely be viewed as a reasonable one.
There’s also a longer play here. The Steelers do not negotiate contracts in season, and they have shown they are not willing to bend on that stance, as seen with Joey Porter Jr. before he was dealt to the Dallas Cowboys. Even so, bringing Nelson into the building for the second half of the year could help lay the groundwork for a future deal once the offseason arrives.
From a roster-building standpoint, the appeal is easy to see. Nelson working alongside Troy Fautanu, Max Iheanachor, Zach Frazier and McCormick would give Pittsburgh an imposing trench group and strengthen the foundation for whoever ends up starting at quarterback in 2027. That’s the sort of infrastructure that can make an offense feel a lot smoother.
But there’s another side to this, and it matters. McCormick has already logged 1,929 snaps at right guard between the 2024 and 2025 seasons, per Pro Football Focus, while Isaac Seumalo handled left guard. McCormick has shown he can start at right guard, and now that he’s settled in on the left side and in the middle of arguably his best stretch so far, moving him again could interrupt that momentum.
Nelson is a pure left guard and has never taken a snap at right guard, per PFF, which means McCormick would have to shift back. That’s not a small detail when Hoffman has also been a bright spot. It leaves Pittsburgh with a real question: is it worth giving up a Day 2 pick for another guard when the current mix has been working?
The money piece also complicates things. Frazier and McCormick are both heading into the final seasons of their rookie contracts and will be up for new deals next year. Pittsburgh can delay some of the pressure by picking up Fautanu’s fifth-year option and maybe pushing extension talks to 2028, but eventually the bill comes due.
And then there’s the bigger issue: if the Steelers traded for Nelson, they could not treat him like a half-season rental. Yes, a compensatory pick could come back if he leaves in free agency, but using major assets on an elite player only to let him walk would be a tough sell. Pittsburgh is a playoff team, but not a Super Bowl team, and that makes the logic of bringing in Nelson for a short stint less compelling.
So the Steelers are left weighing a simple but tricky question. Nelson would upgrade the line immediately and maybe even create a path for something more permanent later. But between the current guard play, the possibility of disrupting that balance and the long-term contract puzzle, this is exactly the kind of move Pittsburgh may decide to leave on the board.
In Other News...
Steelers Face One Paris Question If Sunday Goes Sideways
The Steelers landed in Paris on Friday morning after an overnight flight, leaving them with less than two days to settle in before Sundays matchup with the Saints. New Orleans got there earlier in the week, a contrast that has already fueled a quiet debate around the Steelers travel plan and whether the tighter turnaround could matter once the game starts.
Aaron Rodgers made it clear he would have preferred an earlier arrival, and former Steeler Breiden Fehoko said some players were openly unhappy with the trip and felt worn down. The schedule was a coaching-staff decision, though, and the real test now is whether the extra miles and shorter adjustment window show up on the field or fade into the background by kickoff. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Defense Faces A Bigger Saints Test Than Fans Realize
The Steelers defense has been trending in the right direction under coordinator Patrick Graham, tightening up just enough to make opponents work for every clean throw. Over the last three games, Pittsburgh has allowed only two passing touchdowns while coming away with three interceptions, a stretch that has helped steady a unit that needed to find its footing.
Sundays trip to New Orleans still brings a different kind of challenge, with Tyler Shough entering Week 7 productive enough to stress a secondary that may not be at full strength. Brandin Echols is out with a hamstring injury, and Jalen Ramsey is working through a wrist issue, which makes the task of slowing Shough and his connection with Chris Olave look a lot less comfortable than the recent numbers suggest. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Face A Risky Alex Highsmith Decision They May Regret
With the NFL trade deadline approaching, the Steelers are at least entertaining the kind of move that can reshape a season in a hurry. According to a report from The Athletics Daniel Popper, the front office is weighing a player-for-player deal involving outside linebacker Alex Highsmith, a notable twist for a defense that has leaned on him as one of its most reliable edge threats while the roster still has other areas needing attention.
The appeal is obvious enough: Pittsburgh could look to address needs in the secondary or at wide receiver if the right partner emerges, and a swap like this would force the team to think beyond one position group. But Highsmith is also a central piece of what the Steelers do up front, so any serious discussion carries real risk for a defense that has relied on his production and consistency while the deadline clock keeps ticking. [Read more 🡒]