DK Metcalf’s first season in Pittsburgh has turned into a problem the Steelers can’t ignore, even if they may not love the answer.
Sunday night’s 38-18 loss to the Bengals was another rough chapter. Metcalf was quiet early, struggled to create separation, and let a chance at a big play slip away in the second quarter when he dropped what would have been about a 30-yard gain with Jordan Battle in coverage. Battle’s taunting penalty kept the drive alive, and Metcalf later finished with 54 yards and a touchdown in garbage time, but that late burst didn’t erase the bigger concern.
The veteran wideout has not come close to matching the four-year, $132 million deal he signed after Pittsburgh acquired him in a March 2025 trade from the Seahawks. The contract already looks like a burden, and the Steelers did themselves no favors this offseason when they restructured it to create nearly $18 million in cap room.
That move pushed $23.7 million of Metcalf’s 2026 salary into a signing bonus. It lowered his cap hit by $17.775 million, but it also raised his cap charges in future seasons by $5.925 million per year, according to Over the Cap. On top of that, he has a $6.5 million roster cut due on the fifth day of the 2027 league year, plus $5 million roster bonuses due on the fifth day of the league year in both 2028 and 2029.
The escape routes are messy. A pre-June 1 cut or trade next offseason would barely help, bringing only $2.650 million in cap space while leaving behind $35.775 million in dead money. A post-June 1 move in 2027 would be far cleaner on the cap, saving $26.5 million, but Pittsburgh would still eat $11.925 million in dead money.
If the Steelers wait until 2028, the dead money stays the same while the cap savings climb to $28 million. By 2029, that number rises again to $35.5 million.
Even with those options on the table, moving on from Metcalf would be a tough call inside the building. He came at a steep price, with Pittsburgh sending a 2025 second-round pick and a 2025 seventh-rounder to Seattle in exchange for Metcalf and a 2025 sixth-rounder. Cutting bait that quickly would be a loud message to the locker room, and not necessarily a comfortable one.
Still, the performance has to matter. The drop issues, the lack of downfield separation, and the overall decline have been a surprise.
Pittsburgh believed it was getting a true No. 1 receiver. Instead, Metcalf has looked like a replacement-level player in 2026.
Finding a trade partner would not be easy, either. The Steelers might even have to attach a pick just to move the contract. Releasing him may be more realistic than dealing him, but that path comes with its own dead-money headache.
So yes, there is a way out. It just isn’t pretty.
If Metcalf doesn’t turn things around, Pittsburgh could at least consider moving on next offseason, even if it would not be the cleanest football decision. For now, though, the likeliest outcome is that he stays on the roster in 2027, despite the fact that he has lost a step, offered little value this season and is on pace for 816 yards over 17 games, which would be a career low.
In Other News...
Patrick Queen Sends Clear Warning After Steelers Primetime Collapse
Patrick Queen did his part in a rough Sunday night for Pittsburgh, piling up 14 tackles, a sack and four stops in the Steelers 38-18 loss to the Bengals. Even in a game where the defense spent too much time chasing the action, Queen stood out as one of the few bright spots, and his play fit the urgency of a team that still sits at 6-3 and is trying to keep its playoff position intact.
Afterward, Queen made it clear the response has to come quickly, because the margin for error is shrinking with tougher games ahead. The Steelers have been good enough to stay in the hunt, but not good enough to ignore a collapse like this one, and Queens message was less about panic than about accountability, confidence and getting back on track before the schedule tightens even more. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Suddenly Need Spencer Anderson For A Much Bigger Role
The Steelers offensive line took a hit against Cincinnati when Mason McCormick went down with an ankle injury and had to be carted off the field, leaving a sudden opening in the middle of a unit that has already had to absorb plenty of shuffling. With the team still sorting through the full extent of the injury, the immediate focus has shifted to keeping the line steady and protecting the rest of the offense from the fallout.
Spencer Anderson is the next man up, and head coach Mike McCarthy pointed to his versatility and experience as the reasons he can handle the job. For Pittsburgh, that kind of flexibility matters now more than ever, because one injury can quickly change the look of an entire front and force the Steelers to lean on depth they hoped would stay in reserve a little longer. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Loss Put Mike McCarthys Bye Week Call Under Fire
The Steelers came out of a two-week stretch with plenty of rest and little to show for it, dropping a 38-18 decision to the Bengals in a game that quickly turned into a reminder that time off does not always translate into sharp football. Pittsburghs defense had trouble slowing Cincinnati through the air, and the offense never found much rhythm, finishing with just 222 total yards in a loss that raised immediate questions about how the week was handled.
Mike McCarthys choice to give the team the full bye week off stood out from the more hands-on approach some coaches prefer, and the result has only intensified the scrutiny. After a performance like this, the conversation around preparation is no longer just about rest versus work, but whether the Steelers gave themselves enough of a chance to come out ready for a division game that mattered. [Read more 🡒]
