Steelers’ Coaching Search: Three Names Emerging as Front-Runners to Replace Mike Tomlin
The Mike Tomlin era in Pittsburgh is officially over, and with it, one of the most consistent head coaching tenures in NFL history. Now, for the first time since 2007, the Steelers are in the market for a new head coach-and the search is already heating up.
With interviews underway and speculation swirling, three names have emerged as frontrunners, according to betting markets. These aren’t just long shots or fan-fueled wish lists-each of them is reportedly in the mix with actual interviews taking place in Pittsburgh. Let’s break down the top contenders, what they bring to the table, and why each could be the next man tasked with leading the Black and Gold.
Chris Shula (42% Betting Odds) - The Early Favorite
There’s plenty of buzz around Chris Shula, and it’s not just because of his last name-though being the grandson of Don Shula, the NFL’s all-time winningest coach, certainly doesn’t hurt. What really makes Shula intriguing is how closely he fits the mold of recent Steelers hires: young, defensive-minded, and on the rise.
Currently the defensive coordinator for the Los Angeles Rams, Shula helped guide a unit that quietly became one of the league’s most resilient, despite battling through a rash of injuries. His ability to adapt and keep the defense competitive speaks volumes about his leadership and schematic flexibility.
But it’s more than just X’s and O’s. Shula’s deep ties to Sean McVay’s coaching tree have fans and insiders alike wondering who he might bring in as his offensive coordinator-a crucial decision in today’s NFL. That connection to McVay’s staff could open doors to innovative offensive minds, something Pittsburgh sorely needs.
While his odds have dipped slightly from 48% to 42%, Shula remains the betting favorite for a reason. Reports suggest the Steelers had already done their homework on him during the season, anticipating the possibility of Tomlin stepping away. That kind of early interest is rarely coincidental.
Brian Flores (17% Betting Odds) - The Familiar Face
Brian Flores isn’t just a name from the past-he’s someone the Steelers know well. After a turbulent but ultimately successful stint as head coach in Miami, Flores spent the 2022 season on Pittsburgh’s staff. That year left a strong impression, and his reputation has only grown since.
Now the defensive coordinator in Minnesota, Flores has turned the Vikings’ defense into one of the most efficient units in the league. His aggressive, adaptable schemes have drawn praise across the NFL, and his ability to maximize talent without a roster full of stars is exactly the kind of trait Pittsburgh values.
Unlike the Steelers’ last three hires, Flores has head coaching experience. That could be a plus in a locker room full of veterans who are used to Tomlin’s steady hand.
He led the Dolphins to back-to-back winning seasons in 2020 and 2021-something Miami hadn’t done since 2003. That’s no small feat, especially considering the internal challenges he faced during that time.
His odds peaked at 32% earlier in the week but have since settled at 17%. Still, Flores remains very much in the conversation, and his familiarity with the Steelers’ culture and expectations could give him an edge.
Nathan Scheelhaase (15% Betting Odds) - The Wild Card
Every coaching search has a dark horse, and right now, that’s Nathan Scheelhaase.
Scheelhaase has been gaining momentum quickly-not just in Pittsburgh, but across the league. He’s reportedly received multiple interview requests, and there’s growing chatter that he could be part of a package deal with Chris Shula, either as a head coach or as a potential offensive coordinator if Shula gets the top job.
While he doesn’t check every traditional Steelers box-he’s an offensive coach, after all-his background under Sean McVay has earned him high praise. And in a league that’s increasingly tilted toward offensive innovation, that could be a welcome shift in Pittsburgh.
What’s interesting is the growing fan support for Scheelhaase. Social media has lit up with excitement over his name, and while that doesn’t make the hire, it certainly adds some momentum. His rapid rise in betting markets reflects that buzz, and if the Steelers are looking for a fresh direction, Scheelhaase could be the guy to take them there.
What’s Next for Pittsburgh?
The Steelers are at a pivotal crossroads. Replacing a coach like Mike Tomlin isn’t just about finding the next man up-it’s about setting the tone for the next decade.
Will they stick with their tradition of hiring young, defensive-minded coaches like Shula? Will they go with a proven leader like Flores who already knows the building?
Or will they take a bold swing with an offensive innovator like Scheelhaase?
What’s clear is this: Pittsburgh isn’t rushing the process, but they are being thorough. Interviews are underway, and the shortlist is forming. Whoever gets the job will inherit a team with talent, tradition, and expectations that never waver.
The Tomlin chapter may be closed-but the next one is already being written.