The Colts’ move to send Quenton Nelson to Seattle on Tuesday cracked the door open for teams looking to buy ahead of the November 10 deadline, and the Steelers could absolutely be one of them. Indianapolis is now signaling it is willing to hear offers on just about everybody, and while names like Tyler Warren and Sauce Gardner seem like obvious exceptions, the rest of the roster may be in play.
For Pittsburgh, that creates a few interesting possibilities. The Steelers need help in multiple spots, and Indianapolis has starters who could fit the bill even after the Nelson deal thinned out the top of the market. Here are four Colts players who could make sense for Pittsburgh to target.
Josh Downs is the easiest name to connect to the Steelers. Pittsburgh needs receivers who can separate, and Downs has already shown he can produce from the slot.
He’s 25 and has posted two 750-plus-yard seasons, so the résumé is there. The concern is obvious, though: at 5'9'' and 171 pounds, he does not bring a big catch radius, and his contract year means he might only be a short-term answer.
Matt Goncalves might be the better prize. Even after Nelson moved on, Goncalves gives Pittsburgh another option on the interior, and he comes at a younger age with more team control.
Pro Football Focus has him grading as a top-25 guard among 74 qualifying players this season, and he’s still 25 with another full year left on his rookie contract in 2027. That gives the Steelers a potential long-term piece, not just a quick fix.
He plays right guard, which would let Pittsburgh slot him in for Brock Hoffman, who has struggled over the past three weeks.
Charvarius Ward brings a different kind of appeal. He’s 30 now and no longer at the peak he reached with San Francisco in 2022 and 2023, but he still has the size, length and physicality to change how a defense lines up.
In Pittsburgh, he could help Patrick Graham lean more into press-man looks with Jamel Dean on the other side. Ward’s contract is heavy and runs through 2027, but that could also lower the price to something like a Day 3 pick.
If it doesn’t work, the Steelers would have an exit after the season.
Camryn Bynum would be more of a stabilizer than a headline-grabber, but that has value too. The 28-year-old safety has started 78 of 89 games and has 13 interceptions entering Week 8 of the 2026 season.
For a secondary that could use depth and experience, he would bring immediate help and some insurance if DeShon Elliott keeps struggling after the injury or if more injuries hit. Bynum’s contract is pricey and runs through the 2028 season, but there’s no guaranteed money beyond 2026, so Pittsburgh could move on as early as the 2027 offseason if needed.
In Other News...
Yahya Black Is Giving Steelers Fans Another Reason To Trust This Defense
Yahya Black has quietly become one of the more interesting developments on Pittsburghs defense this season. With Derrick Harmon sidelined, Blacks role has grown, and while the box score and grading metrics may not fully capture it, the tape shows a lineman doing the dirty work that helps the Steelers run defense hold up. He has been clogging lanes, taking on double teams and making life harder for backs trying to find clean space inside.
There is also a little more to his game than just eating blocks, which matters for a defense that wants dependable pieces it can keep on the field. Black has started to show improvement as a pass rusher, giving Pittsburgh a more versatile presence up front and making him increasingly playable in more situations. For a team that leans on its defense to set the tone, that kind of growth is another reason to trust what this unit can still be. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Have A Trade Deadline Question Fans Will Fight Over
With the NFL trade deadline drawing closer, the Steelers are in the familiar position of weighing whether a midseason move could help a roster that still has obvious edges to smooth out. Pittsburgh has about $14.5 million in salary cap space, enough to at least take a serious look at the market if the right deal appears, and the early chatter is already pointing in several directions depending on which part of the roster the front office believes needs the most help.
The names being floated span the board, from cornerback Tariq Woolen and wideout Jauan Jennings to linebacker Frankie Luvu, guard Quenton Nelson and safety Jessie Bates III, which tells you how many different conversations could be happening at once. The bigger question is not just who is available, but whether Pittsburgh wants a short-term fix in a rental type of move or prefers to keep its powder dry and trust what it has, a choice that usually gets fans arguing long before the deadline actually arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Joey Porter Jr Is Reopening An Uncomfortable Steelers Debate
Joey Porter Jr. has become a reminder of what the Steelers used to have at cornerback, and the contrast has been hard to ignore. Now with Dallas, Porter has been sharp in coverage this season, while Pittsburghs secondary looked vulnerable again in its Week 7 game against New Orleans, giving up a string of completions and too many easy yards in the back end.
The comparison is uncomfortable because it goes beyond a single rough afternoon. Porter has been doing his part for the Cowboys, while the Steelers are left sorting through another week where their defensive backs did not hold up the way they needed to, and that only sharpens the old question about how Pittsburgh evaluated and moved on from the young corner. [Read more 🡒]