Steelers Cant Ignore This Aaron Rodgers Problem Much Longer

Once doubtful, Steelers fans are now vindicated as Aaron Rodgers' struggles are exposed in crucial matchups.

Pittsburgh got another brutal reminder on Sunday night that Aaron Rodgers is no longer the kind of quarterback who can carry a team through the rough patches.

The Steelers were already hearing the warning signs last offseason, when fans made it clear Rodgers wasn’t good enough to keep them waiting before they finally signed him to a one-year deal in June. Pittsburgh still made the playoffs, only to get blown out 30-6 by the Houston Texans in what was one of the worst outings of Rodgers’ career. Even then, Omar Khan and team president saw what everyone else saw and chose to run it back.

Now the results are even uglier.

Against the Cincinnati Bengals in Week 10, Rodgers turned in a performance that laid bare exactly why the Steelers’ patience with him has been misplaced. Before he completed his first pass on Sunday Night Football, Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow had already piled up 245 passing yards. That number is a damning reflection on Pittsburgh’s defense, which deserves plenty of blame, but it also underscored how little Rodgers was doing to keep the Steelers afloat.

By the end of three quarters, the Bengals had built a 31-3 lead and effectively forced the game into garbage time. Rodgers did manage to throw two touchdown passes in the fourth quarter after Cincinnati eased off, but the damage was already done. He finished 15 of 29 for 143 yards, just 4.9 yards per attempt, with two touchdowns and a 26.4 QBR.

Strip away the final-quarter padding, and the picture gets even worse. Through three quarters, Rodgers was 4 of 14 for 27 yards, averaging 1.9 yards per attempt, with no touchdowns. Cincinnati also dropped a pick on a pass intended for Darnell Washington.

If Rodgers had been pulled after three quarters and Mike McCarthy hadn’t let him pad the stats, he would have ended Week 10 with a 39.5 passer rating in what was arguably the worst quarterback performance of the 2026 NFL season.

The advanced numbers make the case even harder to ignore. Before the late touchdowns, Rodgers posted a -0.475 dropback EPA and a 13.6 percent success rate, according to RBSDM Stats. For context, an average quarterback success rate in a game usually sits between 45 and 47 percent.

Yes, the Steelers have issues around him. The receivers haven’t helped enough, the route concepts can be dull, and the defense offered little support in this game.

But a quarterback with Rodgers’ reputation is supposed to elevate the offense when things get messy. He didn’t do that here.

He didn’t come close.

And the Bengals weren’t exactly fielding a dominant defense, either. Entering Week 10, Cincinnati ranked in the bottom half of the league on that side of the ball. Two weeks earlier, it had given up 36 points and 440 offensive yards to the now 1-7 Tennessee Titans.

Instead of stabilizing their season, the Steelers watched their contending hopes take another hit. The more Rodgers looks like the player he is now, the harder it is to see Pittsburgh going anywhere in the postseason this year.

In Other News...

Steelers Get A Needed Receiver Boost Before A Huge Bengals Test

The Steelers are getting healthier at a time when they could use the help most, with an AFC North matchup against the Bengals looming. Wide receiver depth has been tested by injuries, and Ben Skowronek has been part of that equation after missing the past two games with a calf injury.

Skowronek has practiced fully this week, which puts him on track to rejoin the mix and give Pittsburgh another option at receiver. For a team heading into a division game with plenty on the line, any added stability at that position matters, especially with Cincinnati coming back into view. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Suddenly Face Real Pressure To Respond Before Eagles Game

A divisional loss like the one Pittsburgh just absorbed from Cincinnati tends to linger, and this one came with enough issues on both sides of the ball to make the next week feel urgent. The Steelers were beaten decisively, and afterward Mike McCarthy and Aaron Rodgers both pointed to the need for accountability and a cleaner standard as the team turns the page toward Philadelphia.

Rodgers also made clear the offense never found its rhythm against the Bengals pressure looks, leaving Pittsburgh with more questions than comfort heading into a matchup with the Eagles. After a performance that fell well short of what the Steelers expect from themselves, the response in practice and in the game plan will matter almost as much as the result on Sunday. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers-Bengals Just Picked Up An Officiating Concern Fans Wont Ignore

A primetime AFC North game already carries enough edge on its own, but the officiating crew for Steelers-Bengals now comes with an unusual wrinkle. A FAA ground stop has scrambled travel plans, and four NFL officials are slated to work the Dolphins-Colts game in Indianapolis before making the drive to Cincinnati for the nightcap.

For Pittsburgh fans, the bigger concern is the potential effect of that tight turnaround on a game that figures to be played with playoff-type intensity. The crew change also means Don Willard will step in as the head referee instead of Clete Blakeman, adding another layer of attention to a matchup where every flag, spot and replay decision is likely to matter. [Read more 🡒]