Steelers fans are already pushing Omar Khan to make a move before the November 10 NFL trade deadline, especially after seeing splashy deals around the league. The Seattle Seahawks landed All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson.
The San Francisco 49ers got defensive tackle DeForest Buckner from the Colts. But Pittsburgh cannot afford to copy the Chicago Bears’ approach.
That warning comes into sharper focus after Thursday’s blockbuster, when the Bears traded for Tennessee Titans All-Pro and four-time Pro Bowl defensive lineman Jeffery Simmons. The price was massive: a 2027 first-round pick, a 2028 first-round pick and a 2027 fourth-round pick, with a 2028 fifth-rounder heading to Tennessee.
Talk about a kings ransom.
Simmons is exactly the kind of player who can tilt a game. Since his second NFL season in 2020, he has been one of the league’s best at his position. Still, paying that kind of draft haul for one defender is tough to defend.
Recent history makes that point even louder. Just before last season, the Green Bay Packers gave up a similar package of draft assets for Dallas Cowboys edge rusher Micah Parsons.
Parsons played from Week 1 through Week 15, and Green Bay’s defense still finished 25th in success rate and 25th in rush EPA, while ranking ninth in EPA per play and sixth in dropback EPA, per RBSDM Stats. The Packers were also 19th in DVOA defense last year, per FTN Fantasy.
Ironically, their defense had been better in DVOA in 2024 before the Parsons trade.
There are other cautionary tales, too. At the 2025 trade deadline, the Indianapolis Colts sent two first-round picks and wide receiver Adonai Mitchell for cornerback Sauce Gardner. A year later, they are selling everything but the kitchen sink before the 2026 trade deadline.
The LA Rams’ Myles Garrett trade is still being judged, although the Cleveland Browns, oddly enough, have the better record right now.
If the Bears end up making a Super Bowl run or a deep playoff push, the criticism around the Simmons deal will fade. But history says giving up multiple first-round picks for one player usually carries too much risk.
The Steelers might be able to part with two first-round picks for the right player, maybe a Garrett Wilson or Chris Olave-type who could meaningfully raise the defense. But that kind of move shrinks the window fast, and if the results don’t show up immediately, the cost can linger for years.
And Pittsburgh, by its own standards, still looks like a team that needs more than one piece. If the Steelers really want to get back to winning Super Bowls, Omar Khan and assistant GM Andy Weidl have to keep building the roster the right way, from the ground up through drafting and development. With no quarterback of the future in sight, the last thing they need is to chase the Bears’ trade blueprint.
No one should be against Khan improving the roster at the deadline. But if the asking price looks anything like what Chicago paid for Jeffery Simmons, the Steelers ought to walk away.
In Other News...
Steelers May Have A Sell High Decision On Patrick Queen
Patrick Queens recent stretch has only sharpened the conversation around what the Steelers might do with him before the NFL trade deadline. The linebacker has shown the kind of impact that made him an intriguing addition in the first place, and that matters for a Pittsburgh team trying to balance present-day competitiveness with longer-term roster value.
At the same time, Queens career has been marked by uneven play, which is why some around the league could view him as a sell-high candidate if the Steelers ever decided to listen. Draft picks would be the obvious lure, but with Pittsburghs current record, a move still feels like more of a possibility to monitor than a decision thats close to being made. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Face A Costly Troy Fautanu Decision With No Easy Answer
The Steelers have a familiar front-burner issue taking shape on the offensive line, and it involves a player they invested heavily in just last year. Troy Fautanu, a 2024 first-round pick, has flashed enough to keep the organization intrigued, but his play has also come with enough uneven stretches to make the long-term math tricky. Pittsburgh is already looking ahead to contract talks for other young linemen such as Zach Frazier and Mason McCormick, which only adds to the pressure of getting the tackle situation right.
Fautanus future now sits in that awkward space between promise and commitment, where the Steelers have to decide how much patience they want to buy and how much risk they are willing to carry. Exercise the option and they are betting on growth, but waiting too long could leave them exposed if he takes the next step elsewhere. For a team trying to stabilize its offensive line for the long haul, it is the kind of decision that can shape more than one season. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Finally Have A Better Read On Two Key Returns
The Steelers are getting a clearer picture on two injured players whose returns could matter as the season wears on. Roman Wilson has recently begun working with the rehab group, which at least puts him on the path back after Week 10, while Derrick Harmon remains on injured reserve without yet taking that step. For a team trying to manage depth and keep options open, any progress on that front is worth tracking.
Mike McCarthy sounded optimistic that everyone currently on injured reserve has a chance to get back on the field this season, but the two cases are not moving at the same pace. Wilson is the closer of the pair to a return, while Harmons timeline is still a little murkier, even though he could be eligible after Week 9. For Pittsburgh, the next update on both will say a lot about how much help is still coming. [Read more 🡒]