Mike Tomlin may be off the Steelers’ sideline, but he is not out of Pittsburgh’s control.
Because the franchise still holds his rights through the 2027 season, any team that wants to pry him away from NBC would have to deal with the Steelers first. That wrinkle changes how fans should think about Tomlin’s future. He is not just a former coach waiting for a new job; he is an asset, and Jon Gruden thinks Pittsburgh should treat him like one.
On the “Not Just Football” podcast, Cam Heyward raised the idea of the Steelers trading Tomlin, and Gruden didn’t hesitate to push the price up. His argument was built around the way the league works now, with teams getting less polished talent out of college and leaning more heavily on coaching to shape players and staffs.
“So, if you get a guy like Mike Tomlin, he’s going to hire a good group of coaches, and he’s going to develop players; that’s worth a lot more than a first-round pick, if you ask me.”
That kind of valuation is bigger than the usual coaching-market baseline, but the most recent major deal gives it some shape. When the New Orleans Saints sent Sean Payton to the Denver Broncos, they got the 29th overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft and a 2024 second-round pick, while Denver also received a 2024 third-round selection.
Payton’s path back to the sideline makes the comparison even more relevant. He spent the 2022 season as a Fox Sports NFL studio analyst before returning to coaching with Denver in 2023. Tomlin is in television now too, and Pittsburgh’s control of his rights through 2027 means the Steelers would still have leverage if another team convinced him to come back.
That’s why Gruden’s first-round-plus logic does not sound far-fetched. A coach with Tomlin’s résumé, presence, and command of a locker room would draw attention fast from a team with an impatient owner, a roster that can win now, and no desire to start over.
Still, there is plenty of room for disagreement, and Steelers fans have their own reasons to bristle at the idea that Tomlin’s value is tied to his ability to build a staff. The source material notes that his coaching tree never really took off, and that virtually none of his coordinators moved on to NFL head coaching jobs. It also points to names like Keith Butler, Teryl Austin, Randy Fichtner, and Matt Canada, who often stayed in place even when their units had stalled.
Tomlin tended to rely on veteran assistants or promote from within, a style that brought continuity but did not often produce fresh schematic ideas. That history makes Gruden’s confidence in Tomlin’s staff-building ability a tougher sell for some in Steelers Nation.
Where Gruden really lands his punch is on Tomlin’s communication. He called Tomlin’s word choice and his ability to hammer home a message “rare” and “very unique,” and said Tomlin won’t let go of a point until it sticks.
That kind of trait could matter enough to push a trade package toward what Denver paid for Payton, especially if the right team believes Tomlin can bring order and direction right away. Pittsburgh’s return would depend on how many clubs wanted in, but the Payton deal at least gives Gruden’s bold price tag a real-world reference point.
For now, Tomlin is staying put in the NBC studio, where life is a lot less stressful than coaching an NFL team.
In Other News...
Steelers Camp Battle Is Putting Travis Homer In A Brutal Spot
Travis Homer came to Pittsburgh as the kind of depth signing teams make when they want a steady back who can also help on special teams. On paper, that should give him a clear lane to the roster, but camp has turned into a tougher evaluation than a straightforward depth chart battle, with the Steelers sorting through several backs who can all make some sort of case.
Kaleb Johnson is part of that mix, and Eli Heidenreich adds another layer because he can help on offense and in the kicking game. For Homer, the uncomfortable part is that his fate may have less to do with what he does than with how the rest of the room performs and how the Steelers decide to build the back end of the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Suddenly Face A Bigger Question About Will Howard
Will Howards standing in Pittsburgh is drawing attention for reasons that go beyond the usual rookie camp chatter. Ray Fittipaldo has pushed back on the notion that the Steelers should view the sixth-round quarterback as a movable asset, pointing out that Howard has not even taken a preseason snap and still has to prove himself in training camp before anyone can start assigning real value to him.
The bigger picture is that the Steelers do not appear to be treating Howard like a disposable piece. Mike McCarthy has shown investment in his development since January, which makes the trade-bait talk sound more speculative than realistic, even if Howards path to a roster role remains tied to how he performs over the next few weeks. For now, his future is less about outside interest and more about whether he can force the team to keep him in the mix. [Read more 🡒]