Joey Porter Jr Is Making Steelers Secondary Questions Even Harder

Steelers fans are left questioning the trade after Joey Porter Jr.'s stellar play for the Cowboys highlights Pittsburgh's defensive woes.

The Pittsburgh Steelers got a brutal reminder in Week 10 that their own problems don’t disappear just because another defense is having a rough year.

Dallas coughed up 46 points at home to the San Francisco 49ers, and only hours later Pittsburgh’s defense was getting carved up by Joe Burrow and the Cincinnati Bengals in a blowout loss that included more than 400 passing yards and four touchdowns allowed. That backdrop makes Joey Porter Jr.’s run with the Cowboys stand out even more.

Since the trade announced on October 1, Porter has appeared in five games since Week 4 and played 205 total defensive snaps. On 136 coverage snaps, he has been targeted 12 times and allowed only three catches for 19 yards, a tiny 1.58 yards per target, along with a 39.6 passer rating, per Pro Football Focus [$].

The Steelers are seeing the contrast in real time.

In Week 10 alone, Pittsburgh cornerback Asante Samuel Jr. gave up 135 yards on seven targets. For the season, Samuel has allowed 460 yards and three touchdowns without an interception, and opposing quarterbacks have posted a 112.0 passer rating against him.

Porter, meanwhile, keeps forcing quarterbacks to look elsewhere. Even with Dallas’ defense struggling around him, he’s been the kind of corner who can take one receiver out of the picture entirely. The Cowboys’ issues are still the Cowboys’ issues; Porter just hasn’t been one of them.

The advanced numbers back that up too. Entering Week 11, Porter is the NFL’s No. 1 cornerback in catch rate allowed over expected and ranks among the best at limiting targets per coverage snap, according to football data scientist Sam Hoppen. Put those together, and he’s sitting in a class of his own.

Cornerback target rate vs catch rate over expected:

JPJ as advertised for the Cowboys pic.twitter.com/TQzc4HtS0y

  • Sam Hoppen (@SamHoppen) November 17, 2026

There is still one familiar flaw in Porter’s game: penalties. He has already been flagged four times in five games, and every one of those penalties has come over the past four contests.

Even so, the bigger picture is hard to miss. Porter looks like the same press-man corner who can erase a top receiver, and that’s exactly the kind of player Pittsburgh could have used when it had to deal with Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins.

The Steelers won’t see many passing attacks on that level the rest of the way unless they run into the Bengals again in the playoffs. Outside of one tough road trip to the Jacksonville Jaguars, Patrick Graham’s defense will mostly face subpar quarterbacks and few elite receiving threats down the stretch.

That doesn’t make the absence any less noticeable. Pittsburgh is starting to feel the Joey Porter Jr.-sized hole in its secondary, especially when the competition gets serious. Porter hasn’t fixed Dallas’ defense, which remains near the bottom of the league, but he has played some of the best football of his four-year career while doing it.

In Other News...

Steelers QB Future Is Suddenly Looking A Lot More Like Drew Allar

The Steelers quarterback picture has shifted quickly since Aaron Rodgers retired and Mason Rudolph moved toward the end of his contract, leaving the franchise with a clear opening under center. Pittsburgh answered by selecting Drew Allar in the 2026 NFL Draft, and the rookies preseason work has only added to the sense that the team may already be looking ahead to him as the next man up.

Insiders around the league are now treating Allar as a real candidate to open the 2027 season as the starter, which says plenty about both his early impression and the uncertainty in the room behind him. For a team that has spent years trying to stabilize the position, the Steelers suddenly have a young quarterback whose timeline may be arriving faster than expected. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Quarterback Contracts Reveal What Pittsburgh Is Really Betting On

The Steelers have quietly built some flexibility into their quarterback plans by attaching 2026 incentives to both Aaron Rodgers and Mason Rudolph, a sign that Pittsburgh is keeping its options open beyond the immediate season. Rodgers can add up to $2.5 million through playoff wins and playing time, while Rudolphs path to extra money is tied to reaching at least half of the offensive snaps and helping the team get into the postseason.

Rudolphs contract situation makes the arrangement especially interesting because he is scheduled to hit free agency after the 2026 season. If Pittsburgh likes how things unfold, there is at least a plausible path to bring him back and let him compete for the starting job in 2027, which says plenty about how the Steelers are trying to balance short-term stability with a longer view at the position. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Suddenly Have A Nick Herbig Problem Before Eagles Game

Nick Herbigs status has become a real storyline for Pittsburgh as the Steelers get ready for a tough Week 11 trip to Philadelphia. The second-year edge rusher was listed as a non-participant in practice because of a hip and ribs injury, an issue he picked up in the Week 10 win over Cincinnati before still managing to finish the game.

The timing is less than ideal with the Eagles waiting next on the schedule, and Pittsburgh now has to sort out its pass-rush rotation without knowing whether Herbig will be available. For a defense that leans on pressure off the edge, his practice absence adds another layer of uncertainty as the Steelers head into one of their biggest tests of the season. [Read more 🡒]