Steelers fans got a little more ammo in the George Pickens debate this week.
Pickens, now with the Dallas Cowboys, showed up on FanSided’s list of the most overrated players in the NFL ahead of the 2026 season. The rankings were compiled by FanSided’s NFL editorial team, and Pickens landed tied for eighth with Indianapolis Colts cornerback Sauce Gardner after receiving seven vote points.
That placement comes despite a big 2025 season in Dallas. Pickens finished with 93 catches, 1,429 receiving yards and nine touchdowns, numbers that would normally put him in a much different conversation.
But the case against him isn’t about raw production. FanSided’s argument centered on the same issues that followed him out of Pittsburgh: attitude, inconsistency and the way he has disappeared in key moments.
His final regular-season game with the Steelers was held up as the example. In a game the Steelers had to have against the Cincinnati Bengals, with playoff seeding on the line, Pickens managed just one catch on six targets for zero yards against one of the league’s worst defenses.
That kind of showing is why some around the league still view him as more volatile than reliable. He has clearly produced since entering the NFL, piling up 4,270 receiving yards over his first four seasons.
But for critics, the problem has never been whether he can make plays. It’s whether he stays engaged when things get tough.
The tag price only adds to the conversation. Pickens is set to earn $27.298 million fully guaranteed on the franchise tag, and not every voter was convinced that kind of commitment is worth the baggage that can come with it.
Still, there’s no denying his talent. Even with the concerns, Pickens is coming off a season that showed why teams keep betting on him. The risk, though, is obvious: a receiver who can look unstoppable one week and then vanish when his team needs him most.
In Other News...
Najee Harris Next Stop Says Plenty About His NFL Value
Najee Harris has found another landing spot, and it says something about how the league still views the former Steelers running back as a useful piece. After moving on from Pittsburgh and spending time with the Chargers, Harris is now headed to New York, where the Giants have turned to him for added backfield help behind rookie Cam Skattebo.
For the Giants, the appeal is straightforward: Harris brings experience, size and a chance to steady a rushing group that can use more depth. The next step in his career comes with a health question attached, though, and his ability to work his way back into form will determine how much of a role he can carve out in New York's offense. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers May Have Dodged A Frustrating Draft Mistake With Makai Lemon
The Steelers had wide receiver Makai Lemon in play during the draft, only to watch Philadelphia take him earlier and remove him from the board. Since then, Lemons early pro start has been slowed by a hamstring injury that has kept him out of multiple practices and offseason activities, a reminder that draft-day disappointment does not always stay that way for long.
Pittsburgh moved on by taking offensive tackle Max Iheanachor instead, and the early return has at least given the Steelers a steadier spring story to follow. Iheanachor has been active in training camp despite a minor injury setback, while Lemon is still working through the kind of availability issues that can make a promising name feel a lot less painful to miss. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Future Just Took A Brutal Hit Despite Drew Allar Hope
The Steelers have at least one reason to feel better about the future in rookie quarterback Drew Allar, whose preseason showing turned heads after he directed three touchdown drives in a game. Head coach Mike McCarthy was upbeat about what he saw from Allar, and the early returns only added to the sense that Pittsburgh may have found a long-term answer at the most important position.
Even so, the bigger picture around the franchise remains bleak. ESPNs latest NFL future outlook slotted the Steelers near the bottom of the league at No. 30, a harsh verdict built on coaching, the roster outside quarterback, the quarterback spot itself, and the front office. For a team that has spent years trying to keep one eye on the present and one on what comes next, that kind of ranking is a blunt reminder that one promising rookie does not erase the work still ahead. [Read more 🡒]