Pittsburgh got the win in Week 1, but DK Metcalf handed Steelers fans a brutal reminder of why his contract is going to be under the microscope all season.
Against the Atlanta Falcons, Aaron Rodgers kept looking his way early and often, and Metcalf just didn’t deliver. He was flagged twice for offensive pass interference after pushing off at the top of his route, then dropped a sharp Rodgers throw over the middle in the second half.
By the time it was over, he had caught only four of 10 targets for 40 yards, a meager 4.0 yards per target. With the penalties, the missed chances, and the drop, it was one of the roughest outings of his career.
That’s what makes this so hard to swallow for the Steelers. Last offseason, they gave up a valuable second-round pick to land Metcalf, then handed him a four-year, $132 million extension that put him near the top of the wide receiver pay scale at an average of nearly $33 million per year.
That kind of investment comes with a simple expectation: production you can count on. On Sunday, Pittsburgh didn’t get anywhere close to that.
The ugly part is that this wasn’t just one bad game floating in a vacuum. Metcalf was coming off a disappointing 2025 campaign in which he finished with 59 receptions on 99 targets for 850 yards and six touchdowns. So when Week 1 started the same way, it only deepened the concern around a player the Steelers need to be much more than a volatile target.
And that’s the bigger issue here. Metcalf can still look dominant when everything is clicking, but too often he swings between electric and unreliable. Last season, Pro Football Focus gave him a 71.1 overall grade, which ranked 41st among 128 qualifying receivers, a pretty clear snapshot of where he stood in the league.
The Steelers don’t need Metcalf to be perfect. They do need him to look like the guy Rodgers can trust when the game tightens up.
Right now, that’s not the image he’s projecting. Pittsburgh escaped with a 20-13 win thanks to T.J.
Watt and the defense, but the offense has a real problem if its highest-paid pass catcher keeps playing like this.
In Other News...
Terry Bradshaw Just Said What Steelers Fans Are Thinking About This Era
Terry Bradshaw had the kind of blunt take Steelers fans could relate to on FOX NFL Sunday, saying the one thing he was most interested in this season was watching Mike McCarthy in Pittsburgh. Bradshaw pointed to McCarthys track record with Aaron Rodgers and the simple reality of a new coach taking over after Mike Tomlin, making it clear this was the change he wanted to watch closest.
Bradshaw did not try to hide his lean toward the Steelers while the rest of the studio crew was previewing the NFL slate. For Pittsburgh fans, the interest is obvious: any coaching switch invites questions about style, quarterback play and whether a new voice can shift the direction of an era, and Bradshaws comments captured that curiosity without pretending the transition will be easy to sort out. [Read more 🡒]
T.J. Watt Just Answered The Steelers Question Fans Feared Most
T.J. Watt opened the season the way the Steelers needed him to, flashing the kind of disruptive play that can change a game in a hurry. Against the Atlanta Falcons in Week 1, he piled up two sacks, two quarterback hits, three tackles for loss and even took an interception back for a pick-six, giving Pittsburgh exactly the sort of defensive spark that has long been central to its identity.
For a defense built around pressure up front, Watts early showing mattered as much for reassurance as it did for the win itself. There had been questions after last season about whether he could still be the same dominant force, but this was a reminder that he remains the player opponents have to account for every snap, and that the Steelers ceiling on defense still runs through him. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Win Came With One Clear Reason For Concern
The Steelers opened the season with a win over Atlanta, but the victory was shaped as much by what happened on defense as anything on offense. Aaron Rodgers handled the passing game with a heavy workload, while Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle never got much room to establish the run, leaving Pittsburgh to lean on a unit that came out fast and kept the Falcons from taking control.
T.J. Watt was the headline act with two sacks and a touchdown interception, and Payton Wilson added a busy day with 13 tackles and two tackles for loss. The concern is harder to ignore on the other side of the ball, where the ground game never really found traction, and the Steelers may already be facing questions about whether that balance will hold up once the games get tighter. [Read more 🡒]