The Steelers may have drafted Eli Heidenreich in the seventh round, but the rookie is already making a real impression inside the building. The Pittsburgh native and Navy graduate has started to earn trust from the organization, and that includes one of the team’s biggest voices in DK Metcalf.
Metcalf has given Heidenreich a nickname that fits the rookie’s background and the way he carries himself. On the Ross Tucker Football Podcast, Heidenreich said the wide receiver began calling him Captain America.
"DK Metcalf, a few weeks ago in practice, he asked me, 'Are you okay if I call you Captain America?' Heidenreich stated.
"I was like, 'Absolutely DK, you can call me Captain America.' I'm honored."
It’s a fitting label for a player who spent his college years at Navy, even if the superhero comparison is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Still, the nickname says something about how quickly Heidenreich has stood out to teammates.
For now, the rookie’s path to playing time looks pretty clear. His best chance to stick in 2026 is as a running back and on special teams, where his speed and awareness could help him carve out a role early.
That special teams value could be the first step toward more work on offense. Pittsburgh has competition for the third spot at running back, with Heidenreich among the names in the mix alongside Travis Homer and second-year back Kaleb Johnson.
Training camp and the preseason will matter a lot for him. He’ll need to show the same versatility he displayed in college and at St.
Vincent College in Latrobe, Pennsylvania. The Steelers already have a power option in Rico Dowdle and a do-it-all back in Jaylen Warren, so Heidenreich’s best chance to separate himself is with something different.
That difference is speed. He flashed real burst at Navy, creating separation in space and making plays that turned heads. If that carries over, he could work his way into the Steelers’ third running back role as a rookie.
In Other News...
Steelers Offseason Just Got Hit With A Brutal National Reality Check
ESPNs Seth Walder took a skeptical look at the Steelers 2026 offseason, handing the group a C+ and casting doubt on whether the moves were enough to keep Pittsburgh in the AFC North race. The biggest concerns centered on the quarterback room and the front offices willingness to double down on Aaron Rodgers, while Walder also took issue with the trade for Michael Pittman Jr. as the team tried to reshape its offense.
Patrick Grahams defense may end up carrying much of the load if the Steelers are to stay in the conversation, and that only raises the pressure on a roster that is about to report to training camp on July 28 under new head coach Mike McCarthy. For a team trying to reset without losing its edge, the next few weeks will say plenty about whether this offseason was a calculated bet or a step backward. [Read more 🡒]
Steelers Fans Just Got A Surprising Mike McCarthy Prediction
Mike McCarthy is already getting a little extra attention before his first season with his hometown team even begins, and not just because of the usual expectations that come with coaching in Pittsburgh. NFL.com analyst Bucky Brooks recently floated McCarthy as a long-shot pick for the 2026 Coach of the Year award, a nod that says as much about the Steelers ceiling as it does about the coachs rsum.
For that kind of recognition to become real, the pieces around McCarthy have to come together quickly. Brooks pointed to Aaron Rodgers settling in at quarterback and Patrick Graham helping the defense find its edge again, which puts the spotlight on whether this group can look more complete than it did a year ago. McCarthy has built a winning career, but the award has somehow never been part of it, and this season may be the one that decides whether that changes. [Read more 🡒]