The Cleveland Browns’ head coaching search just took an unexpected turn-and it’s one that could reshape the direction of the franchise.
On Monday, the Buffalo Bills made a stunning move, parting ways with head coach Sean McDermott after yet another early playoff exit. And just like that, McDermott becomes one of the most compelling names on the coaching market. For a Browns team still weighing its options, this development could shift the conversation in a big way.
Up until now, the buzz around Cleveland’s vacancy had centered on two main candidates: current defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz and Ravens offensive coordinator Todd Monken. Schwartz, in particular, had strong momentum after leading one of the league’s most dominant defenses in 2025. But with McDermott suddenly available, the Browns may be tempted to explore a different path.
There’s some history here, too. According to reports, Cleveland has had eyes on McDermott before.
Back in 2016, general manager Andrew Berry was reportedly in favor of hiring him, but ownership went in another direction, opting for Hue Jackson instead. That decision proved costly-Jackson’s tenure was a low point for the franchise-while McDermott went on to build a consistent winner in Buffalo.
Now, with Berry still in place and the Browns once again in the market for a head coach, the opportunity to bring in McDermott might be too tempting to pass up.
McDermott’s résumé speaks for itself: a 106-58 record over nine seasons, two trips to the AFC Championship Game, and a reputation for building tough, disciplined teams. Sure, he never quite got the Bills over the Super Bowl hump, but his track record of sustained success is rare in today’s NFL. For a Browns organization that’s been defined more by instability than consistency, McDermott could offer a much-needed dose of both.
Of course, hiring McDermott wouldn’t come without consequences. He’s a defensive-minded coach, and bringing him in would likely mean moving on from Schwartz.
That’s no small decision-Schwartz’s defense was one of the league’s best last season, anchored by elite talent like Myles Garrett and rising star Mason Graham. But it’s also worth noting that McDermott would inherit that same talent, along with two first-round picks in 2026.
He wouldn’t be starting from scratch.
There’s also the question of fit. McDermott is known for his no-nonsense leadership style and defensive acumen, traits that could resonate in a locker room looking for stability. And while he may not have the upside of a hot-shot coordinator, he brings a high floor-a coach who can walk into the building and command respect from day one.
It’s not a done deal, and Cleveland isn’t the only team with an opening. McDermott could draw interest from other AFC North rivals like the Ravens or Steelers, or he could take a step back and return to a coordinator role. But if the Browns are serious about turning the page and building something sustainable, revisiting their past interest in McDermott might be more than just a footnote-it could be the move that finally brings some long-term direction to a franchise that’s been searching for it for years.
Stay tuned. The Browns’ coaching search just got a lot more interesting.