The Cincinnati Bengals faced significant challenges on defense in 2025, largely due to the inexperience of their linebacker corps. With rookies Demetrius Knight Jr. and Barrett Carter taking the field, the growing pains were evident. Both players struggled to adapt to the NFL's demands, highlighting a crucial area in need of improvement.
Knight and Carter's performances left much to be desired, raising questions about their readiness for prime-time roles. While Carter, a fourth-round pick, may not have been expected to shine immediately, the pressure was on Knight, a second-round selection, to deliver more impact than he managed.
Cincinnati's need for linebacker reinforcement is clear, and exploring free agency could be a wise move. Enter Tremaine Edmunds, a standout linebacker from the Chicago Bears, who is reportedly seeking a trade. Edmunds, a two-time Pro Bowler, could be the game-changer the Bengals need.
Despite the $15 million cap hit Edmunds would bring in 2026, his potential impact is undeniable. With Edmunds on the market, Bengals' director of player personnel, Duke Tobin, hinted at bold moves during the Combine, suggesting Cincinnati might finally act decisively.
The likelihood of Knight remaining a starter in Week 1 seems high, but upgrading Carter's spot with a seasoned veteran like Edmunds could make a substantial difference. Edmunds' stats speak volumes: four interceptions in 2025, an 87.2 passer rating allowed, ranking 16th in run defense by PFF, and a mere 8.8% missed tackle rate.
In contrast, Carter's numbers tell a different story: one interception, a 114.6 passer rating allowed, 83rd out of 93 in run defense, and a 14.8% missed tackle rate. The upgrade potential is clear.
Given Edmunds' availability, the Bears' negotiating position is weakened, possibly allowing the Bengals to acquire him without breaking the bank. Instead of gambling on another late-round draft pick, Cincinnati could secure a proven leader in Edmunds, whose experience and production would be invaluable.
As Edmunds approaches his 28th birthday with eight solid NFL seasons, the Bengals have a chance to inject veteran leadership into their defense. Meanwhile, Knight, with one challenging season behind him, turns 26 this July.
Keep an eye on the Bengals' draft strategy this year. Will they opt for seasoned talent or continue to build through youth?
The decision could shape their defensive fortunes moving forward. Stay tuned!