Aaron Rodgers Is Giving Steelers A Quarterback Problem They Can't Ignore

As Aaron Rodgers' struggles put Pittsburgh's offense under the microscope, the Steelers must decide whether to chart a different course amid disappointing advanced stats and missed opportunities.

Aaron Rodgers’ latest stretch is forcing the Steelers to face an uncomfortable truth: the box score is doing him a favor.

Pittsburgh’s offense has plenty of issues around him. The wide receivers aren’t separating with any consistency, and the offensive line has been uneven in pass protection. But the quarterback is still the center of everything, and Rodgers’ recent play has put a spotlight on just how shaky that position has become.

Sunday night against the Bengals in Week 10 was a rough one. Through the first three quarters, Rodgers had completed only seven passes for 27 yards while the Steelers managed just three points. He did pad the final line in garbage time, finishing 15 of 29 for 143 yards and two meaningless touchdowns, but that stat line doesn’t tell the real story.

The deeper numbers are far less flattering. Entering Week 11, Rodgers ranks near the bottom of the league in almost every major advanced passing metric, according to SumerSports and Pro Football Reference, with a minimum of 100 attempts.

Here’s where he stands:

🟥31st in EPA per play (-0.13)

🟥30th in success rate (40.34%)

🟧21st in adjusted net yards per attempt (5.3)

🟧24th in ADOT (7.55)

🟧23rd in QBR (47.8)

🟥27th in time to throw (2.61)

🟥33rd in completion % (59.94%)

🟧26th in intended air yards per pass (7.2)

🟥30th in completed air yards per comp. (4.2)

🟧26th in bad throw % (17.4%)

🟨19th in on-target throw % (72.4%)

Those numbers line up with what shows up on film. EPA per play is one of the cleanest ways to measure quarterback performance, and Rodgers’ -0.13 mark puts him in the same range as the Titans’ Cameron Ward this season and behind quarterbacks like Jameis Winston, Jacoby Brissett, Malik Willis, Kyler Murray, and Michael Penix.

He also sits near the bottom of the league in success rate, completion percentage, and completed air yards per completion. On top of that, he’s getting the ball out fast, which cuts down the chance for explosive plays in Pittsburgh’s offense.

Sure, the context matters. Rodgers can’t make his receivers separate, and he can’t block for himself when the protection breaks down. But he also hasn’t done enough to lift the offense when those problems show up.

That’s why the Steelers have to be having real doubts about him, even if nobody in the building is going to say it out loud. They’ve watched this offense sink when Rodgers is off, and the advanced numbers suggest the decline is not just a bad night or two.

What stands out even more is that Rodgers’ EPA per play is worse than it was last year with Arthur Smith calling plays. It’s also lower than the EPA numbers Russell Wilson and Justin Fields posted when they were starting for Pittsburgh.

The tape paints the same picture: an aging quarterback who struggles to handle pressure, gets rid of the ball quickly, and doesn’t consistently hit throws down the field. He’s also not staying in the pocket long enough to deliver when defenders are closing in.

Even with a strong rushing attack behind him, Rodgers hasn’t been able to use it to open up the passing game. Defenses aren’t treating him like a quarterback they need to fear over the top, so they load the box and make him prove he can beat them deep.

At this point, it’s hard to say with confidence that Rodgers is even the Steelers’ best quarterback option on their own roster. And there’s no reason to view him as anything more than a baseline starter right now.

Pittsburgh brought him back for another season after a disappointing year and a rough Wild Card showing against the Houston Texans. Based on what he’s done lately, none of this should come as a surprise to anyone who watched how last season ended.

In Other News...

Steelers Still Face One Big Test After That Bengals Loss

The loss to Cincinnati did not knock Pittsburgh off course, but it did sharpen the next stretch of the season into something more revealing. At 6-3, the Steelers still have room to build toward a winning record and a playoff berth, yet the margin for comfort is thinner now with eight games left and a schedule that keeps asking for answers against quality opponents.

What comes next will say plenty about how far this team can go beyond simply getting back to the postseason. Matchups with Baltimore and Philadelphia loom as the kind of tests that can separate a sturdy contender from a team that merely survives the regular season, and Pittsburgh also has to handle the games it is expected to win if it wants to avoid putting itself in a bad spot come January. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Suddenly Have Real Hope On Mason McCormick

Mason McCormicks injury looked grim in the moment against the Cincinnati Bengals, but the early read has given the Steelers a much better sense of what they are dealing with. The rookie lineman suffered a dislocated ankle, and the fact that the injury did not include a fracture changes the outlook considerably for a team trying to hold things together late in the season.

The bigger development is the recovery path, which does not appear to require surgery and leaves at least some room for optimism down the stretch. For Pittsburgh, that means McCormick is not automatically lost for the year, and there is now a real possibility he could be back in the postseason if his rehab goes well. [Read more 🡒]

Steelers Suddenly Have A Bigger Alex Highsmith Problem Than Expected

Alex Highsmiths season has become a more complicated conversation than the Steelers probably expected when they entered the year counting on him to be one of the steadier parts of their pass rush. The edge rusher has not produced at the level Pittsburgh needs, and the problem is not just the sack total. Opposing quarterbacks are getting the ball out quickly, which has made it harder for Highsmith to finish plays and has put more pressure on the Steelers to evaluate what their long-term edge rotation should look like.

Nick Herbigs recent contract extension only sharpens that discussion, because it gives Pittsburgh another young piece to build around while Highsmiths future becomes less certain. The Steelers still have time to see whether his play rebounds, but the broader question is already there: whether they eventually look to move him, or simply ride out the rest of his deal and let the contract expire after the 2027 season. [Read more 🡒]