The Pittsburgh Pirates are facing a familiar foe: the struggle for reliable relief pitching. On Saturday at PNC Park, the bullpen's woes were on full display as the team was just one strike away from a comeback victory. Instead, they found themselves on the wrong end of a 9-7 loss to the Cincinnati Reds, falling to one game under .500.
The pivotal moment came in the ninth inning when Gregory Soto, tasked with closing out the game, delivered a 2-2 fastball that drifted over the heart of the plate. Reds' slugger Eugenio Suárez seized the opportunity, launching the ball over the right-field fence to give Cincinnati the lead.
This marked the Pirates' 17th blown save in 34 opportunities this season, putting them on a troubling trajectory. Historically, the team's worst save rate since saves became an official stat in 1969 was 48.3%, a record set in 1985.
After the game, Pirates manager Don Kelly emphasized the need for improvement in tight situations. "We've got to get better in games like that," Kelly stated. "We have to find a way to win them, and that comes in a lot of different ways."
One potential solution could be external reinforcements. The Pirates attempted to bolster their bullpen in the offseason by signing Soto to a one-year, $7.75 million contract. Despite being a two-time All-Star, Soto has converted only 11 of his 15 save opportunities.
In the ninth inning, Soto's pitch count climbed to 33 as the Reds strategically used their ABS challenges, winning two out of three. Soto allowed a single and issued two walks, setting the stage for Suárez's heroics. Despite reaching two strikes against Suárez, the Reds' designated hitter adjusted his approach to simply make contact, ultimately driving the ball out of the park.
June has been particularly unkind to Soto, who has posted a 12.15 ERA in 6 2/3 innings. This is a stark contrast to his dominant performance earlier in the season, where he boasted a 1.95 ERA, a .109 batting average against, and a 0.76 WHIP.
"Definitely, it's frustrating," Soto admitted through translator Stephen Morales. "But at the end, that's part of our job. We're gonna continue to go out there and do our job, and it's gonna happen sometimes, but just trying to minimize it."
The Pirates' bullpen struggles extend beyond Soto. The team ranks 19th in Major League Baseball with a 4.41 bullpen ERA.
They've suffered four losses when leading after seven innings and three when leading after eight. Even their most reliable arms have faltered at times, as evidenced by Evan Sisk's performance on Saturday.
Sisk allowed two runners in a tie game during the sixth inning, forcing Yohan Ramírez into a difficult situation that resulted in two runs scored.
There was a glimmer of hope earlier in the series, as the Pirates' bullpen delivered 11 2/3 scoreless innings in relief during their homestand against the Mariners and the early part of Friday's game. However, the series against Cincinnati proved challenging, with starters Paul Skenes and Jared Jones unable to reach the sixth inning, leaving the bullpen to shoulder the load.
Help is on the horizon with Wilber Dotel expected to return from the injured list soon. While Dotel showed promise before his injury, relying on a rookie to address such significant issues is far from ideal.
With 17 blown saves in 83 games, it's hard not to wonder what might have been. If the Pirates had managed to convert even half of those opportunities, they would boast a record of 49-34, placing them in a strong position for the National League Wild Card and within striking distance of the NL Central-leading Brewers. The path ahead is clear: the Pirates need to shore up their bullpen if they hope to turn their season around.
In Other News...
Pirates Rumored Catcher Swing Could Test Everything Fans Fear About This Deadline
The catching market is suddenly one of the more intriguing places for the Pirates to look as the deadline approaches, and it is easy to understand why. Pittsburgh has been linked in speculation to names such as Luis Arraez and Willson Contreras while also weighing whether it should lean into its current group or try to add a more proven bat behind the plate, all against the backdrop of a payroll that leaves little room for mistakes.
Endy Rodriguez has given the club a reason to think twice about chasing a big swing, especially now that he is healthy again and Joey Bart is out of the picture. The question for the front office is whether it wants to spend real prospect capital to solve a need that might already have an internal answer, or whether the smarter play is to stay patient and shop on the margins instead of forcing a move that could cost too much future value. [Read more 🡒]
Ben Cherington's Bullpen Comments Won't Calm Frustrated Pirates Fans
The Pirates bullpen has been one of the early-season sore spots dragging down a club that still wants to think it can stay in the playoff chase, and Ben Cherington did nothing to pretend otherwise during an appearance on The Pirates Insider Show. The general manager acknowledged the relief corps needs help, which at least matched what frustrated fans have been watching unfold, and he pointed to the teams one bullpen-related move so far, the trade that brought Hunter Stratton in from the Braves for catcher Joey Bart.
Cheringtons comments, though, also made clear that any larger fix is not going to arrive right away. He said bullpen trades are likely, but they may not come until after the July draft, pushing the meaningful reshaping of the relief mix closer to the trade deadline than to the present moment. For a fan base already anxious about how much damage the bullpen has done, that timetable is probably the least reassuring part of all. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Injury Picture Just Took Another Frustrating Turn
Ben Cheringtons latest injury update offered one bit of progress and two reminders of how quickly the Pirates depth can get tested. Oneil Cruz is moving forward in his rehab from hand fractures, with the shortstop beginning gripping exercises and heading to Bradenton, Florida to continue the recovery process after having his cast removed. It is not a finish line, but it is at least a sign that one of Pittsburghs most important lineup pieces is turning a corner.
The rest of the picture was less encouraging. Wilber Dotel began a rehab assignment, but his recovery has already required a reassessment after he felt some discomfort, while Spencer Horwitz is facing a longer absence after suffering a left hamstring injury in late June. Horwitz had become a useful middle-order presence before getting hurt, and the Pirates now have to keep piecing together the infield and lineup while waiting for the injury count to settle down. [Read more 🡒]