PITTSBURGH - Tyler Callihan has spent his baseball life answering the same question in different forms: where exactly does he fit?
When MLB clubs scouted him out of Providence School of Jacksonville (Fla.), they loved the left-handed swing. The position, though, was another matter.
So Providence head coach Mac Mackiewitz turned him into a moving target, using him all over the field. Years later, that wandering path has put Callihan on the doorstep of a rare club: he wants to become the 24th player in MLB history to appear at all nine positions.
That chase puts him alongside Pirates manager Don Kelly, who finished the feat during his nine-year Major League career. Only 10 players have done it in a single season, and five have managed it in one game. Callihan still has work to do, with catcher, shortstop and center field left to complete the set.
For now, the versatility has given him the longest Major League run of his career.
“You're not gonna hit every day. You're gonna hit a homer every day, unless he's him,” Callihan said. “But being able to contribute in any way [defensively] helps the team, and helps make me feel valuable.”
Kelly knows the appeal of the challenge. When he was working toward the nine-position milestone, he treated it like a “puzzle,” taking grounders at third base on a regular basis and filling in wherever needed.
Callihan has taken the same approach. If he’s starting somewhere, he gets his work there.
If he’s not in the lineup, he tries to prepare for where he might be asked to jump in later.
The routine is demanding, and Callihan admits he wants more consistency. Still, he sees the benefit in the daily grind.
“I think it's just something you have to really focus on every single day that you're at the position,” Callihan said. “You can't just go through the motions.
When I get my reps at third base in practice, I can't just do it like I'm doing it every day. It's like, ‘All right, I have to pay attention to what I'm doing, so I can get better.’”
The gear alone tells part of the story. Callihan uses an 11 1/2 inch glove for the infield and is breaking in an 11 3/4 inch glove for third base.
In the outfield, he uses one of Bryan Reynolds’ back-ups, a 12 3/4 inch web, after losing his own during his trade from Cincinnati. At first base, he’s using one of Spencer Horwitz’s gloves while working in his own, which he’s borrowing from Billy Cook.
The Pirates acquired Callihan from Cincinnati on March 4, and he made his debut for Pittsburgh on May 28. He appeared in just four MLB games in 2025 before fracturing his left forearm in the outfield. Out there, he was still relatively new to the position; he had rarely played the outfield before reaching Double-A in 2024.
Callihan entered pro ball as a second baseman, but the Reds had Elly De La Cruz and Matt McLain emerging in the middle infield, so he shifted to the corner outfield. He added more reps in the Arizona Fall League, and when Austin Hays went down in 2025, Callihan got his chance.
Center field is the only position he hasn’t played yet, and he thinks the move would come easily.
“It wouldn’t be difficult at all,” he said, pointing to the reads as something that would likely be simpler there.
Mackiewitz sees it the same way.
“He’s versatile,” Mackiewitz said. “Embedded in him, he loves challenges, and he's a baseball junkie.”
Callihan has logged the most time at second base over the course of his life, while Mackiewitz believes third base is his best fit. Shortstop was one of his main positions in high school, and he also mixed in first base for Team USA.
Callihan, though, doesn’t pick a favorite. He says he goes through “phases.”
He’s already checked off two of the toughest boxes. Callihan has pitched twice for the Pirates in blowout losses, leaning on the mound skills he showed in high school.
“I was way more nervous for that than I was for any of my [at-]bats,” Callihan joked.
Catching may be the final hurdle before he can complete the full set. Callihan is the Pirates’ emergency catcher.
He caught now Rangers starter Jack Leiter for Team USA in Panama and served as Providence’s backup catcher behind Nathan Hickey, who is now in Triple-A for the Red Sox. In Pittsburgh, he has at least started getting comfortable with the equipment, catching off a pitching machine a few weeks ago.
He hopes that if he does catch in a big league game, it comes in a comfortable spot on the scoreboard. But with injuries piling up around the Pirates, his willingness to go anywhere has already mattered.
“It's whatever the team needs,” Callihan said. “If I can contribute in any way, that's kind of what I've done my whole life. I've played all positions my whole life, so it doesn't bother me or anything, I love doing it."
In Other News...
Mets Deadline Shift Could Hand Pirates The Bullpen Fix They Need
The Mets decision to sell at the deadline could give the Pirates a timely opening if they want to shore up a bullpen that still looks like one of the cleaner places to upgrade. New York is making most of its roster available, and that includes the kind of late-inning arms Pittsburgh has been hunting for as it tries to turn a solid overall roster into a more reliable one in close games.
For the Pirates, the appeal is obvious: they do not need a wholesale makeover, just a few more trustworthy outs when games tighten up in the late innings. That is why the Mets bullpen situation matters so much in Pittsburgh, where the front office can now weigh fit, health and cost against a market that suddenly has more options than it did a few days ago. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Could Make One Deadline Move Fans Never Saw Coming
Even with the Pirates hanging around the playoff race, the front office may be thinking more about fit than sentiment as the deadline approaches. Bob Nightengale reported that Pittsburgh has enough outfield depth to at least listen on Oneil Cruz, a player whose talent has always made him one of the most intriguing names on the roster but who has not fully matched the expectations that followed him to the majors.
Cruz is currently on the 60-day injured list with a hand injury, and the timing only adds another layer to a decision that could say plenty about how aggressive the Pirates want to be. If the club is serious about upgrading the bullpen and possibly adding another starter, moving a recognizable piece from a crowded outfield would be a bold way to do it, especially with the deadline pressure starting to build. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Just Reached A Crucial Spencer Horwitz Turning Point
Spencer Horwitz is finally moving toward a return, with the Pirates first baseman slated to begin a rehab assignment with Single-A Bradenton on July 21. It is the kind of checkpoint Pittsburgh has been waiting for after Horwitz went down in late June, and it gives the club a clearer sense of when one of its more stable bats might be back in the mix.
The timing matters because the Pirates have been piecing together their lineup around a wave of injuries, including absences for Endy Rodrguez, Konnor Griffin and Oneil Cruz. Horwitzs return would help steady a spot that has already required some shuffling, and the next step will be seeing how he responds once game action resumes in Bradenton. [Read more 🡒]