The Mariners just put a price tag on the kind of third baseman the Pirates have been hunting for, and it’s not a small one.
Seattle landed Gold Glove third baseman Maikel Garcia from the Royals in a six-player blockbuster Wednesday, sending pitchers Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and José A. Ferrer to Kansas City.
The Mariners also got right-hander James McArthur and pitching prospect L.P. Langevin in the deal.
For Pittsburgh, the message is hard to miss: if you want a real solution at third base, you’re probably going to have to pay up.
Garcia is the exact sort of target the Pirates should be chasing. He’s 26, brings elite defense, and still has plenty of offensive upside.
He’s under contract through 2030 with a club option for 2031, and he backed that profile in 2025 with a Gold Glove, an All-Star nod and a .286/.351/.449 line with 16 home runs and 23 stolen bases. Injuries cut him down to 82 games in 2026, when he posted a .715 OPS, but the long-term appeal clearly stayed strong enough for Seattle to make the move.
That’s where the Pirates’ problem gets tricky. They’ve spent years stockpiling pitching, and on paper, that’s supposed to give them leverage. Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler and Braxton Ashcraft give Pittsburgh a promising group of young arms, while Mitch Keller and Carmen Mlodzinski add more names to the mix.
But not all pitching depth is equal. Skenes should be off-limits.
Jones and Chandler are central to the long-term rotation picture. Ashcraft has made himself tough to move.
Keller’s value is clouded by an injury-shortened, disappointing season, even with his salary attached. Mlodzinski is the one arm who could make sense in trade talks, especially since his future role isn’t settled.
Even so, it’s fair to wonder whether a package built around him would be enough to land an established, controllable third baseman.
Seattle’s trade suggests maybe not.
The Mariners weren’t giving away front-line aces, but they still moved three pitchers with big-league experience. Miller had a 4.17 ERA in 2026, Evans missed the entire season after elbow surgery, and Ferrer finished with a 4.18 ERA.
Miller, in particular, still carries real rotation upside. Seattle could stomach that because it has pitching to spare.
Pittsburgh may not be in the same spot, especially with reports that the Pirates are also looking to add pitching, including left-handed arms.
That’s the bind for Ben Cherington. The Pirates need a real answer at third base, and they need it badly enough that the current mix feels thin.
Nick Gonzales hit .303 in 2026, but his move to third was rough on defense, and his minus-15 defensive runs saved tells the story. Jared Triolo gives them a much better glove, but the bat hasn’t been enough to make him a clean everyday fix.
And with Brandon Lowe’s future in Pittsburgh uncertain, the club could be staring at another infield hole that needs real production.
Seattle saw its weakness, identified a player who could solve it for years, and paid the freight.
“We didn’t think he would be available, and lo and behold.”
Cherington doesn’t have to copy that exact approach. Shipping out multiple young pitchers for one infielder could be a dangerous gamble given Pittsburgh’s current situation. But the Pirates also can’t keep treating pitching depth as both sacred and endlessly available when it’s convenient.
If they want a legitimate everyday third baseman, they may have to move a pitcher they’d prefer to keep. The other route is spending enough to land an established bat without stripping the staff.
Neither path is easy. The fallback is the one Pittsburgh has leaned on too often: bargain hunting, internal experiments and hoping the answer shows up on its own.
In Other News...
Pirates May Finally Fix One Lineup Flaw At A Real Cost
The Pirates have spent plenty of time this winter looking for a way to balance out a lineup that can still use more right-handed thump, and Casey Schmitt has surfaced as a possible fit. The Giants infielder is coming off a strong 2026 season and has shown he can handle left-handed pitching, which is exactly the sort of skill set that can help a roster built around matchup advantages rather than pure star power.
Getting him, though, would not come cheaply. Pittsburgh is said to be weighing whether Carmen Mlodzinski is the kind of pitcher it can afford to move, and that is no small decision for a club that values his ability to work both as a starter and out of the bullpen. The talks are still speculative, but they underscore the same familiar front-office dilemma: whether to spend from an area of depth to patch a lineup flaw that has lingered too long. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Fans Are Revisiting The Johan Oviedo Trade For One Reason
The Johan Oviedo trade tree is back in the conversation, and for Pirates fans it is easy to see why. Boston moved the right-hander to Arizona for lefty Luke Dotson and a player to be named later after Oviedo had appeared in only one game for the Red Sox, which naturally sent attention back to the original deal that brought him out of Pittsburgh.
What makes this one worth revisiting from the Pirates side is the prospect haul they received in return, Jhostynxon Garcia and Jesus Travieso, and the way those pieces are being measured against what Oviedo has done since changing hands. It is the kind of transaction that can look very different over time depending on development, health and opportunity, and this latest move has only sharpened the debate about who got the better end of it. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Third Base Search Just Got A Complicated Astros Twist
The Pirates search for help at third base has already been a familiar offseason theme, but Josh Harrison added a new wrinkle when he floated Jeremy Pea as a possible fit on a podcast. It is the kind of suggestion that makes sense on paper for Pittsburgh: Pea would bring right-handed balance, postseason experience, speed and a contact-oriented approach to a lineup that could use all of it.
The complication is that landing a player like Pea is never just about fit. Houstons priorities would shape any conversation, and Peas impending free agency only adds another layer of uncertainty for a Pirates front office trying to plan carefully. There is also the broader backdrop of a looming lockout, which could make any trade talks even harder to navigate as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
