Pirates Third Base Search Just Got A Complicated Astros Twist

Could the Pirates' pursuit of Jeremy Pea address their lineup's right-handed imbalance and third base issues while providing valuable postseason experience?

Josh Harrison sees a way for the Pirates to tackle two issues at once, and it starts with a name that might surprise some fans.

Pittsburgh needs right-handed balance in the lineup, and after Nick Gonzales’s defensive struggles in 2026, third base is also a spot that needs attention. On the Bucco Territory Podcast, the former Pirates second baseman floated a trade idea that would address both: go after Houston Astros shortstop Jeremy Peña and slide him over to the hot corner.

Harrison made it clear he wasn’t talking about Isaac Paredes, the more obvious Astros name but not the best fit for PNC Park. Instead, he pointed to Peña’s athletic profile and experience as the kind of package Pittsburgh should be chasing.

"I look at the other intangibles. Sprint speed - this Pirates team is a team that we talk about team speed.

[Peña] adds that dynamic, and a guy that not only adds that dynamic, but has also played on some teams that have gone deep into the playoffs. And when you’re a team that is, you know, on the brink of that, you want to add players that have been to where you’re trying to get," Harrison said.

Peña’s postseason résumé backs that up. He was the first rookie ever to win World Series MVP during Houston’s 2022 title run, and he also took home ALCS MVP that same year. That kind of experience would matter for a Pirates club hoping to keep moving toward October.

The speed is part of the appeal, too. Peña’s 29.3 feet per second sprint speed in 2026 ranked in the 93rd percentile.

He only stole 12 bases that season and has never topped 20 in a year, but that’s tied more to Houston’s cautious approach on the bases than to any lack of ability. Paired with players like Konnor Griffin, Oneil Cruz, and Jake Mangum, he would give Pittsburgh another layer of athleticism beyond raw power.

He’d also bring a bat that fits in plenty of ways. Peña hit .277/.325/.477 in 2026 and .304/.363/.477 in 2025, with 20-homer pop and enough contact to make him a multi-dimensional addition to the lineup.

On paper, the trade match makes sense. Houston has extra infielders and needs cost-controlled pitching, while Pittsburgh has pitching to deal.

The clubs have done business before, too. But there are complications.

Houston has a new regime now, so past trade history only goes so far. The Astros would also prefer to move one of their corner infielders, such as Paredes or first baseman Christian Walker, rather than Peña.

Then there’s the bigger issue: Peña is scheduled to reach free agency after the 2027 season. Under normal circumstances, that would help lower the price in a trade.

But with the possibility of a lockout threatening games next season, figuring out fair value gets tricky fast. The Pirates would have to be careful not to give up too much for a player who might not even play a full 2027 season and could leave afterward.

One way around that would be to extend Peña, but that comes with its own challenge. The 29-year-old has turned down extension offers from the Astros before, and that was before he changed agents and hired Scott Boras, who is known for taking clients to the open market.

So this is not a simple yes-or-no proposition. Peña would clearly help Pittsburgh, but the Pirates would need to move carefully and avoid overpaying for a player whose long-term future might be uncertain. If Houston is willing to be reasonable, though, this could be the kind of move that makes a lot of sense.

In Other News...

Pirates May Finally Fix One Lineup Flaw At A Real Cost

The Pirates have spent plenty of time this winter looking for a way to balance out a lineup that can still use more right-handed thump, and Casey Schmitt has surfaced as a possible fit. The Giants infielder is coming off a strong 2026 season and has shown he can handle left-handed pitching, which is exactly the sort of skill set that can help a roster built around matchup advantages rather than pure star power.

Getting him, though, would not come cheaply. Pittsburgh is said to be weighing whether Carmen Mlodzinski is the kind of pitcher it can afford to move, and that is no small decision for a club that values his ability to work both as a starter and out of the bullpen. The talks are still speculative, but they underscore the same familiar front-office dilemma: whether to spend from an area of depth to patch a lineup flaw that has lingered too long. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Fans Are Revisiting The Johan Oviedo Trade For One Reason

The Johan Oviedo trade tree is back in the conversation, and for Pirates fans it is easy to see why. Boston moved the right-hander to Arizona for lefty Luke Dotson and a player to be named later after Oviedo had appeared in only one game for the Red Sox, which naturally sent attention back to the original deal that brought him out of Pittsburgh.

What makes this one worth revisiting from the Pirates side is the prospect haul they received in return, Jhostynxon Garcia and Jesus Travieso, and the way those pieces are being measured against what Oviedo has done since changing hands. It is the kind of transaction that can look very different over time depending on development, health and opportunity, and this latest move has only sharpened the debate about who got the better end of it. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates May Be Running Out Of Time To Keep Brandon Lowe

Brandon Lowes market is moving in a direction the Pirates had to expect, but not necessarily welcome. After declining Pittsburghs qualifying offer, the veteran infielder is drawing interest from more than half a dozen teams, with the Yankees, Blue Jays and his former Rays among the clubs in the mix as free agency keeps rolling along.

For the Pirates, the challenge is no longer just making a competitive pitch, but doing it while knowing the competition is widening. The longer this drags on, the more they have to weigh backup plans in case Lowe chooses a different landing spot, leaving Pittsburgh to regroup and keep its offseason moving. [Read more 🡒]