The Pirates’ catching pipeline has gone from promising to downright loud, and the latest rankings refresh showed it in a big way. Axiel Plaz, Easton Carmichael and Edgleen Perez all surged up Pittsburgh’s Top 30, landing at No.
6, No. 7 and No. 8, respectively. That’s a three-man climb, and it lines up with the kind of seasons each backstop is putting together.
Plaz made the biggest leap of the bunch, jumping 12 spots. Carmichael moved up nine, and Perez climbed 11. Together, they’ve become the trio of consecutively ranked catchers near the top of the list, and all three are in the middle of the best seasons of their careers.
Plaz, listed as a catcher/first baseman, has been especially eye-catching at High-A Greensboro in his first full campaign after a brief 11-game look there in 2025. The 20-year-old has hit .302 through 73 games, with 10 homers and an .854 OPS. He’s also been behind the plate for 40 of those games.
That production is a welcome step forward for a player who signed out of Venezuela for $350,000 in 2022 and got off to a blazing start in the Dominican Summer League that same year. In 32 Rookie-level games, Plaz hit .382/.500/.706 and led players with at least 80 plate appearances in OPS (1.206), wOBA (.550) and wRC+ (211). His climb through the system after that was steadier, if less explosive, until this season.
The biggest change for Plaz has been at the plate. Pirates farm director Michael Chernow pointed to his selectivity when speaking with Mayo in May, and the numbers back that up.
Plaz has cut his strikeout rate all the way down to 17.9 percent after striking out 31.3 percent of the time in 2023 and 28.4 percent in 2024. For a 5-foot-11, 165-pound catcher with real raw pop, that’s the kind of adjustment that changes a profile.
Carmichael’s rise has been just as impressive, and maybe even more immediate. After splitting catching duties with Plaz for much of the year, he was promoted to Double-A on July 24 and wasted little time making an impression. He has recorded hits in five of his first eight starts there, and on July 30 he turned in a three-hit, two-homer game for his first multihomer performance as a pro.
The 2025 third-round pick came into pro ball with a reputation for offense after starring in the Oklahoma Sooners lineup. Wrist pain after the Draft last summer slowed his production during his shortened debut, but this season has looked much more like the player Pittsburgh expected. In 74 games before the promotion, Carmichael hit .305/.350/.518 with 16 homers, and his batting average ranked second at the time he left, just behind Plaz.
The power has been impossible to miss. Carmichael is one of 11 minor league catchers with at least 18 homers, and he leads that group with only 68 strikeouts in 84 games.
The Pirates have also liked what they’ve seen on defense. His blocking and receiving have improved, and he has thrown out 42.1 percent of attempted basestealers.
Perez was the one of the three who landed on the injured list most recently, going there on July 30, but he had already built plenty of momentum before that. Acquired from the Yankees before the 2025 Trade Deadline in the David Bednar deal, Perez brings a different kind of profile to the group. He’s one of only two players in the Pirates’ Top 30 with plus arm and fielding grades, and he has thrown out 31.8 percent of runners.
At the plate, Perez has leaned on his feel for the strike zone. In 77 games for Single-A Bradenton, the 20-year-old hit .296/.385/.352 with two homers, while striking out just 37 times against 31 walks.
At 5-foot-9 and 155 pounds, he doesn’t project as a power hitter right now, though Mayo noted in the spring that his bat speed was up 5 mph when he spoke with Chernow. For now, the Pirates see a player with elite defense and solid bat-to-ball ability, and maybe more pop down the line.
In Other News...
Diamondbacks Take A Bullpen Flier As Wild Card Pressure Builds
Arizona is taking a look at a familiar bullpen arm as the race tightens, bringing in right-hander Dennis Santana on a minor league contract. The move gives the Diamondbacks another veteran option to sort through while they try to stabilize a relief group that can matter a lot in September, and Santana arrives with plenty of late-inning experience after logging 22 career saves over nine seasons.
For Pittsburgh, it is another reminder of how quickly bullpen evaluations can change. Santana was out of the picture after a rocky run in which his season went sideways, but the Diamondbacks are betting there is still something to recover from his sharper 2025 form, when he was far more dependable across 70 outings. The real question now is whether a fresh start can get him back to that version before Arizonas playoff pressure becomes even heavier. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Just Took A Quiet Bullpen Hit Fans Should Notice
The bullpen churn kept moving this week, and one of the quieter developments involved a right-hander the Pirates had only just added. Cincinnati claimed Ron Marinaccio off waivers and immediately slotted him onto its active roster, a reminder of how quickly relief depth can disappear in a season when clubs are constantly trying to patch innings and keep a fresh arm available.
For Pittsburgh, it adds another small but notable loss of bullpen inventory after bringing Marinaccio in only recently. The Reds also made room by moving Blake Dunn to the 60-day injured list, while Chase Solesky was sent to Triple-A Louisville, but the part Pirates fans will notice is how a low-profile arm can vanish almost as soon as he arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Are Putting Carmen Mlodzinski In A Spot That Could Change Everything
The Pirates are turning to Carmen Mlodzinski for a chance that could reshape his season, with manager Don Kelly announcing that the right-hander will get the ball in the next game. Mlodzinski has worked in both roles this year, starting some games and also helping out of the bullpen, but this assignment gives him a more direct path to show he belongs in a rotation spot.
The opportunity comes at a time when Pittsburgh is sorting through life without Mitch Keller, which has opened a vacancy the club now needs to cover. For Mlodzinski, it is the kind of opening that can matter far beyond one outing, because the Pirates are not just asking him to fill in - they are giving him a chance to make a case that he should stay there. [Read more 🡒]