Pirates Suddenly Face A Tough Mitch Keller Decision

The White Sox's bold move for Dustin May may prompt the Pirates to rethink their strategy with Mitch Keller, amid evolving dynamics in the pitching market.

The White Sox just threw a big number at Dustin May, and that has to make the Pirates think twice about Mitch Keller.

FanSided MLB insider Robert Murray first reported that Chicago agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million deal with the right-hander, a hefty commitment for a pitcher who finished the 2026 season with a 4.70 ERA over 145 2/3 innings split between the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers.

May is only 29 and still brings plenty of upside, but the injuries and uneven production are part of the package. Even so, the White Sox decided he was worth $17.5 million per year.

That matters in Pittsburgh because Keller’s contract has started to look like one of the trickier decisions on the Pirates’ books. The 30-year-old stumbled through 2026 with a 5.29 ERA in 22 starts, then a severe teres major injury shut him down in August. And the money keeps climbing: he’s due about $18.4 million in 2027 and $20.4 million in 2028, which leaves the Pirates on the hook for nearly $38.8 million over the final two years of his extension.

For a club with Pittsburgh’s historically limited payroll, that’s not a small bet on a pitcher coming off what was arguably his worst season.

Still, May’s deal changes the lens. Keller’s remaining contract works out to an average annual salary of about $19.4 million, barely more than May’s new figure.

May has youth on his side and a healthier 2026 workload, but Keller has a much longer record of taking the ball and holding up over a full season. From 2022 through 2025, he averaged roughly 31 starts a year and posted a 4.15 ERA.

That doesn’t mean Keller suddenly becomes easy to move. The injury concerns are real, and Pittsburgh may still have to eat salary to get a deal done. But if clubs are willing to guarantee more than $50 million to a pitcher with May’s uncertainty, Keller’s contract doesn’t look nearly as impossible to navigate as it did before.

The other wrinkle is that trading Keller could create a different problem entirely. Yes, the Pirates could wipe out nearly $39 million in future salary, but replacing him would be another matter. Pittsburgh does have a strong group of young arms in Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler and Braxton Ashcraft, yet counting on that entire group to anchor a rotation without dependable veteran depth would be a risk.

And the savings from moving Keller might not stretch very far if the Pirates have to spend again on a proven starter. That’s especially relevant with significant offensive needs still on the board, including after Brandon Lowe’s departure into free agency.

Cherington has said the organization believes Keller can bounce back in 2027, and May’s contract only gives that view more weight. One deal doesn’t set the market for every starter, but Chicago’s willingness to pay for upside instead of certainty should push Pittsburgh to reassess what Keller is actually worth.

The Pirates shouldn’t deal him just because the contract is big. They should only move him if the return makes the roster better. After the White Sox’s move, that line just got a lot harder to ignore.

In Other News...

Pirates Just Added To An Outfield Battle Fans Should Watch

The Pirates have added another name to an outfield mix that already has some intrigue, signing Chas McCormick to a minor league deal with an invitation to Spring Training. McCormick brings big league experience from his time with the Astros, and the move gives Pittsburgh another veteran option to look at as camp opens and roster spots start to sort themselves out.

He is not on the 40-man roster, which keeps the path to a job from being simple, but the addition does add more depth to a group that already includes Akil Baddoo, whom the Pirates claimed off waivers earlier this offseason. For a team still sorting through its outfield picture, McCormicks presence gives the spring competition another layer worth watching. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Decision Could Show What They Really Think Of Henry Davis

The Pirates have a roster call coming up by the November 17 deadline that could say plenty about how they view their catching depth, and especially Henry Davis. Axiel Plaz is one of the organizations top prospects, but he has only reached High-A, which makes the decision more complicated for a club that already has three catchers on the roster and a former No. 1 pick still trying to find his offensive footing.

Plaz is the kind of player teams usually try to protect when the Rule 5 Draft looms, yet carrying him would force Pittsburgh to weigh present depth against future upside. If the Pirates decide to leave him exposed, it would suggest they believe more strongly in Daviss ability to improve at the plate and settle in as part of the answer behind it. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Take A Chance On Former Astros Outfielder With Something To Prove

The Pirates are taking a low-risk look at a familiar name, signing veteran outfielder Chas McCormick to a minor league contract with an invitation to major league spring training in 2027. McCormick, who was part of Houstons 2022 World Series run, arrives in Pittsburgh as a depth addition after a difficult stretch in which injuries and declining production slowed his momentum.

A year in Triple-A with the Cubs organization helped him rebuild some value, and that was enough for the Pirates to give him another chance. For a club that is always trying to uncover useful outfield depth without spending heavily, McCormick fits the profile of a player with big-league experience, a recent reset, and something to prove as he tries to work his way back into the conversation. [Read more 🡒]