The Pirates may have a chance to bring David Bednar back home this offseason. Whether they actually should is a much messier question.
Bednar is headed for free agency after another strong run with the New York Yankees, and the fit with Pittsburgh is obvious on the surface. He was traded to New York at the 2025 deadline, and the two-time All-Star turned in another elite year, finishing the 2026 regular season with a 2.47 ERA, 35 saves and 76 strikeouts over 69 1/3 innings.
That kind of production is going to draw attention. Bednar has again looked like one of the steadiest late-inning arms in the game, and teams in need of bullpen help will notice. The Pirates are certainly among them after another season where relief inconsistency, especially in the first half, kept tripping up a roster that had enough talent to do more.
But Pittsburgh’s calculus changed when Mason Montgomery took off.
Acquired from Tampa Bay in the December 2025 deal that also brought Brandon Lowe to Pittsburgh, Montgomery turned into one of the team’s most important bullpen pieces. The 26-year-old lefty finished the year with a 2.88 ERA, 105 strikeouts in 68 2/3 innings and 18 saves, showing he could handle the kind of pressure that comes with the ninth inning.
September was the real statement month. Montgomery converted 11 of 12 save chances, logged a 2.08 ERA and picked up National League Reliever of the Month honors. He also ripped off 24 2/3 straight scoreless innings, the sort of run that changes how a front office sees its bullpen.
Ironically, the last Pirates reliever to win that monthly award was Bednar in June 2025.
So now Pittsburgh is staring at the kind of decision every club says it wants: do you pay up for a proven closer when you may already have one?
Bednar will not be a bargain. He’s entering his age-32 season and should have plenty of interest, possibly from the Yankees as well. A multiyear deal for a veteran closer would mean real money, and the Pirates have generally steered clear of that kind of spending on relievers.
Montgomery’s affordability matters here. He gives the Pirates a cheaper answer in the ninth, which should allow them to devote scarce resources elsewhere.
Still, Montgomery’s rise should not shut the door on Bednar automatically. Pittsburgh won 82 games in 2026 and still missed the postseason, which is a good reminder that one reliable closer doesn’t solve everything. The bigger need is bullpen depth, and a combination of Montgomery from the left side and Bednar from the right would give manager Don Kelly a lot of options late in games.
The odds of a reunion still feel slim if Bednar’s market grows the way it should. The Pirates have other holes to fill, and committing big money to an aging reliever comes with obvious risk. But Montgomery’s breakout shouldn’t be used as cover to do nothing.
Pittsburgh finally has a young, cost-controlled closer worth building around. What remains to be seen is whether the Pirates use that advantage to make the rest of the bullpen better - or just decide the job is done and save the money.
In Other News...
Bob Nutting Could Finally Face Pressure To Spend More
The latest labor talks around Major League Baseball have added a fresh wrinkle for teams that already live near the bottom of the spending ladder, and Pittsburgh is squarely in that conversation. Owners have floated a sweeping economic overhaul for the next collective bargaining agreement, including a salary cap and a payroll floor, as negotiations inch toward what could become a serious work stoppage with the MLB Players Association pushing back hard.
For Bob Nutting, the proposal could create a rare kind of pressure to spend, since the Pirates have long operated far below the levels being discussed. A new framework would force clubs like Pittsburgh to rethink how they build, and even by the standards of a sport used to financial haves and have-nots, it would represent a major shift in the expectations placed on ownership. [Read more 🡒]
Former Pirates Are Still Chasing October While Pittsburgh Watches Again
Pittsburgh is once again watching the postseason from home, but a handful of familiar names are still in the October mix elsewhere. Tyler Glasnow remains the most prominent former Pirate still standing, now part of the Dodgers playoff push after his route out of Pittsburgh began in the Chris Archer trade. Around him, a small group of ex-Pirates has surfaced on other contenders too, keeping a little bit of old black-and-gold bloodline alive deep into the fall.
Ryan Vilade is with the Rays, Austin Hedges is in the Guardians orbit, and Colin Holderman had been in position to be part of the same conversation before a season-ending wrist surgery took him out of the picture. The list is a reminder of how often Pittsburghs recent roster churn has left the club tracking familiar faces in October while trying to build a version of that same relevance for itself. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Face An Offseason That Will Reveal Ownerships Real Ambition
A winning season in 2026 gave the Pirates a little more to build on, but the real test is arriving now. After years without a postseason berth, Pittsburgh heads into an offseason that should say plenty about how aggressively ownership wants to push the club toward contention in 2027, especially with a core already under contract and a few more important players nearing arbitration.
The front office has roster work to do, but the bigger question is how much room it will have to operate while trying to keep the team moving forward. The Pirates are in position to make additions and still protect the foundation they have assembled, yet the choices ahead will show whether the plan is to merely stay respectable or to finally treat a playoff push like the expectation. [Read more 🡒]