The Pirates have been stuck in the same third-base loop for years, and this offseason could decide whether they finally break it or fall right back into it.
That’s the tension hanging over Pittsburgh’s search at the hot corner. Ke’Bryan Hayes once gave them elite defense there, but the bat never matched the glove.
Nick Gonzales has gone the other direction, giving the lineup a much better offensive look while creating problems in the field. So the Pirates are once again staring at a spot that needs fixing, and the front office has to be careful not to solve one issue by creating another.
Alec Bohm is one of the names that could come up. He’s coming off a rough season at the plate, hitting .249 with a .698 OPS, but he still brought some pop with 88 RBIs last season. That kind of production will tempt teams looking for help on offense.
The problem is that Bohm brings the same defensive headache the Pirates are trying to escape. In 2026, he finished with a -9 Fielding Run Value, which put him in the 4th percentile of MLB players, and he also logged -11 Outs Above Average. His range and error totals have long made him a negative in most analytical models, and Pittsburgh can’t afford to chase an “easy fix” that leaves them in the same bind.
The concern gets even sharper if Brandon Lowe isn’t brought back. If that happens, Gonzales would move to second, and third base would likely be left to some mix of Nick Yorke, Jared Triolo, and Jacob Gonzalez, with others possibly in the picture. That would be a clear step down.
A short-term free agent addition makes the most sense, especially with top prospect Murf Gray likely on the way to the majors and expected to handle third base for the foreseeable future. A one-year deal for a player trying to rebuild value would fit both sides.
The issue is that the market doesn’t offer much. Eugenio Suárez sits at the top of the third-base group, but the source makes clear he should be avoided at all costs. The Reds took a chance on him last season, and even with a .433 slugging percentage, he ended up on waivers because of how poorly he performed.
Edmundo Sosa brings solid defense and a good batting average, but he isn’t an everyday answer. After that, the options thin out fast.
For Pittsburgh, the cleaner path is to keep the known quantity in Lowe and leave Gonzales at third rather than gamble on another one-sided player like Bohm.
In Other News...
Pirates Right Field Battle Just Became Harder To Ignore
The Pirates search for stability in right field now has a little more shape to it, even if the job still looks open. General manager Ben Cherington said the club plans to keep Ryan OHearn mostly at first base and designated hitter, which takes one of the more familiar names out of the everyday outfield mix and pushes the competition back toward the younger options in camp and in the system.
Esmerlyn Valdez remains the most intriguing candidate to claim the position long term, but the Pirates want to see cleaner defense and fewer strikeouts before handing him that kind of responsibility. Jake Mangum is also in the mix for playing time, and the front office could still look for a right-handed bat to balance out Valdez and OHearn, leaving right field as one of the more interesting roster questions left to sort through. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Bullpen Search May Come Down To One Familiar Problem
The Pirates are already looking ahead to 2027, and one of the cleaner ways to shore up the bullpen could be a familiar one: shopping in free agency for a proven arm. Jonathan Loisiga is among the names in the mix after a strong 2026 season with the Diamondbacks, when he worked 67 innings and put up a 2.42 ERA while showing the kind of underlying numbers that tend to get attention from teams in need of late-inning help.
What makes the fit interesting is also what makes it complicated. Loisiga is expected to draw a multi-year major league deal, which puts the Pirates right back at the same crossroads they often face when trying to add meaningful pitching depth. The talent is there, and the need is obvious, but any real pursuit will have to be weighed against payroll limits before the front office decides how aggressive it wants to be. [Read more 🡒]
