Pirates Right Field Battle Just Became Harder To Ignore

As the Pirates aim for a strategic outfield overhaul, Ryan O'Hearn's role shifts to shore up first base and DH, while new opportunities emerge for rookie Esmerlyn Valdez.

The Pirates are trying to redraw the map in right field, and the biggest change may be how little they want to see Ryan O’Hearn out there.

At the GM Meetings this week, general manager Ben Cherington said the club is aiming to build a roster that keeps O’Hearn mostly off the grass. The preferred setup would have him splitting time at first base and designated hitter with Spencer Horwitz, with only the occasional start or late-inning appearance in right field.

That would be a shift from last season, when O’Hearn was asked to do plenty of both. Pittsburgh signed him to a two-year, $29MM deal last winter expecting him to divide his time between first base and right field, while Marcell Ozuna handled most of the DH work. That’s basically how it unfolded: O’Hearn made 42 starts in right field, 36 at first base, and 25 at DH before Ozuna’s run with the club ended in August.

There’s a pretty clear baseball case for trimming O’Hearn’s outfield work. He finished with -5 Defensive Runs Saved in right field in 2026, and his career mark there sits at -16 DRS.

First base has been a mixed bag for him too, though he has had some decent stretches at the position. Health is part of the equation as well.

O’Hearn had two separate IL stints last year because of quad strains, and the second one wiped out nearly six weeks in the second half, leaving a dent in Pittsburgh’s offense down the stretch.

If O’Hearn is parked more at first base and DH, that opens the door for Esmerlyn Valdez to get more run in right. Valdez, nicknamed The Magician, launched 17 homers in only 72 games as a rookie. A hamstring injury ended his season early, but the injury is not expected to affect his 2027 campaign.

Still, Cherington didn’t hand him the spot. He said Valdez has “ some earning to do ” before he can claim the everyday job in right field.

The power was real, but so was the swing-and-miss: Valdez struck out at a 37.6% clip. After a scorching first month, he cooled off hard, put up a .662 OPS in August, and was hitting .125 in September before the hamstring strain shut him down.

Valdez also didn’t help much with the glove. He posted -6 DRS in 72 appearances across the corner outfield spots, with most of his starts coming in right field.

If the Pirates need another internal answer, Jake Mangum is the next name in the mix. He settled in as a useful part-time piece after arriving from the Rays in the trade, giving Pittsburgh a positive defender who swiped 23 bases while bouncing around all three spots. He profiles as a classic fourth outfielder, but one who can still help in a limited role.

Pittsburgh may not be done looking outside the organization, either. Beazley reported that the Pirates won’t rule out corner outfield additions, and a right-handed bat would make sense with both Valdez and O’Hearn hitting left-handed. Randal Grichuk, Ramon Laureano, Austin Hays and Tommy Pham are among the veterans in that group.

For now, though, the clearest path looks like this: let Valdez try to win the job, keep O’Hearn anchored at first base and DH, and have Mangum ready if the Pirates need another option in right.

In Other News...

Pirates Risk Repeating A Costly Third Base Mistake This Offseason

Third base has been a problem spot for the Pirates for a while, and this offseason looks like another chance to decide whether they want to solve it with a bat, a glove or a little of both. Alec Bohm is one of the more intriguing free-agent names on the market because of his offensive upside, but his defensive metrics have been a concern, which puts Pittsburgh right back in the same debate it has faced before.

The market does not offer many clean answers, so the Pirates may have to choose between chasing a one-dimensional upgrade or taking a different route entirely. Re-signing Brandon Lowe and reshuffling the infield would give them another path, one that could help avoid repeating a costly mistake if they are not careful about how they balance production and defense at the position. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Bullpen Search May Come Down To One Familiar Problem

The Pirates are already looking ahead to 2027, and one of the cleaner ways to shore up the bullpen could be a familiar one: shopping in free agency for a proven arm. Jonathan Loisiga is among the names in the mix after a strong 2026 season with the Diamondbacks, when he worked 67 innings and put up a 2.42 ERA while showing the kind of underlying numbers that tend to get attention from teams in need of late-inning help.

What makes the fit interesting is also what makes it complicated. Loisiga is expected to draw a multi-year major league deal, which puts the Pirates right back at the same crossroads they often face when trying to add meaningful pitching depth. The talent is there, and the need is obvious, but any real pursuit will have to be weighed against payroll limits before the front office decides how aggressive it wants to be. [Read more 🡒]