The Pittsburgh Pirates are heading toward an arbitration bill that will force a simple question: when the young talent finally gets expensive, does ownership actually step up?
MLB Trade Rumors projects 10 arbitration-eligible players for the Pirates in 2027, with combined salaries totaling $28.7 million. By Pittsburgh’s historically modest payroll standards, that’s a hefty number. But it’s also the kind of cost that comes with building a contender, not a reason to back away from one.
Paul Skenes tops the list at a projected $7.2 million, a figure that would put him close to the record for a first-year arbitration-eligible pitcher. Even after what the source describes as a less dominant 2026 season, Skenes remains one of the most valuable young arms in the game, and that salary still looks like a bargain for a pitcher of his caliber.
Oneil Cruz is next at a projected $6.3 million, nearly doubling his $3.3 million salary from 2026. Nick Gonzales is projected at $3.1 million, while Spencer Horwitz checks in at $2.5 million and Jared Jones at $2.1 million.
Not every case is as clean-cut. Endy Rodríguez is projected for $1.2 million despite another injury-shortened season that ended with hip surgery. Henry Davis is projected at $1.4 million after another disappointing offensive year, though his work behind the plate still carries value.
Rafael Flores Jr.’s emergence gives Pittsburgh more room to maneuver at catcher, which makes the Rodríguez and Davis numbers easier to absorb. Horwitz’s projected $2.5 million also creates an interesting call after an inconsistent, injury-affected season.
Pirates have until November, before the lockout, to decide whether to tender contracts to those arbitration-eligible players. And while there’s a reasonable case that all 10 should get deals, that alone wouldn’t mean the Pirates are suddenly acting aggressively. It would simply mean they’re keeping together the roster they already have.
That’s the larger issue here. Pittsburgh finished 2026 at 82-80, its first winning season since 2018, but still missed the postseason. The pitching core gives the organization real reason for optimism, but the offense faded badly in the second half, exposing holes that can’t be ignored.
The Pirates also have money coming off the books with Brandon Lowe, Marcell Ozuna and Gregory Soto among the players leaving. That should create chances to address obvious needs, whether that’s replacing Lowe’s production, adding another dependable starter or strengthening the bullpen.
Those problems won’t get easier as Skenes, Cruz, Jones and the rest of the young core move closer to free agency. For a club that has spent years rebuilding, paying its own players more should be a sign that the plan is working, not a cue to stop spending elsewhere.
Bob Nutting and the Pirates have said plenty of times that they want a sustainable winner. Now the bill is arriving. The only question left is whether they treat it like the cost of doing business - or another reason to stay cheap.
In Other News...
Pirates Rotation Just Made One Offseason Need Impossible To Ignore
The Pirates rotation has gotten by with a solid, if unspectacular, profile, but the shape of the group is becoming hard to miss. Pittsburghs 2026 starting five is all right-handed, and with the staff sitting around the middle of the league in several pitching metrics, the offseason conversation is starting to point toward balance as much as upside. Given how PNC Park can play for pitchers, the fit seems obvious enough: the next step may be less about chasing another power arm and more about finding a different look.
Jason Mackeys read on the situation is straightforward, and it puts the front office in a lane it probably cant ignore. He sees Pittsburgh needing a soft-tossing lefty to deepen the rotation and make better use of the ballpark, with a free-agent market that includes names such as Shota Imanaga, Matthew Boyd, Foster Griffin, David Peterson and Eric Lauer. The Pirates do not need to overhaul the staff, but if they want the rotation to be more than middle-of-the-pack, this is the kind of need that tends to rise quickly from nice-to-have to must-address. [Read more 🡒]