Pirates May Have An Opening In Brandon Lowe Battle

The Yankees' pursuit of Jazz Chisholm Jr. could open the door for the Pirates to retain Brandon Lowe despite stiff competition.

The Yankees may have just given the Pirates a little breathing room in the Brandon Lowe chase.

Pittsburgh’s offseason plan starts with keeping Lowe, and the club already tried to protect that goal by tagging him with the qualifying offer. The idea wasn’t really to bank on him accepting it; it was to make life harder for everyone else by attaching draft-pick cost to the pursuit. That strategy matters because Lowe is exactly the kind of second baseman plenty of teams could use, and the Pirates do not have the kind of financial muscle to win a bidding war if the market gets aggressive.

New York looked like one of the biggest threats. The Yankees know Lowe well from his years with the Tampa Bay Rays, and they have the kind of resources that can make a race ugly fast.

But Jim Bowden’s report from last week’s General Manager Meetings in Las Vegas may have changed the picture. In his column for The Athletic, Bowden said the Yankees are open to a reunion with Jazz Chisholm Jr., which could take some heat off the Pirates in the Lowe sweepstakes.

That doesn’t mean New York is out on Lowe completely. Bowden also connected the Yankees to Luis Arraez, so this is not a clean pivot with the second-base market suddenly solved. And there was already some tension between the team and Chisholm Jr. last season, with his defensive mistakes in the ALDS standing out as especially costly.

Even with a payroll north of $300 million, the Yankees have been described as “budget conscious” in recent years. They haven’t been operating like the Mets or Dodgers, and they’re also carrying several expensive contracts already. That makes every new addition matter, especially if they’re trying to address multiple spots at once.

Right now, the bullpen appears to be New York’s top priority. The Yankees are chasing a reunion with old friend David Bednar, are expected to be heavily involved in the Adrian Morejon chase, and are also looking at other relief options, including bringing back Paul Blackburn.

With several openings in that group, they may not stop at one arm. They could wind up with one, two, or all three.

That kind of spending can add up quickly. If the Yankees pour serious money into the bullpen, second base could become the place where they look for a cheaper answer.

Chisholm Jr. would fit that lane after a down year in which he hit .231/.312/.399, struck out 29.5% of the time, and still finished with 41 stolen bases. Bowden noted that New York is open to bringing him back, and the idea of getting the “best” version of Jazz remains part of the appeal.

For the Pirates, that matters. They still have competition for the 2026 Silver Slugger nominee, but if the Yankees truly step back from Lowe, one of the biggest financial threats in the market could be gone. That would leave Pittsburgh a step closer to the reunion it wants most.

In Other News...

Pirates Face A Brandon Lowe Decision That Could Define Their Winter

Brandon Lowes decision to turn down Pittsburghs qualifying offer puts the Pirates right at the center of one of their biggest offseason questions. The club had put a one-year deal worth $23.15 million on the table, a figure that would have set a franchise salary record, but Lowe is clearly looking for the kind of longer-term security that changes a winter plan in a hurry.

For Pittsburgh, the move leaves the door open but also raises the stakes, because Lowe remains one of the more attractive free-agent options on the market and is drawing interest from multiple teams. The Pirates can still try to keep him in the mix, but now they have to weigh whether to stretch for a player of his caliber or pivot before the market tightens around them. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Just Sent A Clear Message About Two Young Prospects

The Pirates made their intentions clear ahead of the Rule 5 Draft deadline, adding outfielder Mitch Jebb and catcher/first baseman Axiel Plaz to the 40-man roster to keep both young players out of reach for other clubs. It was a straightforward move, but one that says plenty about how the organization views two prospects who have each put themselves on the radar in different ways.

Jebb, a 2023 draft pick, has spent most of his time in center field and recently worked back from a thumb injury, while Plaz boosted his stock with a strong season at High-A Greensboro as a right-handed power bat. For a Pirates system that continues to lean on internal development, protecting both players was as much about preserving depth as it was about rewarding progress. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Face A Tough Young Talent Decision They Can't Afford To Miss

The Pirates are approaching one of the quieter but more consequential dates on the offseason calendar, with a November 17 deadline to decide which minor leaguers belong on the 40-man roster and which ones they are willing to leave exposed to the Rule 5 Draft on December 9. It is the kind of roster crunch that forces a front office to weigh present depth against future upside, and for Pittsburgh, the list of possible protections includes a handful of names that have pushed themselves into the conversation.

Outfielders Lonnie White Jr. and Mitch Jebb, right-hander Derek Diamond and catcher Axiel Plaz are among the prospects being considered, each for different reasons tied to recent performance and long-term potential. The Pirates have to balance those evaluations against their own roster needs, and the next few days will reveal how aggressively they plan to shield that young talent from other clubs looking for an opportunity in the Rule 5 Draft. [Read more 🡒]