Pirates May Be Running Out Of Time To Keep Brandon Lowe

Brandon Lowe's potential departure intensifies the Pittsburgh Pirates' struggles amid fierce competition and pressing deadlines.

The Pirates wanted Brandon Lowe back. Now they’re staring at a free-agent market that keeps getting uglier by the day.

What looked like a tough decision has turned into a crowded chase, with MLB Network’s Jon Paul Morosi reporting that more than half a dozen teams are in on Lowe. The list includes the New York Yankees, Toronto Blue Jays and, in a twist that has to sting in Pittsburgh, the Tampa Bay Rays - the club that traded him away.

That only makes life harder for Ben Cherington and the Pirates, who are trying to hold on to their most productive offensive player while the rest of the league circles. Pittsburgh already knew Lowe would draw interest after he turned down the team’s $23.15 million qualifying offer earlier this week, but the growing number of suitors raises the stakes even more.

Lowe’s case is easy to understand. He hit .260 with 35 home runs and 96 RBI, won his first Silver Slugger Award and made major strides defensively at second base. At 32, he has set himself up for a multiyear deal, and the market now looks ready to reward him.

For the Pirates, the frustrating part is how quickly this has shifted from hopeful to precarious. They acquired Lowe last offseason in a three-team trade that also brought Mason Montgomery and Jake Mangum to Pittsburgh, and he immediately delivered one of the best seasons of his career. He helped lift an offense that had been among baseball’s worst, giving the Pirates exactly the kind of impact bat they were desperate to find.

Now they may lose him after one season.

The Rays’ involvement adds another layer of aggravation, even if interest doesn’t always translate into a serious bid. Still, Pittsburgh was already dealing with competition from the Yankees and Blue Jays. With Tampa Bay and several other clubs now in the mix, Lowe has more paths to a strong offer than ever.

Cherington said during the GM meetings last week that the Pirates remained in contact with Lowe and his representatives. He also said the team didn’t push extension talks during the season because the timing didn’t feel right while the club was in a playoff push.

That explanation makes sense on one level. But it also left Pittsburgh heading into the offseason without much leverage beyond Lowe’s familiarity with the organization.

And the Pirates can’t afford to let this drag on without a backup plan. They need offense whether Lowe stays or goes, and losing their home run leader would only sharpen that need for a lineup that faded after its strong first half. The clock matters too, with a possible MLB lockout beginning December 2 and the chance for real movement narrowing as that date approaches.

Cherington doesn’t have to settle this overnight. But he does need a plan that doesn’t rely on waiting around for Lowe to make a decision.

Pittsburgh can set its number, make its best offer and keep moving on other options. What it can’t do is sit back and hope the market somehow cools off.

The Pirates found a player who changed their offense. They may have done it only to watch him walk away after one season, perhaps even back to the team that let him go in the first place.

In Other News...

Pirates May Finally Fix One Lineup Flaw At A Real Cost

The Pirates have spent plenty of time this winter looking for a way to balance out a lineup that can still use more right-handed thump, and Casey Schmitt has surfaced as a possible fit. The Giants infielder is coming off a strong 2026 season and has shown he can handle left-handed pitching, which is exactly the sort of skill set that can help a roster built around matchup advantages rather than pure star power.

Getting him, though, would not come cheaply. Pittsburgh is said to be weighing whether Carmen Mlodzinski is the kind of pitcher it can afford to move, and that is no small decision for a club that values his ability to work both as a starter and out of the bullpen. The talks are still speculative, but they underscore the same familiar front-office dilemma: whether to spend from an area of depth to patch a lineup flaw that has lingered too long. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Fans Are Revisiting The Johan Oviedo Trade For One Reason

The Johan Oviedo trade tree is back in the conversation, and for Pirates fans it is easy to see why. Boston moved the right-hander to Arizona for lefty Luke Dotson and a player to be named later after Oviedo had appeared in only one game for the Red Sox, which naturally sent attention back to the original deal that brought him out of Pittsburgh.

What makes this one worth revisiting from the Pirates side is the prospect haul they received in return, Jhostynxon Garcia and Jesus Travieso, and the way those pieces are being measured against what Oviedo has done since changing hands. It is the kind of transaction that can look very different over time depending on development, health and opportunity, and this latest move has only sharpened the debate about who got the better end of it. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Third Base Search Just Got A Complicated Astros Twist

The Pirates search for help at third base has already been a familiar offseason theme, but Josh Harrison added a new wrinkle when he floated Jeremy Pea as a possible fit on a podcast. It is the kind of suggestion that makes sense on paper for Pittsburgh: Pea would bring right-handed balance, postseason experience, speed and a contact-oriented approach to a lineup that could use all of it.

The complication is that landing a player like Pea is never just about fit. Houstons priorities would shape any conversation, and Peas impending free agency only adds another layer of uncertainty for a Pirates front office trying to plan carefully. There is also the broader backdrop of a looming lockout, which could make any trade talks even harder to navigate as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]