The Pittsburgh Pirates got out of Saturday with only one run charged to them after one of the messiest defensive stretches of their season against the St. Louis Cardinals. That was the escape.
The bigger story is that the sequence fit a pattern the Pirates have spent much of 2026 repeating: giving opponents extra outs and making simple plays far harder than they need to be.
The trouble began in the seventh inning when Jacob Gonzalez let a ground ball slip straight through his legs. The next batter brought another grounder Gonzalez should have turned into a double play, but he booted that one too. Then Oneil Cruz added to the chaos by whiffing on a catch while trying to build momentum for a throw before he had actually secured the ball.
This has been an unthinkably bad defensive inning.
- Colin Beazley (@colin_beazley) August 29, 2026
Three plays. Three errors. Only one run crossed the plate.
Pittsburgh can breathe a little easier about surviving that inning, but the larger issue is impossible to ignore. The Pirates are now tied for the major-league lead with 90 errors, a huge number for a team that opened the season with playoff expectations. This is not a rebuilding club anymore, where sloppy defense can be brushed aside as part of the learning curve.
Instead, the Pirates keep sabotaging themselves in the moments that should already be over. Saturday’s seventh inning was just the most concentrated version of a season-long problem.
Cruz’s error stood out because it felt so avoidable. He seemed to be thinking ahead to the throw before finishing the catch, a move that captured the way Pittsburgh has played too often this year: athletic, aggressive, and too often undone by the basic stuff.
That matters even more when the rest of the margin is thin. A team that already struggles to score cannot afford to hand out extra chances. A pitching staff trying to protect close leads should not be forced to work through four, five, or even six outs in one inning.
The Pirates were fortunate this time. Three straight errors somehow turned into only one run, not a total disaster. But 90 errors tell the story of a problem that has been there all season.
If Pittsburgh wants to act like a contender, tightening up the defense cannot be treated like an offseason item on a to-do list. Playoff teams already have enough trouble getting 27 outs. The Pirates need to stop volunteering for more.
In Other News...
Pirates Just Got A New Opening In The NL Central Race
The Cardinals September push took a hit when they placed rookie infielder JJ Wetherholt on the 10-day injured list with right wrist tendinitis, a setback for a player who had become one of their more important contributors and a legitimate NL Rookie of the Year candidate. For Pittsburgh, the timing matters because the Pirates are still hanging around in the NL Central race and have spent enough of the season looking up at St. Louis that any disruption in the division picture is worth noticing.
It also comes at a moment when the Pirates could be getting a boost of their own, with Konnor Griffin close to returning from injury. If that happens, Pittsburgh would not only be watching a rival lose a key piece, but potentially adding help at the same time, which is exactly the kind of late-season swing that can keep a clubs playoff hopes alive a little longer. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Drew A Hard Line With Carmen Mlodzinski For A Reason
Ketel Martes unexplained absence for the Diamondbacks put a familiar baseball issue back in the spotlight: what happens when a player is not where the club expects him to be. For the Pirates, it brings back the earlier case of Carmen Mlodzinski, who was sent to the restricted list after refusing to pitch out of the bullpen following his move out of the starting rotation, even though he did at least keep the team informed.
The difference in those situations matters to Pittsburgh, which made a point of drawing a hard line on availability. Mlodzinskis frustration was real, but the Pirates still chose to enforce the standard that a player has to be ready to fill the role the club asks of him, and that stance is part of why the episode resonated beyond one pitchers disappointment. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates September Push Rests On Three Slumping Contributors
With 24 games left, the Pirates are entering September with no room for their margin of error to shrink any further. A postseason push is going to depend not just on the usual core carrying the load, but on a few important contributors finding their form again after a rough stretch.
Bryan Reynolds, Mitch Jones and Spencer Horwitz have all been part of the problem in recent months, with Reynolds and Horwitz slipping at the plate and Jones dealing with pitching issues after surgery. If Pittsburgh is going to make the final month interesting, it needs those familiar names to look more like themselves and give the club a much-needed lift when every game starts to feel like a swing game. [Read more 🡒]