The Cardinals made their move on Friday, locking up rookie infielder JJ Wetherholt on an eight-year, $112.5 million contract extension that could climb to $132 million with performance bonuses. It’s the kind of deal that tells you St. Louis sees a long runway ahead for one of its young cornerstones.
But for the Pirates, the extension landed with a different kind of punch. It was also a reminder of how close the 2024 MLB Draft came to breaking another way.
Wetherholt went seventh overall to St. Louis, two picks before Pittsburgh grabbed Konnor Griffin at No.
- And per Noah Hiles of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the Cardinals had at least considered taking Griffin themselves.
The twist is the part that makes the whole thing feel even more surreal: St. Louis was exploring Griffin as a pitcher.
That detail matters because Griffin was one of the most intriguing players in that draft class thanks to his two-way ability. Pittsburgh ultimately chased the upside that made him so appealing as a shortstop and center fielder, but that only became possible because the board kept breaking the Pirates’ way.
The first six picks set the stage. Cleveland, Cincinnati, Colorado and Oakland passed on Griffin.
Chicago took Arkansas left-hander Hagen Smith at No. 5, and that’s when Pittsburgh started to sense Griffin might actually slide. Kansas City and St.
Louis had both shown interest, but the Royals went with Jac Caglianone and the Cardinals chose Wetherholt. Then the Angels took Christian Moore at No.
That left Griffin for the Pirates.
Now, two years later, the contrast is impossible to miss. Wetherholt has quickly looked like the real thing in St.
Louis, putting together an above-average offensive season and becoming one of the best defensive second basemen in the game. The Cardinals have responded by paying him like a player they expect to build around.
Griffin has forced a similar conversation in Pittsburgh. His fast rise through the minors and early major league success led the Pirates to hand him a nine-year, $140 million extension, a clear sign they view him as one of the centerpieces of their push toward sustained contention.
Pittsburgh deserves credit for recognizing Griffin’s talent and acting when he fell into range. But there was luck in the equation too.
The Cardinals were in the mix. They were only two picks ahead.
And they saw Griffin differently than the Pirates did.
St. Louis got its franchise infielder. Pittsburgh believes it got something even rarer.
In Other News...
Pirates Make Another Pitching Move With Bigger Questions Still Looming
The Pirates kept tinkering with their pitching depth by bringing Antwone Kelly and Thomas Harrington back into the major league mix, another reminder that the staff is still very much a work in progress. Kelly has already gotten a look in the big leagues this season, while Harrington is back in position to help at the top level as the organization keeps searching for more stability on the mound.
Even with those moves, the bigger picture around Pittsburghs pitching plan is still unsettled. The front office is weighing whether to make a more meaningful addition before the trade deadline, and the draft could also become part of the answer if the Pirates decide to use valuable picks as trade currency to help the rotation and bullpen now. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates May Have A Surprising Option At Fifth Overall
With the 2026 MLB Draft still months away, the Pirates are already being tied to a few different directions at No. 5 overall. Most mock drafts have Pittsburgh leaning toward UCSB right-hander Jackson Flora, but the early conversation is broader than one arm, with Georgia Tech catcher Vahn Lackey and Mississippi prep outfielder Eric Booth Jr. also drawing attention as the draft picture starts to take shape.
For a club trying to balance immediate upside with long-term development, the fifth pick could come down to what kind of player the front office wants to bet on. Flora fits the profile of a polished college pitcher, while Booth offers the sort of younger, higher-risk ceiling that can appeal in the top half of the first round. The Pirates still have time before July 11-12, but the range of names already in play suggests this pick may not be as straightforward as it first looked. [Read more 🡒]