The Pirates don’t need September roster expansion to become a month-long audition. They need it to help them win, and that’s why the two obvious calls are Jack Brannigan and Khristian Curtis.
Beginning Sept. 1, rosters grow from 26 to 28 players, with clubs allowed to carry 14 pitchers instead of 13. For Pittsburgh, those extra spots should eventually go to Brannigan and Curtis, even if the timing on one of them isn’t perfectly clean.
On the position-player side, Konnor Griffin makes the picture a little messy - but only for the moment. The Pirates still have their rookie shortstop’s return listed as early September while he continues ramping up baseball activities after tearing the sagittal band in his left ring finger.
That’s exactly why Brannigan makes sense now. Pittsburgh has already brought him up several times this season and has somehow managed to give him just one major-league at-bat. At this point, that tells the Pirates almost nothing about a 25-year-old prospect who is already on the 40-man roster and whose best trait lines up with an immediate need.
Brannigan is a real shortstop. MLB Pipeline gives him 60 grades for both his arm and fielding and says he can play outstanding defense at the position.
The bat is still the question mark. He’s hitting .218 with 14 home runs and a .766 OPS in the minors this season, and strikeouts have long been a concern.
Still, there’s no downside to finding out more.
No one is arguing Brannigan should stay ahead of Griffin once the rookie is healthy. Griffin takes the shortstop job right back. But until that happens, Pittsburgh doesn’t gain much by keeping Brannigan in the Indianapolis shuttle cycle without letting him actually play.
The pitching side is even more straightforward. Curtis has already made two big-league appearances this year and has thrown eight scoreless innings while allowing only two hits. One of those outings came Sunday against the Dodgers, when he worked three scoreless innings before the Pirates sent him back down again in their ongoing search for a fresh bullpen arm.
Curtis also offers something the Pirates can use: length. With Mitch Keller done for the season, Carmen Mlodzinski not giving them innings consistently, and the club trying different ways to cover the back end of the rotation, Curtis can fill multiple roles.
He can bulk, piggyback, or spot start. For a team still trying to squeeze whatever it can from its playoff chances, those innings matter.
There is one catch. Because Curtis was optioned Aug. 25, he normally has to spend 15 days in the minors before coming back unless he’s replacing an injured player. September expansion does not wipe out that rule.
So Curtis might not be the first move on Sept. 1.
But he should be the arm in that expanded spot as soon as he’s eligible. Pittsburgh can use someone else there for the short term and then make the switch.
Brannigan gives them defense and a true shortstop while Griffin finishes his rehab. Curtis has already shown he can retire major-league hitters and handle multiple innings. That’s enough reason to make both promotions obvious.
In Other News...
Spencer Horwitz Has Become A Real Problem For The Pirates Lineup
Spencer Horwitz came back into the Pirates lineup on Aug. 2 after missing 33 games with a left hamstring injury and a concussion, but the offense has not gotten the lift it hoped for. Instead, his return has been part of a broader slide for a club whose second-half production has tailed off, leaving far too much pressure on the middle of the order to carry the load.
Horwitz has admitted he has not been at his best since rejoining the group, and the timing has only made the slump feel heavier. With Pittsburgh still trying to stay in the playoff race, the bigger concern is no longer just one hitter finding his timing, but whether the lineup as a whole can start producing enough to make the push matter. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Face A Telling Decision On A Power Bat They Need
The waiver wire has put Eugenio Surez back into the spotlight, and that matters for a Pirates club that has been looking for more right-handed punch in the middle of its lineup. Cincinnatis decision to place the veteran third baseman on outright waivers opens a 48-hour window for interested teams, and Pittsburgh is among the clubs weighing whether the fit makes enough sense to act quickly. Surez has been better since the All-Star break, which only adds to the appeal for a team still searching for offense.
For the Pirates, the question is less about talent than timing and commitment. Any claiming club would take on the rest of Surezs salary, which is just under $3 million, a manageable cost for a player who could deepen the lineup and potentially stabilize a corner-infield spot. Whether Pittsburgh sees enough reason to move now, though, will come down to how it values the bat against the risk of adding another piece before the waiver clock runs out. [Read more 🡒]
Oneil Cruz Is Making The Pirates Ask What Might Have Been
Oneil Cruz gave the Pirates a familiar flash of why he matters so much to everything they try to build. Back from injury, he homered against Mason Miller and helped push Pittsburgh to a 1-0 win, a reminder that even in a season defined by missed time, his bat can still change the mood of a game in one swing.
Cruz has still managed to put together a strong 2026 season, hitting .257 with an .833 OPS, 17 home runs, 22 stolen bases and 52 RBIs in 72 games despite the fractures in his left hand that kept him out for a stretch. That production only sharpens the question around the Pirates now, because when a player with that kind of power and speed is healthy, the missed opportunities start to feel even bigger. [Read more 🡒]