The Pirates have a chance this winter to chase more than just bullpen depth. They could go after a familiar arm who has turned into one of the Yankees’ most reliable late-inning weapons: David Bednar.
Bednar is a free agent after this season, and the case for Pittsburgh bringing him back is built on more than nostalgia. The former Pirates right-hander, who grew up in the Pittsburgh area, has been outstanding since the Pirates sent him to New York at the 2025 deadline.
In 86 appearances with the Yankees, Bednar has gone 11-3 with a 2.39 ERA over 94.0 innings, piling up 111 strikeouts against 29 walks. He has also posted a 1.01 WHIP and a .193 BAA. In save situations, he has been even more valuable, locking down 45 of 52 chances, including 35 of 39 in 2026.
His first full season in the Bronx was just as sharp. Bednar finished 2026 at 7-3 with a 2.47 ERA in 64 outings, throwing 69.1 innings with 76 strikeouts and 20 walks. He also carried a .205 BAA and a 1.04 WHIP.
One of the biggest reasons for the jump was a pitch change. Bednar leaned on the splitter instead of the four-seam fastball he featured more heavily in Pittsburgh.
That adjustment paid off in a major way. The splitter produced a +14 run value, the best mark of any pitcher in baseball and tied for the 17th-most for any pitch this season, according to Baseball Savant.
The underlying numbers back it up, too. Bednar sat in the 99th percentile in chase percentage at 38.4% and graded in the 70th percentile or better in other advanced categories. He also ranked in the top 10% in expected slugging percentage (.309), weighted on-base average (.249) and expected weighted on-base average (.263).
He has not only been dominant in the regular season. Bednar also logged postseason work for the Yankees, putting up a 1.50 ERA across five games and six innings in 2025, then adding two scoreless appearances in 2026.
For the Pirates, the fit is about impact, not just sentiment. Their bullpen improved by the end of the season, but that does not mean the front office should be done adding. Left-hander Mason Montgomery emerged as the club’s ninth-inning arm and was the best relief pitcher in baseball over the final two months, allowing only three runs, all in one outing.
That gives Pittsburgh flexibility. Bednar would not have to walk back in as the only closer option. He could form a late-inning tandem with Montgomery and give the Pirates a second answer in the ninth, whether the matchup calls for a right-hander or a left-hander.
He would also join right-hander Luke Weaver, who arrived at the 2026 trade deadline from the New York Mets, as another high-leverage piece. Put those three together, and the Pirates would have one of the better late-inning groups in the game.
That kind of bullpen could swing wins, and wins are what Pittsburgh needs if it wants to get back to the postseason for the first time since 2015. Bednar never got much team success during his first run with the Pirates, but a return in 2027 would give him a chance to help bring winning baseball back to his hometown.
In Other News...
Pirates Face A Costly Rotation Decision Fans Can't Ignore
The Pirates offseason could turn quickly from evaluation to hard choices, and Mitch Keller sits at the center of it. The right-hander is coming off a rough stretch after an injury, and with a five-year extension already on the books, his deal now carries heavier salary obligations in the later years. For a club that has spent the past season leaning on a promising young rotation, the question is no longer whether Keller has value, but whether that value still fits the rest of the roster.
Pittsburgh has reason to believe it can cover innings in other ways, whether by turning to cheaper arms or giving another rookie a larger role. That kind of depth makes Keller easier to discuss in trade terms, even if moving him would mean giving up a pitcher who was supposed to be part of the long-term core. The challenge for the Pirates is balancing present performance with future payroll, and Kellers contract makes that decision even harder to avoid. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Can't Afford One Costly Winter Mistake Again
The Pirates got to 82-80 in 2026, a mark that still says as much about how far theyve come as how far they have to go. It was their fifth winning season in 34 years, yet the postseason drought now stretches back to 2015, which is why this winter matters so much more than a typical roster tune-up.
Pittsburgh has reason to believe the foundation is sturdier than it used to be, with a young rotation and a bullpen that has taken a real step forward. But the front office has also lived through enough mixed results to know the margin for error is thin, and with a possible MLB lockout looming, the challenge is not just adding talent but keeping it in place, especially with key players like Brandon Lowe needing attention after an offseason that was more helpful than perfect. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Could Be Facing An Uncomfortable Oscar Marin What-If
Oscar Marins next stop could put the Pirates in an awkward spot. The former Pittsburgh pitching coach is now in the mix to become the Cincinnati Reds next pitching coach after Derek Johnsons departure, a development that brings his name back into the division conversation not long after the Pirates chose not to retain him following the 2025 season.
Marins case in Cincinnati has only grown stronger since he took over as the Reds bullpen coach and helped manage the staff during Johnsons personal leave. For the Pirates, it is the kind of what-if that lingers because their pitching groups performed well under his watch, and a promotion elsewhere would only sharpen the question of why that run in Pittsburgh ended when it did. [Read more 🡒]