The Pirates don’t usually dive headfirst into free agency, but this offseason still calls for some targeted shopping. With a projected payroll of $100 million - including salaries and arbitration/pre-arbitration and with no new additions - Pittsburgh has room to make a few sensible moves without chasing the top of the market.
That’s the lane the Pirates should stay in: useful, affordable pieces who fit obvious needs. And there are three free agents who check that box.
One of the clearest priorities is a hard-throwing right-handed reliever who can handle high-leverage innings. Bryan Abreu fits that description as well as anyone. He’s spent the past six seasons with the Houston Astros and has been one of the better bullpen arms in baseball over that stretch.
Abreu also has a familiar connection in Pittsburgh. He worked under Pirates pitching coach Bill Murphy from 2022 to 2025, and during that span he pitched the second-most innings, posted the sixth-best WAR at 6.0, the ninth-lowest ERA at 2.30 and the 10th-highest K/9 at 12.7 among relievers. His four-seam fastball and slider have driven that success, and his work with Murphy helped make him so effective in Houston.
There are some blemishes in the profile, though. Abreu’s walk rate was 15.3%, tied for the highest among relievers in baseball in 2026. He also allowed a 90.6 mph average exit velocity, which ranked in the seventh percentile, and a 41.5% hard-hit rate, good for the 24th percentile.
Even with those issues, the fit makes sense. Murphy could help get Abreu back to his best form in 2027, and the Pirates should be able to land him in the $10-$11 million range. He’d give Pittsburgh a strong late-inning trio alongside setup man Luke Weaver and closer Mason Montgomery.
Another area that needs attention is the infield, especially if the Pirates don’t bring back free agent second baseman Brandon Lowe. Edmundo Sosa stands out as a low-cost, versatile answer who can move around and defend multiple spots.
Sosa has handled second base, shortstop and third base well defensively, and he even logged time in left field this season. At the plate, he brings a right-handed bat that has done damage against lefties, hitting .290/.343/.492 for an .835 OPS in 2026.
That matters for Pittsburgh, which needs more production against left-handed pitching and better infield defense. Lowe was a Gold Glove Award finalist, and Sosa could help keep that level of play in place if he takes over at second. He could also slide to third base, another area of need for the Pirates.
The concern with Sosa is durability. He has topped 100 games in a season only twice over the last six years. Still, he wouldn’t cost much, and he’d give the Pirates a useful glove and a right-handed bat that can move around wherever needed.
The third target is another bullpen arm, this time from the left side. JoJo Romero would give Pittsburgh a southpaw with National League Central experience, having spent the past five seasons with the St. Louis Cardinals before going to the Milwaukee Brewers after the trade deadline in 2026.
Romero was part of the Brewers’ first World Series title this season and was excellent in the playoffs, putting up a 1.13 ERA over seven games with 11 strikeouts to one walk, a .107 BAA and a 0.50 WHIP.
He isn’t a power arm, but he gets by with weak contact and a strong groundball rate. The Pirates could use that, along with some added experience in the bullpen. Right now, Montgomery is the only sure left-hander for next season, though Evan Sisk and Brandon Eisert could also be in the mix.
Romero would give Pittsburgh a veteran left-handed option and a smart, practical addition to a bullpen that still needs more depth.
In Other News...
Pirates Risk Repeating A Costly Third Base Mistake This Offseason
Third base has been a problem spot for the Pirates for a while, and this offseason looks like another chance to decide whether they want to solve it with a bat, a glove or a little of both. Alec Bohm is one of the more intriguing free-agent names on the market because of his offensive upside, but his defensive metrics have been a concern, which puts Pittsburgh right back in the same debate it has faced before.
The market does not offer many clean answers, so the Pirates may have to choose between chasing a one-dimensional upgrade or taking a different route entirely. Re-signing Brandon Lowe and reshuffling the infield would give them another path, one that could help avoid repeating a costly mistake if they are not careful about how they balance production and defense at the position. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Right Field Battle Just Became Harder To Ignore
The Pirates search for stability in right field now has a little more shape to it, even if the job still looks open. General manager Ben Cherington said the club plans to keep Ryan OHearn mostly at first base and designated hitter, which takes one of the more familiar names out of the everyday outfield mix and pushes the competition back toward the younger options in camp and in the system.
Esmerlyn Valdez remains the most intriguing candidate to claim the position long term, but the Pirates want to see cleaner defense and fewer strikeouts before handing him that kind of responsibility. Jake Mangum is also in the mix for playing time, and the front office could still look for a right-handed bat to balance out Valdez and OHearn, leaving right field as one of the more interesting roster questions left to sort through. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Bullpen Search May Come Down To One Familiar Problem
The Pirates are already looking ahead to 2027, and one of the cleaner ways to shore up the bullpen could be a familiar one: shopping in free agency for a proven arm. Jonathan Loisiga is among the names in the mix after a strong 2026 season with the Diamondbacks, when he worked 67 innings and put up a 2.42 ERA while showing the kind of underlying numbers that tend to get attention from teams in need of late-inning help.
What makes the fit interesting is also what makes it complicated. Loisiga is expected to draw a multi-year major league deal, which puts the Pirates right back at the same crossroads they often face when trying to add meaningful pitching depth. The talent is there, and the need is obvious, but any real pursuit will have to be weighed against payroll limits before the front office decides how aggressive it wants to be. [Read more 🡒]
