There’s a particular kind of October pain that Pirates fans know all too well: watching other cities treat playoff baseball like an entitlement while Pittsburgh keeps waiting for its turn. On Tuesday afternoon, the Houston Astros somehow managed to make that feeling even sharper.
Houston opened its American League Wild Card Series against the Chicago White Sox at Daikin Park, but the scene was a long way from the usual postseason buzz. The announced crowd was 34,011 in a ballpark that holds nearly 41,000, and some of the fans who were there spent the early innings booing the home team. The Astros went on to lose 6-3, and several players were clearly bothered by the reception.
For Pirates fans, sympathy was never going to come easily.
The comparison is brutal. The Astros have made the postseason nine times in the past 10 seasons, reached four World Series in that span and won titles in 2017 and 2022. They also ran off seven straight American League Championship Series appearances from 2017 through 2023.
Pittsburgh’s recent October résumé looks nothing like that. The Pirates haven’t played a postseason game since 2015. They haven’t won a playoff series since 1979, which is also the last time they won the World Series.
That’s what made the atmosphere in Houston feel so out of touch from a Pirates point of view. One fan base has spent years living with meaningful baseball deep into the fall.
The other has spent that same stretch wishing for a team good enough to get there at all. Yet the boos came from the city that’s had the better part of a decade of October relevance.
To be fair, Houston didn’t give its crowd much reason to cheer. The Astros fell behind 3-0 in the second inning and were down 5-0 by the fifth. Bennett Sousa made things worse in the seventh, spiking a pair of breaking balls and drawing another round of boos.
Sousa, who used to pitch for the White Sox, didn’t hold back afterward.
"The fans here are definitely spoiled," Sousa told The Athletic, referencing Houston's sustained postseason success. He also suggested the atmosphere would have been considerably louder had the game been played in Chicago.
Christian Walker also voiced frustration with the crowd, saying the players needed support instead of negativity.
There’s truth on both sides of that argument. Players want energy from the stands, especially in the playoffs.
Fans want better baseball than what Houston showed Tuesday. And a weekday afternoon start doesn’t exactly make it easy to pack a stadium.
But there’s still a line between holding a team accountable and acting like a playoff appearance is supposed to come with guaranteed celebration.
That’s where the Pirates angle gets especially galling. Pittsburgh finished the regular season at 82-80, good for its first winning season since 2018.
Houston finished 81-81 and became the first division champion in a full-length MLB season without a winning record. The Astros still won the AL West and got a home playoff series.
The Pirates finished third in the NL Central and stayed home.
If Pittsburgh’s 82-80 record had been enough to win its division the way it would have in the 2026 AL West standings, the Pirates would be playing October baseball right now.
That doesn’t mean the Pirates belonged in the postseason simply because they had one more win than Houston. They didn’t navigate their own division well enough to get there. But the contrast is still hard to miss.
Pirates fans have spent years living through losing seasons, failed rebuilds, questionable roster decisions and an ownership group that has repeatedly fallen short of delivering a consistent winner. They’d love nothing more than to see Paul Skenes, Jared Jones and the rest of that young core playing a home playoff game.
Instead, Houston fans got the chance Tuesday, and what stood out most was the emptiness and the boos.
In Other News...
Former Pirate Joe Musgrove Just Got A Painful October Reminder
Joe Musgroves return to a major league mound finally arrived Tuesday night in San Diego, and it came with the kind of October stage that can make every pitch feel heavier. In the Padres 8-0 win over the Cubs in the National League Wild Card Series, the former Pirate got into the game in the ninth inning and finished off a scoreless frame, striking out the final batter while working around two hits and a walk.
For Pittsburgh fans who watched Musgrove develop into a dependable arm before moving on, the appearance was a reminder of how long his road back had been. Nearly two years had passed since his last major league pitching appearance, and the comeback has taken him through Tommy John surgery and more than one setback before he could get back in front of a postseason crowd. [Read more 🡒]
Ben Cheringtons Pirates Problem Is Showing Up On Playoff Rosters
Several familiar names from recent Pirates lineups are still around October baseball, just not in the same roles they had in Pittsburgh. Rowdy Tellez, Tommy Pham, Bryan De La Cruz and Isiah Kiner-Falefa have all surfaced on MLB playoff rosters, but as bench or reserve pieces for contenders that can afford to use them in supporting roles rather than leaning on them every day.
For the Pirates, that difference goes to the heart of Ben Cheringtons roster-building problem. Pittsburgh spent recent seasons asking too much of players who, on better teams, fit more naturally as complementary depth, and the result is a club that finished with a winning record in 2026 but still stayed home when the postseason began. The drought rolls on, and the sight of those former regulars in October only sharpens the question of whether the Pirates have been miscast by the very pieces they were counting on. [Read more 🡒]
Nick Gonzales Just Became A Real Pirates Offseason Dilemma
Nick Gonzales gave the Pirates plenty to like at the plate in 2026, but his work at third base left the club with a tougher question than it would prefer heading into the offseason. He logged the worst defensive metrics among third basemen with significant playing time, turning what looked like a useful infield solution into one of Pittsburghs more complicated roster discussions.
Ben Cherington and Don Kelly have not settled on where Gonzales fits defensively going forward, and that conversation is still playing out in offseason exit meetings. The Pirates know the offense was real, but the challenge now is figuring out whether the bat is best served by keeping him at third or moving him somewhere that better protects both him and the club. [Read more 🡒]